Apple vs. Dell Home machines

Discussion in 'General Mac Discussion' started by Ensign Paris, Feb 16, 2002.

  1. Ensign Paris macrumors 68000

    Ensign Paris

    Nov 4, 2001
    Can you see any problems with this comparison:

    Dell Spec:

    1.6ghz Pentium 4 (256k Cache)
    Floppy Drive
    On-Board Sound
    Mini Tower Chassic
    512mb SDRAM
    80gb HD
    15" Flat Panel Monitor
    64mb nVidia GeForce 2 MX
    8x IDE DVD/CDRW Combo Drive
    Harmon Kardon 395 Speakers
    Microsoft Windows XP
    3Com 10/100 Ethernet PCI Card
    Dell 56k Data/Fax Modem
    2 USB Ports
    No Firewire Ports
    MSWorks Suite 2001
    KBoard & Mouse

    Price - £1,469 (Not including VAT)

    iMac Spec:

    800mhz G4 (256k Cache)
    On-Board Sound
    60gb HD
    15.1" LCD Monitor
    32mb nVidia Geforce 2 MX
    SuperDrive (CDR&RW Writes @ 24x,CDROM @ 32x, DVDROM @ 24x, DVD-R @ 2x)
    Harmon Kardon Pro Speakers
    Mac OS X.12
    10/100bs-t Ethernet
    56k v.90 Built-in Ethernet
    Five USB Ports
    Two Firewire Ports
    AppleWorks 6
    Keyboard & Optical Mouse
    Wireless Networking Support (Airport)

    Price - £1725.95


    In the mid-high end Home PC range. The video, audio, processor, and RAM configurations are good. The hard drive is not particularly fast and should be plenty for most. The software package is not too good: WinXP and Microsoft Works Suite 2001. No easy to use and simple MP3 or Movie programs as standard. The Tower is also ugly but this is personal preference. It has PCI card slots but most of these are used up by added on pieces of kit, such as Ethernet, Modem, Graphics etc. The graphics card is in advance of the iMacs and should be able to beat the graphics card in the iMac. Also, the Dell has no way of writing DVD video and file disks where as the iMac does. To add the DVD-R feature would cost around £500.

    Dell Pros: PCI Slots, £200 cheaper that the iMac
    Dell Cons: WindowsXP is annoying for some users. No DVD Writing technology, slow CD writer. Ugly Case (Personal Pref), 512mb less of RAM than the iMac. No easy to use MP3 software. No Firewire. 2 USB cards.

    Apple's G4 is faring much better against its PC competitors nowadays, especially that it is now available in the iMac. The processor should be plenty for any work, and should work the video card is plenty for high-res gaming. The 800mhz processor clock speed is easily enough to compete with the Intel Pentium 4 1.6ghz in the Dell machine. The hard drive's plenty, even if it is 20GB less than the Dell's. One draw back with the iMac is the lack of PCI slots but normally this is not needed in a home / small office enviroment due to it having most of the technologies (such as Ethernet, Modem, Firewire inbuilt) DVD-R technology inbuilt is a major advantage over the Dell.

    iMac Pros: DVD-Writing Technology, iTunes MP3 Software, iMovie & iDVD for creating Movies and writing them to DVD. Mac OS X.1 is a very stable OS. Much easier to use that Windows. 1GB of RAM. 5 USB Ports, Firewire.
    iMac Cons: No PCI Slots, £200 more expensive than Dell.

    Overall Winner - Apple's G4 iMac

  2. mac15 macrumors 68040

    Dec 29, 2001
    how can you compare the most elegant computer in the world to a DELL
    the imac wins hand down
  3. krossfyter macrumors 601


    Jan 13, 2002
    secret city
    Dells like a pontiac grandam and the Apples new iMac is like a low end Porshe.

    whats to compare?

Share This Page