Any of you preunibody guys still on your original 8600GT?

puma1552

Suspended
Original poster
Nov 20, 2008
5,559
1,917
Make me feel better about possibly picking up a pre-unibody machine just because I want one to replace my air, even though I already have a unibody MBP as well. I just like the design, tell me happy stories.
 

scottness

macrumors 65816
Mar 18, 2009
1,370
3
Room 101
Wish I could tell you happy stories...

Every single one of the pre-unibody mbps I've owned have had bad clamshell locking hooks (whatever you call them). That's my only real complaint, besides speed.
 

jsnuff1

macrumors 6502a
Oct 4, 2003
639
188
NY
Yea...been running mine since mid 2007 with no issues so far (and have been playing WOW on it and beating the GPU/CPU.

Id be happy to sell it to you too when the new MBP's comeout.
 

Auszero

macrumors member
Jul 18, 2009
64
4
August 08 and still going strong. It has been used heavily for gaming and no video issues. Battery just took a dive though. :(
 

DaveTheGrey

macrumors 6502a
Dec 28, 2003
614
0
My Dad's Santa Rosa MBP died a Logicborad death 4 weeks ago (unfortunately not the nvidea issue...)
I have the same one, it's ok but the battery quite sucks and the fans go crazy when I recharge the battery (although I did the firmware update which should have fixed this problem)
 

puma1552

Suspended
Original poster
Nov 20, 2008
5,559
1,917
Anyone else?

Everything in my body says "bad financial decision" but no matter how much I try to be happy with what I have and just forget about selling my base Air for a Pro (of whatever iteration) I just can't do it and always find myself looking at the pro lustfully. All that silver is so sexy too.

The model I would be likely getting would be a 2008 model, model number MB133LL/A, with the 2.4/2/200 setup and LED backlit screen. These machines were sold in my pre-Apple days, so...

1) Is there anything to look out for on these models sans graphics card or were they solid machines?

2) Are they lacking any of the multitouch functionality of the pros?

3) SL is no problem, correct?

4) How much worse are the screens in terms of brightness/contrast/crispness compared to the unibody? I'm expecting them not to be as good, but I would still expect them to be pretty good, and not far off from the unibodies.

TIA.
 

Erasmus

macrumors 68030
Jun 22, 2006
2,655
165
Hiding from Omnius in Australia
1) Is there anything to look out for on these models sans graphics card or were they solid machines?

2) Are they lacking any of the multitouch functionality of the pros?

3) SL is no problem, correct?

4) How much worse are the screens in terms of brightness/contrast/crispness compared to the unibody? I'm expecting them not to be as good, but I would still expect them to be pretty good, and not far off from the unibodies.

TIA.
1) Yellow screen tint at the bottom, which seems to be pretty common (as both I have had have had it) but isn't really noticeable unless you're looking for it. Downside of reading stuff on forums. Make sure the lid closes nicely, both latch, and the screen doesn't bend up at the corners a lot.

BATTERY. Mine is completely shot, need new one bad. Check the battery health, and do a battery calibration. Make sure it actually drains to 0% battery before it dies/hibernates, mine shuts down when it's still ~95% charged, lol.

2) I thought SL was supposed to bring super multitouch to these machines, but it hasn't. Two fingers only, so zoom and scroll is fine.

3) I'm running SL on mine, no probs. The 8600M GT doesn't do the video decode thing some of the others do (So don't expect a really long battery life watching movies), but does do OpenCL.

4) Not a clue, but they are the same resolution, and still LED backlit, so I doubt whether you'll notice that much of a difference

I dislike airs immensely. If you get this MBP, it will be noticeably faster than your air, and much, much faster in anything that requires a graphics card. What MBA do you have?

BTW, my graphics card "died", well just became extremely slow. Turns out only one of the 16 PCI lanes was working, so it was just unbelievably bandwidth starved. Apple replaced the motherboard for free, but that extended warranty might be over now. My second has been working like a charm for 12 months now.
 

hellric

macrumors member
Feb 8, 2010
69
0
Belgium
I'm running SL on my early 2008 MBP (Penryn 2.4) and my 8600M GT is running perfectly.
I can play Bioshock in 1280x800 without problem.
But I think I'll update soon if the new MBP release is not too bad ;)
 

WHM

macrumors regular
Feb 5, 2008
190
1
South
Make me feel better about possibly picking up a pre-unibody machine just because I want one to replace my air, even though I already have a unibody MBP as well. I just like the design, tell me happy stories.
My Feb 2008 was still working great when I sold it last week... I took out Apple Care and that is one of the things that helped me sell it... I am laptopless now waiting on the refresh ?
 

smiddlehurst

macrumors 65816
Jun 5, 2007
1,226
22
Anyone else?

Everything in my body says "bad financial decision" but no matter how much I try to be happy with what I have and just forget about selling my base Air for a Pro (of whatever iteration) I just can't do it and always find myself looking at the pro lustfully. All that silver is so sexy too.

The model I would be likely getting would be a 2008 model, model number MB133LL/A, with the 2.4/2/200 setup and LED backlit screen. These machines were sold in my pre-Apple days, so...

1) Is there anything to look out for on these models sans graphics card or were they solid machines?
Where to start....

Chassis: The non-unibody MBP is very prone to dents. I've dropped mine a grand total of once from a height of MAYBE six inches and the port for the magsafe is now noticeably buckled. The palmrest is prone to 'pitting', not sure why but on mine the right side of the rest is badly discoloured thanks to this (the left side is fine...). Top case doesn't always align properly with the bottom case when closed leaving a big gap between the two. Silver covering on the latch switch wears off over time. The construction method of the bottom case can result in creaking panels, especially on the right side of the laptop.

Battery: Oh god, the headaches this has caused. The swelling / shorting battery issue that dogged pre 07 MBP's seems to be common in ALL pre-unibody machines. This can cause your battery to go from perfectly healthy to screwed overnight and can also be an intermitent problem so you may not notice it during testing on a second hand machine.

Keyboard: Can be misaligned. This can be a cosmetic issue or may be more serious and cause some keys to respond poorly.

Trackpad: Isn't that bad but the button can become clogged up with debris making it's way into the space underneath the button. Hopefully the owner took good care of the machine though.

Heat: Make no mistake, pre-unibody machines get HOT. Even my 17" MBP gets uncomfortable to use on the lap, the 15" I had briefly got hot enough to be uncomfortable on the palmrest.

Screen: As someone mentioned above, yellow screens were common on the first LED-backlit MBP's and not all were swapped out if the user didn't spot it. I was originally going to buy a 15" with LED backlighting and went through three of 'em before giving up and getting a 17" because of this issue. It's really noticeable, especially on full-screen web browsing and WILL annoy you.

GPU: In off-the-record discussions with an Apple store manager I was told Apple expect all Nvidia 8600GT's to fail on these machines. When that'll happen will of course vary and I'm sure some will keep on going regardless but it's a huge problem and the odds probably aren't in your favour.

That's just the issues I've personally experienced, I know there are others out there too. Personally I wouldn't do it, if you want to replace an Air the 13" MBP is, IMHO, a far better choice than any second hand pre-unibody MBP.
 

theLimit

macrumors 6502a
Jan 30, 2007
928
1
up tha holler, acrost tha crick
My Early 2008 2.4GHz Penryn MBP has been flawless. I use it daily and play games in OS X and Windows via Boot Camp and have had no problems with the GPU. I had the original battery replaced after a couple months because it would no longer charge and System Profiler said to replace it after only 16 cycles. I just walked into an Apple Store and they swapped it on the spot, no questions asked. The new battery has been running over 18 months and still gets 3-4 hours. The only "problem" is that the silver on the latch button is wearing off.
 

noskill

macrumors newbie
Oct 2, 2007
5
0
Had a early 2008 MBP (2.4 GHz) up until a couple of weeks ago. Was actually planning to sell it at some point in future after new models will be released. But that was one of those "I just want it" things with no real reasoning behind it -- MBP was more than enough for my needs, stable and smooth...

... up until logic board miserably failed one morning about a month ago. Now I'm laptopless and OSX-less and don't have any other choice than to buy a new one.

Other than that it was a very good machine.
 

bushbeat

macrumors member
Oct 1, 2009
48
0
MBP 2008/A1260/2.4/4G still going strong...

1) Had issues with trackpad button and several keys. Topcase replaced.

2) Full multitouch functionality

3) SL ok

4) LED screen ok, but 15" is not high res.
 

psxtreme

macrumors member
Jun 27, 2009
33
0
I have an early 2008 penryn 15" and it's still going strong almost two years later *crosses fingers*. I haven't had any problems so far. I game a bit, lately playing call of duty 4.
 

puma1552

Suspended
Original poster
Nov 20, 2008
5,559
1,917
What if I told you guys it was a brand new, never opened, factory sealed machine?

And what if I told you they want $1900 for it?
 

barkomatic

macrumors 601
Aug 8, 2008
4,027
1,798
Manhattan
I'm still on my 2006 first generation MBP and I love it. None of the updates since have impressed me enough to replace it. Same optical drives, same screen resolution, slightly better processors, but lots and lots of hype when they're released. Perhaps the next update will be substantial enough to buy.

I like the old design better as well by the way. I don't like the black keys on the new ones.
 

Azmordean

macrumors 6502
Mar 10, 2004
250
0
Silicon Valley
I suspect for me the answer is no. Not long ago I had flickering and other screen issues. The fix was to replace my logic board. I suspect the 8600M GT bug but I don't have proof of that.