very interesting age old battle
i agree with everything you say, amibitiouslemon...good points
i will play devil's advocate for one moment
i have a technical certification and an associate's degree (liberal arts) and a bachelor's degree (business), i am a computer science teacher, and i am working on a graduate degree in computer science/engineering as well as another technical certification...when it is all over i will hopefully have my phd in computer engineering and my mcse
however, before i even got my first set of letters behind my name, i was in the working world for 16 years...a customer of mine was the co-founder of sun microsystems and he dropped out of school in the first year...silicon valley and the high tech industry is built on computers (by non-degreed steve jobs, then non-degreed steve wozniak) and non-degreed mike dell...it it built on software with non-degreed bill gates, larry ellison, and paul allen...and it is still hopefully built around the internet and commerce (non-degreed shawn fanning)...now these non-degreed people were and are not idiots by any stretch of the imagination and being from northern california, i don't think i just mentioned fly-by-nights here...bill gates came to our local college and talked and no one took him seriously because software was not yet a force in the IT industry but nobody cared if he had a degree or not, we just knew he was a multi-millionaire at the time...in silicon valley, money talks louder than degrees or certifications
but since i do understand the research side of IT since i worked at autodesk and some other companies, many of the products that those above mentioned non-degreed people made trillions on did so on the shoulders of many of the world's bright phds who did the legwork on the motherboard, componenets, and developement...most of these people in the early days of silicon valley had their phds in either electrical/electronic engineering and mathenatics and for the most part, still do today and like yesteryear, they are the unsung heroes of silicon valley...and many, if not most of these brilliant mathematicians and engineers with phds do not speak english as their first language as i have met many from india and china
but when i recieve my graduate degree and have the best certification i can receive from microsoft, i will still realize that people who do not have letters behind their names are just as important in the IT field...my entire business clientele comes from being microsoft certified and one "man" in redmond washington with no degree could yank that away from me any second...bill gates almost did away with the entire concept of an IT certification because he thought it got in the way of speedy sales, his favorite topic
anyway, thanks for the comment and giving me something to say...the IT world is not so black and white as you will realize once you get in the working field of IT and sorry if i gave you the impression that education is a waste of time...i am also a teacher, but i mentioned that already (if i think education is a waste of time, then i just wasted away 14 semesters so far