Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Politics, Religion, Social Issues' started by zimv20, Sep 11, 2005.
Yes. Heard this on the radio this morning... extremely sad.
What do the most vocal right-wing 'pro-life' organisations have to say about this?
I agree with this, because it is better for the people that were dying.
in my opinion of course
I suppose it's the humane thing to do from a Utilitarian point of view.
I have no idea what I would do if I were the doctor.
suffering that leads to death?
or painless death?
its a tough call, but i can't see a doctor doing this unless the situation was dire, as it was.... still it upsets something inside of me, although it was probably the humanitarian thing to do.
Rough call for the doctors. I hope that no one sees this as an issue to pursue and prosecute. Sounds like they did the right thing.
The Modern Hippocratic Oath seems to give them the narrowest of margin for such drastic measure without violating their sworn integrity. "I will respect the privacy of my patients, for their problems are not disclosed to me that the world may know. Most especially must I tread with care in matters of life and death. If it is given me to save a life, all thanks. But it may also be within my power to take a life; this awesome responsibility must be faced with great humbleness and awareness of my own frailty. Above all, I must not play at God." Surely no rational, compassionate group will seek to make this an issue, though I'm both leery and weary of professional finger-pointers, be they cloaked in political or religious garb.
I predict the administration will have a field day with this.
I'm surprised people aren't more upset, the nation as a whole is still not comprehending the extent of what has happened, it seems.
shall i suspect the same kind of rationality that surrounded the terry schiavo circus?
i don't think the administration will, but i expect the conservative media will respond.
Ah! Too much controversy! Is that all this country is about anymore?
I share your viewpoint, but what is troubling is the fact that it never seems to be too challenging locating some overzealous prosecutor lurking in the woods, willing to make a huge issue out of events that do not warrant an aggressive response. It'll be interesting to see how it plays out.
From the people I've been talking to, most of them don't want to think about it.
But this kinda reminds me of the evolution debate. They don't want you to teach evolution, but it's on the NCLB test. To quote Cavey Jr. "they screw you coming and going". Bush and the neocons wouldn't dare make a comment about this. People are already blaming them for the disaster's aftermath in the first place. If they started in on doctors having to make tough decisions like this because of their perceived incompetence... I don't think that would go over very well.
Rather unenviable position those doctors were in. At the end of the day can anyone really critisise them for what they did.
Also must have been really hard on the doctors themselves.
I'd imagine the only thing harder would've been watching them die slowly.
I believe that euthanasia should be legalized.
With a checks and balance system to the ultimate decision.
In this case, I don't judge the doctor one bit. It's almost like a battlefield triage. Had to make a call.
This is horrible. But I think they did the right thing in a incredibly difficult situation.
Edit: Just glad they didn't suffer. It must've been hard on the doctors and nurses
fwiw, a former roommate used to date an emergency room doc. he told us that the docs made those kinds of triage decisions all the time, due to limited resources.
he also told us that if it was between a white gunshot victim and a black one, they'd almost always treat the white kid first.
How finely tuned is that distinction? What's the score between a mixed-race kid and a semite? Native American and Chinese? Chicano and Puerto Rican? Just out of interest, you understand...
he drew out the whole chart, but this was in the early 90's, and i don't remember most of it. i do recall, however, that brits were at the very, very bottom.