Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

Apple to Acquire Discreet Desktop Video division?

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
50,386
11,759

SumDumGuy

macrumors regular
Jun 17, 2002
122
0
Loserville
Oh goody! This will be quite a boon for content creation. With Apple at the helm, Cleaner could become usable again like when it was owned by Terran.
 
Comment

spaced

macrumors newbie
May 1, 2002
19
0
Raleigh, NC
Great move, Discreet. Threatening to close your floundering Mac division was the perfect bait to position Apple for a buyout. Bravo!
 
Comment

Bakey

macrumors 6502
Oct 6, 2003
446
0
O Donny Boy
Just Hold on a Minute!!

Sod Cleaner, if there's any credence to this rumour then maybe [just maybe] there may be 3ds Mac!!
 
Comment

ennerseed

macrumors regular
Jan 3, 2002
142
0
ROCK ON!

that would be great... although an alias acquisition would be better news.
 
Comment

srobert

macrumors 68020
Jan 7, 2002
2,062
0
Please excuse my ignorance on this topic... but is this a:

A) We're buyin' ya 'cause we really like your product and want to integrate it.

or

B) We're buyin' ya 'cause we don't like your product (even if it's a good one) because it is competing with one of our present or future product.

Any idea?
 
Comment

henryblackman

macrumors member
Nov 23, 2002
52
0
Let's hope Apple do acquire them, or at least their technology. Apple do NOT need any kind of knocks when they are pushing forward with video as a target market!

Of course, hopefully they'll discontinue the PC version and give them Mac Cleaner free with a purchase of a Mac - a la EMagic.
 
Comment

AmigoMac

macrumors 68020
Aug 5, 2003
2,063
0
l'Allemagne
The return of the king...

Just a small step for apple but a big one for the computers community...

or was it the other way? ...

Some tools are needed to catch that expected market share increase... step by step ... if you want money, you have to invest...
 
Comment

nuckinfutz

macrumors 603
Jul 3, 2002
5,502
314
Middle Earth
Not too sure 3ds would be for sale. Who knows though.

I doubt this comes to fruition for the simple fact that Apple must tread lightly as far as software acquisitions. Microsoft can get away with competing with developers without punishment, Apple cannot.

Although if the price is right I say do it. Apple doesn't really need alot of extra video products but I'm sure they could poach the best code from many discreet products and strengthen DV on the Mac.
 
Comment

jettredmont

macrumors 68030
Jul 25, 2002
2,724
314
Hmmm ... seems to me that if Apple was buying Cleaner then the Cleaner development team wouldn't have already been laid off ... so one rumor or the other is inaccurate.
 
Comment

hkhaskell

macrumors newbie
Jun 23, 2003
9
0
Mauldin, SC
Mixed feelings...

I am not sure whether this would be a good thing or not.

There's no question that somebody who will actually develop it should buy the technology from Discreet. It's ridiculous that there's no Real Player or Windows Media 9 export on OS X, while the PC version has had both of these for a while now. It's not like the codecs haven't been available for almost a year now...

My fear is that Apple would not be very motivated to develop a product that exports streaming media to other formats other than QuickTime.
 
Comment

Makosuke

macrumors 603
Aug 15, 2001
6,288
523
The Cool Part of CA, USA
If Apple maintained Cleaner (or improved it) as a standalone product, that'd be very cool, particularly since they'd probably drop the price some, maybe putting it within the reach of cheap-o folks like me.

But if they wrapped it into/bundled it with FCE/FCP, that would be even cooler. It'd be nice to have a standalone version for postprocessing video, but (also, hopefully) having an integrated version would be very cool.

Who knows, if we're really lucky they'll just make it part of QuickTime Pro.
 
Comment

Longey Nowze

macrumors regular
Apr 18, 2001
222
0
3dsmax!

A lot of people I know wont buy a mac cuz it doesn't have 3ds max! I keep telling them about Cinema 4d, de éspirit (sp) maya and all the others that are better than 3ds max! so this would be a good thing! bring on G5 optimisation and altivec! and show us numbers that are 3-5 times faster than on windows!

I hope this is true... I'm excited!
 
Comment

ennerseed

macrumors regular
Jan 3, 2002
142
0
Next!

Macromedia.
Apple (or someone worth a **** read NOT microsoft) needs to buy them.
 
Comment

Raidiant

macrumors member
Nov 28, 2002
34
0
To add to the discussion, both combustion 3 and 3d studio max are extremely good and has a huge fanbase applications, alot of people actually don't want a mac for work because it can't run 3DSMAX, thats why all game developers use PCs....

I personally have not bought a mac desktop because of this.
 
Comment

rspress

macrumors member
Jul 22, 2002
40
0
Northern California
This is great news! I hope Apple will purchase cleaner, combustion and 3dsmax.

God knows that Cleaner could use Apples magic touch and it should replace the lame Compressor program that ships with final cut pro.

Combustion is one of my favorite compositing and effects program and Apple could give this program the attention it deserves.

3DSMax on the other hand is a mixed bag. Powerful but with an interface the could stump even the most hardened 3d veteran. This program would benefit the most from Apples UI magic. Apple having this program on their shelves could alienate Alias Wavefront and other vendors..maybe this one will be resold to pixar.

These would be great additions to Apples Pro line of video authoring programs if they decide to purchase them...I can hardly wait for an Apple branded Combustion!
 
Comment

zedwards

macrumors member
Jul 8, 2002
59
0
France
First, DVD Studio Pro and Final Cut Pro come with a compression software already. So, most likely, most people will not need this. Combustion's competition is Shake, although about 8000 less.

Also, it is ironic that if this was Microsoft, people would be howling about the corportate conglomeration grabbing every software company.
 
Comment

D*I*S_Frontman

macrumors 6502
May 20, 2002
450
17
Appleton,WI
Seems to me they might gut Cleaner and take the best parts in order to beef up Compressor. That would be very cool for us DV editing guys. Compressor does some things well, but it isn't as flexible nor does it support as many formats (at least that is my understanding from playing around with both of them).

Sometimes it makes more sense to BUY R&D from a company with a proven product than to SPEND R&D yourself on a competing product. Much more efficient. Now everyone should well understand why Apple keeps a sizable cash warchest around--for just such an opportunity.

It would be fabulous if Apple bought MacroMedia. Even better incentive to go with Mac as a platform: all your major-league content-generating software made by the same compnay that makes your hardware. Stable and reliable beats cheaper 95% of the time for people who actually work in these fields.
 
Comment

Dahl

macrumors 6502a
Nov 21, 2002
623
16
L.A.
Originally posted by zedwards
Also, it is ironic that if this was Microsoft, people would be howling about the corportate conglomeration grabbing every software company.
I guess most people still see Apple as a "small" company, I know I do.
 
Comment

hkhaskell

macrumors newbie
Jun 23, 2003
9
0
Mauldin, SC
Actually what would be neat...

...is if Apple bought these three products and then resold 3dsMax to Alias Wavefront with the stipulation that they have to develop MAYA Unlimited for Mac OS X. It's just plain silly that they don't have it already, since the Mac platform accounts for 25% of their sales.

(Plus, they already make it for SGI and Linux. How hard can it be?) :)
 
Comment

P-Worm

macrumors 68020
Jul 16, 2002
2,045
0
Salt Lake City, UT
A lot of people are talking about compressor, but I think that it is 3D Studio Max that is most important here. This program has a HUGE fanbase and there is no current Mac version. Now what would be sweet is if Appl bought 3DSMax and did the same thing to it as they did for Shake, cheeper for the Mac, and that is the only version we are going to support from now on.

P-Worm
 
Comment

ant_s

macrumors member
Jun 17, 2003
92
69
Derby, UK
3dsmax

If Apple were to acquire 3DSMax, then they'd have to start shipping Power Mac G5 BTOs with nVIDIA Quadro (or equivalent) cards. That would be a benchmark worth watching!

:D
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.