Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iPad Retina

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Jan 6, 2013
762
66
Toronto
hello, I might be receiving a Mid-2015 macbook Pro 2.5GHz with the DGPU, should I sell it and wait for the 2016 model, will the Macbook Pro have a new design this year? What is the likely hood?

Thanks
 
I think it's likely that there will be a redesign, this wouldn't be the first thread about it.

However, past launches and chipset-availability indicate the MacBook Pro 15 might not come out until June-August or even later, so maybe hold on to your current machine until then if you should.
 
I think it's likely that there will be a redesign, this wouldn't be the first thread about it.

However, past launches and chipset-availability indicate the MacBook Pro 15 might not come out until June-August or even later, so maybe hold on to your current machine until then if you should.

I'm getting a replacement computer, due to so many repairs, two screen replacements, a left fan, and the logic board. Deciding if i should sell it, but it still needs to be approved
 
Nothing so far suggests a redesign, maybe some new ports and a new graphics card for the 15 inch but other than that all we know so far is skylake CPUs.

I would keep it and worry about what to do when the new one comes out (as mentioned above it could be months) it'll probably be more trouble than it's worth to swap unless you have a specific need the current 15inch doesn't meet.
 
I'm getting a replacement computer, due to so many repairs, two screen replacements, a left fan, and the logic board. Deciding if i should sell it, but it still needs to be approved
I got the same 2.5ghz w/ dGPU replacement for my base model 15" early 2013 rMBP that had tons of problems back in August last year. It's been a huge upgrade and i've been extremely happy with it. I would recommend you keep it.
 
I got the same 2.5ghz w/ dGPU replacement for my base model 15" early 2013 rMBP that had tons of problems back in August last year. It's been a huge upgrade and i've been extremely happy with it. I would recommend you keep it.
Which Early 2013 Model did you have what specs?
Getting a 2.5GHz but I have the 2.6GHz, I don't think it matters
 
Which Early 2013 Model did you have what specs?
Getting a 2.5GHz but I have the 2.6GHz, I don't think it matters

But your 2.6 is based on Ivy Bridge, while your replacement is based on Haswell.

According to geek bench, even the 2.2 Ghz 4770HQ in the current base model comfortably beats your old 3720QM. It's no match for the 2.5GHz 4870HQ in your replacement Mac.
 
Which Early 2013 Model did you have what specs?
Getting a 2.5GHz but I have the 2.6GHz, I don't think it matters
My original was a base model 15" early 2013 2.4GHz 256GB 1GB dGPU with an upgrade to 16GB of RAM I paid $200 for. My replacement is the high end 2.5GHz 512GB w/2GB discrete GPU. I paid nothing for the whole deal, except to get AppleCare again since it definitely came in handy on my previous one.
 
Do you guys think AppleCare is good in the long run? Never gotten AppleCare. Not even this one. They just asked me if your ok with replacing it.

I've heard horror story's and amazing story's
 
Do you guys think AppleCare is good in the long run? Never gotten AppleCare. Not even this one. They just asked me if your ok with replacing it.

I've heard horror story's and amazing story's

AppleCare is great! My old mid-2009 MBP developed a couple of problems that would always come back after I had it fixed, and Apple continued to repair it at no charge even after AppleCare expired. The only thing I have paid for on that machine is a new battery and a RAM upgrade I did myself! They also fixed a gummed up home button on my iPhone, replaced a lightening cable that bent, and replaced the battery in my iPhone 5 (even after AC+ expired, and at not charge!). I will always get AppleCare for my devices!!

As for waiting for a new model of MacBook Pro, good luck! I waited for the Haswell update, and it dragged on forever! Although the waiting thread was highly entertaining :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dydegu
AppleCare is great! My old mid-2009 MBP developed a couple of problems that would always come back after I had it fixed, and Apple continued to repair it at no charge even after AppleCare expired. The only thing I have paid for on that machine is a new battery and a RAM upgrade I did myself! They also fixed a gummed up home button on my iPhone, replaced a lightening cable that bent, and replaced the battery in my iPhone 5 (even after AC+ expired, and at not charge!). I will always get AppleCare for my devices!!

As for waiting for a new model of MacBook Pro, good luck! I waited for the Haswell update, and it dragged on forever! Although the waiting thread was highly entertaining :)
I've received many cable replacements due to it bubbling. And EarPods. The other day. I brought both of my chargers one is a 45W MagSafe 1 from a Late 2010 MacBook Air and they just replaced it. I was like do you need a serial number. They were like nope. Also have the mid-2012 MacBook Pro with retina. Replaced the 85W MagSafe 2 for free as well. Even though the warranty expired a really long time ago
 
Ugh. I'm in the same boat. So I just bought a 2015 15" rMBP (base model) because I got a hell of a deal on it. It's sitting in my house still shrink wrapped because I'm now thinking of waiting until March to see if a Skylake model is going to be introduced. I don't have buyers remorse because it's still a great machine, but I could probably sell it for more than I paid for it, but all this waiting feels like an exercise in futility.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dydegu
Ugh. I'm in the same boat. So I just bought a 2015 15" rMBP (base model) because I got a hell of a deal on it. It's sitting in my house still shrink wrapped because I'm now thinking of waiting until March to see if a Skylake model is going to be introduced. I don't have buyers remorse because it's still a great machine, but I could probably sell it for more than I paid for it, but all this waiting feels like an exercise in futility.
I know right. But at the same time j really need the computer and I alreday have a Soeck case for it. So debating.
 
I know right. But at the same time j really need the computer and I alreday have a Soeck case for it. So debating.
I would wait until the March event before deciding what to do. While I doubt there will be a redesign, the Skylake chips are looking good and might be worth waiting a month for.
 
I would wait until the March event before deciding what to do. While I doubt there will be a redesign, the Skylake chips are looking good and might be worth waiting a month for.
Agree..but anyone that has been dealing with the Skylake driver issues on Surface or HPs will tell you, be careful what you wish for :)
 
Skylake will have a 5-10% improvement in speed and a 5-10% improvement in battery life. The GPU is where they'll see the biggest boost.

Honestly, on the desktop side of things, folks aren't upgrading from Ivy Bridge or newer because it's really not worth it.
 
My 8GB 2013 MBA just had its display (and display housing) replaced by Applecare because of a display issue. Since the laptop now basically looks new, I am considering also replacing the lower case, and selling it and replace it by a 13" rMBP when the new ones come out. I think I could get a pretty good price for the MBA and since I get the UK 15% student discount (+free AppleCare) on new laptops I wouldn't have to spend that much to upgrade, maybe £250-300. I wouldn't normally consider doing this since I love my MBA but that would seem like a pretty good deal to upgrade a 3 year old laptop.

Obviously this is all speculative, but what are we thinking in terms of performance gain? I know Skylake CPU performance is not much greater than Haswell's, but what about the GPU? How much of an improvement v Intel HD 5000 Graphics?
 
I'm getting a replacement computer, due to so many repairs, two screen replacements, a left fan, and the logic board. Deciding if i should sell it, but it still needs to be approved

I'd keep the replacement. For 3 reasons.

1) You don't know when, or if, there will be a redesign.
2) You don't know if you'll like the redesign. (For example, they go completely USB-C)
3) You don't know if there will be potential bugs/issues with a rev1 product.
 
I'd keep the replacement. For 3 reasons.

1) You don't know when, or if, there will be a redesign.
2) You don't know if you'll like the redesign. (For example, they go completely USB-C)
3) You don't know if there will be potential bugs/issues with a rev1 product.

I'll add a few points

1) that's actually pretty easy to do based in part availability. Match should launch new 12" & 13" MacBooks both on Skylake. 15"s won't launch until September at best; why? Because there are no Skylake GTE-4 parts available. Given Iris Pro is needed to drive the retina displays that rules out both 15s. Apples metal API relies heavily on OpenCL which means it'll have another AMD GPU. Polaris won't arrive until the back-to-school period so again Q3-Q4. The ironic part is that by the time it launches it may be using Kaby Lake and skip Skylake entirely; we'll see.

2) there haven't been any leaked shells indicating a redesign so most likely it'll be new ports on the existing shell. USB-C and TB-3 are all but guaranteed

3) I don't buy that. The current 15" has way more bugs than the rev1 12" MB
 
I'll add a few points

1) that's actually pretty easy to do based in part availability. Match should launch new 12" & 13" MacBooks both on Skylake. 15"s won't launch until September at best; why? Because there are no Skylake GTE-4 parts available. Given Iris Pro is needed to drive the retina displays that rules out both 15s. Apples metal API relies heavily on OpenCL which means it'll have another AMD GPU. Polaris won't arrive until the back-to-school period so again Q3-Q4. The ironic part is that by the time it launches it may be using Kaby Lake and skip Skylake entirely; we'll see.

2) there haven't been any leaked shells indicating a redesign so most likely it'll be new ports on the existing shell. USB-C and TB-3 are all but guaranteed

3) I don't buy that. The current 15" has way more bugs than the rev1 12" MB
Worth keeping it?
Like what problems with the Mid 2015
 
Worth keeping it?
Like what problems with the Mid 2015

The 15" with the AMD M370X has documented problems with throttling under load.
I should know: I owned one, was in contact with Apple (expected behavior, they called it), got a replacement, sold it.

For proof of throttling in Bootcamp:
http://www.notebookcheck.net/Apple-MacBook-Pro-Retina-15-Mid-2015-Review.144402.0.html

Quotes:
"Unfortunately, the MacBook Pro is affected by a very annoying problem when you use Windows, which results in frame rate drops during prolonged gaming sessions: The Radeon GPU cannot maintain its core clock of 800 MHz. The clock often fluctuates between 675 and 725 MHz, but occasionally drops to 400 MHz. The resulting stutters are very annoying, particularly when you play shooting games, and seem to be caused by thermal throttling when the core temperature reaches around 74 °C (~165 °F)."

"The 85-watt power adaptor is hardly adequate and limits the consumption to around 90 watts – which means that the MacBook cannot maintain the maximum clock for the CPU and the GPU simultaneously, even when the temperatures are very low. However, the temperature development will result in throttling after a couple of minutes anyway..."


The throttling is just as prevalent under OS X but sadly GPU Z doesn't work in OS X, so I can't just slap the numbers in your face.
If you want to see throttling in OS X you can use a GPU benchmarking application like Unigine Heaven, awful.


It is a pain in the ass for sure, but depending on you demands, you might not be bothered by it.
I was, so I got rid of it.
 
The 15" with the AMD M370X has documented problems with throttling under load.
I should know: I owned one, was in contact with Apple (expected behavior, they called it), got a replacement, sold it.

For proof of throttling in Bootcamp:
http://www.notebookcheck.net/Apple-MacBook-Pro-Retina-15-Mid-2015-Review.144402.0.html

Quotes:
"Unfortunately, the MacBook Pro is affected by a very annoying problem when you use Windows, which results in frame rate drops during prolonged gaming sessions: The Radeon GPU cannot maintain its core clock of 800 MHz. The clock often fluctuates between 675 and 725 MHz, but occasionally drops to 400 MHz. The resulting stutters are very annoying, particularly when you play shooting games, and seem to be caused by thermal throttling when the core temperature reaches around 74 °C (~165 °F)."

"The 85-watt power adaptor is hardly adequate and limits the consumption to around 90 watts – which means that the MacBook cannot maintain the maximum clock for the CPU and the GPU simultaneously, even when the temperatures are very low. However, the temperature development will result in throttling after a couple of minutes anyway..."


The throttling is just as prevalent under OS X but sadly GPU Z doesn't work in OS X, so I can't just slap the numbers in your face.
If you want to see throttling in OS X you can use a GPU benchmarking application like Unigine Heaven, awful.


It is a pain in the ass for sure, but depending on you demands, you might not be bothered by it.
I was, so I got rid of it.
Yeah. I'm getting the one with the Dedicated Graphics. This should be interesting.
[doublepost=1455783826][/doublepost]
Yeah. I'm getting the one with the Dedicated Graphics. This should be interesting.
I'm not a gamer, video editor, 4K videos, YouTube, word, PowerPoint.

Slightly concerned about the temperature. Of the computer. Better get AppleCare. Should I get AppleCare when I get the computer or when the one year is almost up. If I were to spill something on the computer. Very low likely hood, I basically just wasted $400 on AppleCare. Any thoughts?

Maybe I might run Windows. Maybe. Just because of school things. My school district is mainly foucsed on PCs, ugh. I have about 120GB or 300GB of free space if I take my photos library out. Probbaly just view documents and certain files. What would be a good partition size for that? If I wanted to remove windows. Do I need to repartition the whole computer, remove all my data? Or just uninstall windows?

Thanks
 
Last edited:
Yeah. I'm getting the one with the Dedicated Graphics. This should be interesting.

Thing is, it's much better than the integrated Iris Pro gpu.
You might not even be bothered by it.
I would try not to worry and instead just try to sell it if it starts to become a problem.
 
Thing is, it's much better than the integrated Iris Pro gpu.
You might not even be bothered by it.
I would try not to worry and instead just try to sell it if it starts to become a problem.
But at the same time I really need the computer for work. But idk if it's worth the wait till June or so still.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.