An article came out this morning that said the Google Phone is a piece of junk - read

Discussion in 'iPhone' started by Rybold, Sep 23, 2008.

  1. Rybold macrumors 6502a


    Jun 23, 2008
    California, USA
    Just read the bold parts, if you don't want to read the whole article.

    Google's G1: First Impressions, Sep 23, 2008.
    "From All Things Digital, Sept. 23, 2008:

    Google’s new G1 phone announced today is the first real competitor to the iPhone. Like Apple’s product, it’s a serious handheld computer with a powerful new operating system (called Android) and a clever touch-based user interface. Like the iPhone, it’s likely to be a major new platform for third-party software. But it’s also very different, and may appeal to different buyers.

    The phone, expected to be the first of many to use the Android operating system, was largely designed by Google, and was built by HTC of Taiwan. It will be sold in the U.S. starting next month by T-Mobile, for $179 with a two-year contract.

    Here are some first impressions of the G1, based on some experience with a prototype. This isn’t a full review; that will come later, when I’ve had a chance to use a more finished device.

    A Keyboard

    Most importantly, the G1 complements its touch screen with a physical keyboard, the lack of which has made the iPhone a non-starter for some users. The G1’s keyboard is revealed when you slide open its screen. The keys are a bit flat, and you have to reach your right thumb around a bulging portion of the phone’s body to type, but it’s a real keyboard. And there’s also a BlackBerry-like trackball that supplements the touch screen navigation. I found typing on this keyboard to be OK, but not great.

    A second big feature, or limitation, of the G1 — depending on your point of view — is that it is tightly tied to Google’s web-based email, contacts and calendar programs. In fact, you must have a Google (GOOG) account to use the phone, and can only synchronize the phone’s calendar and address book with Google online services. Unlike the iPhone, it doesn’t work with Microsoft Exchange, and it can’t physically be synced with a PC-based calendar or contacts program, like Microsoft Outlook.

    So, if your world already revolves around Google services, you may find that the G1 fits like a glove. If not, you may be disappointed.

    Also, like the iPhone, the G1 has a download service for third-party programs, called Market. I downloaded a couple of simple Market programs and they worked fine.

    The G1 won’t win any beauty contests with its Apple (AAPL) rival. It’s stubby and chunky, nearly 30% thicker and almost 20% heavier than the iPhone. It’s a bit narrower — more like a standard phone than a “smart phone” — and longer, but has a somewhat smaller screen.

    Still, it feels pretty good in the hand when closed, although I found it more awkward when opened.

    Slick software

    But the software is slick. Programs appear in a virtual drawer you slide open via a tab at the bottom of the screen, and notifications of new messages and the like can be read by sliding the top bar of the screen down. The screen and software were quick and responsive.

    The web browser is based on the same open-source technology as the iPhone’s, but works differently. You can view a portion of a page, and use a zoom control and finger-dragging to see the rest, or you can view the whole page in miniature, as on the iPhone. In the latter mode, however, you can’t simply use Apple’s technique of tapping or “pinching” to zoom in on a portion of a page. You must move around a virtual lens to pick out a part of the page on which to focus.

    There are two email programs: one for Google’s Gmail, another for all other email services. There’s an instant messaging program, that works with multiple services — not just Google’s. And, as on the iPhone, there are programs for using Google Maps and Google’s YouTube video service. The G1’s Google Maps program has a feature lacking in the iPhone version: photographic street views of some locations.

    More on functionality

    The G1 has a couple of other things the iPhone omits: copy and paste functionality and a so-called MMS program, which sends photos to other phones without using email. Its camera is higher-resolution than the iPhone’s, but, like Apple’s, doesn’t record video.

    It also gives you far more flexibility in organizing your desktop, or home screen, than the iPhone, or almost any phone I’ve seen. In addition to placing icons for programs there, you can everything from individual contacts, music playlists, folders, web pages, and more.

    The G1’s multimedia capabilities are less polished and complete than the iPhone’s. There’s a very basic music player, and a built-in version of Amazon’s MP3 download service that works fine. But the G1 lacks a built-in video player — you have to download one from the third-party software store. Also, you cannot use standard stereo headphones with the G1. You need special ones, or an adapter.

    And it lacks the iPhone’s ability to change the orientation of a web page or photo by just turning the phone. You also can’t move through groups of photos by just “flicking,” as on the iPhone.

    The G1 also has much less memory than the iPhone. The base $199 iPhone comes with 8 gigabytes sealed in, but the G1 comes with just a 1 gigabyte memory card. Its maximum memory, if you buy a bigger card, is 8 gigabytes, while the iPhone can be purchased (for $299) with twice that.

    T-Mobile is claiming similar talk time to that of the iPhone, but, unlike Apple’s product, the G1 has a removable battery.

    Finally, a word about networks. In the U.S., the G1 will initially only be available on T-Mobile, whose high-speed 3G network will be up and running in many fewer cities than those of its larger rivals, AT&T (T) and Verizon (VZ). Like the iPhone, the G1 does have Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and GPS.

    In sum, the G1 is a powerful, versatile device which will offer users a real alternative in the new handheld computing category the iPhone has occupied alone."

    SOURCE: Via Yahoo Tech Ticker,,aapl,t,vz
  2. soberbrain macrumors 65816


    May 9, 2008
    Did you read the article?

    I hope Android/G1 becomes a good competitor to the iPhone so that features and upgrades keep coming and maybe even sooner!
  3. Raid macrumors 68020


    Feb 18, 2003
    Hmm well the article hardly says it's a 'piece of junk', but (just like the iPhone) many won't like it's limitations, and therefore won't buy it. Different strokes...
  4. Rybold thread starter macrumors 6502a


    Jun 23, 2008
    California, USA

    Yes. I bolded select text to highlight the FACTS, not the authors subjective opinion.
  5. Elven macrumors 6502a


    May 13, 2008
    That thing will not be a problem to the iPhone.

    Now when the inevitable facelift of it comes out, THEN we have a new problem :)
  6. iblastoff macrumors 6502

    Aug 2, 2008
    how on earth did you conclude this article was saying the android phone was a piece of junk? do you not know how to read?

    i like how you say you bolded the FACTS and yet i clearly see "I found it more awkward when opened" highlighted in your post.
  7. Rybold thread starter macrumors 6502a


    Jun 23, 2008
    California, USA
  8. Rybold thread starter macrumors 6502a


    Jun 23, 2008
    California, USA
  9. Psyxologos macrumors regular

    Feb 12, 2008
    I love it when people go bitter with themselves and embark on a journey of polemics in a futile attempt to convince themselves they are happy with their choice, now they see the alternatives.

    Rybold, come to terms with it, you are stuck with the iphone!

Share This Page