My question is what do you do if your stock hdd crashes? Would you buy a 1.5 Gb/s hdd to replace it? Also is it absolutely true that the current 13" and 15" mbp has a 1.5 Gb/s controller or does it have a 3 Gb/s? Bad firmware or what is going on!?! Another thing is that has anyone tried their 3rd party hdd under windows vista to see if it freezes? I heard in one of the apple support forum that someone said that their mbp works fine under windows.