Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple's $634 million patent loss to medical technology company Masimo has just gotten even bigger, after a federal judge ordered Apple to pay an additional $184 million in interest on what it owes (via Bloomberg Law).

apple-watch-series-6-blood-oxygen-monitoring-1.jpg
 
Seems like it would have been better to just collaborate than to come out in the light and eyes of public as a patent pirate. Hopefully Apple does better in their future opportunities.
Masimo would certainly have gained far more than the less than 1 billion they’re getting here. BUT, it allowed them the opportunity to dump their CEO, so still likely a huge win for them.
 
Here's a way around it... I bought a cheap Apple Watch last year from a grey market website. It was a US model to the UK. So it had the feature disabled. Apple support couldn't enable it even if I verified my address / account etc.

I advise any of you if you happen to be on holiday to a UK or Europe or some other market-country that you accidentally crack your Apple Watch and require an express replacement to your hotel or nearest store.... seems to be they give you the country issued in device.

Sickening that this comapny can drag Apple through the courts. How exactly did Masimo lose out again because I bought an Apple Watch? ... I don't know what they make but I'm pretty sure it doesn't compete nor had a chance on my shortlist for my Apple integrated health sensor needs. is Tim Sweeney a shareholder or something?
 
Do you believe in intellectual property and the rights of those who create it? Massimo has every right to protect its assets, just as you are within your rights to protect your belongings. You can’t be for Apple’s patent defenses but be against Massimo’s (if you are logically consistent and intellectual honest).
 
Here's a way around it... I bought a cheap Apple Watch last year from a grey market website. It was a US model to the UK. So it had the feature disabled. Apple support couldn't enable it even if I verified my address / account etc.

I advise any of you if you happen to be on holiday to a UK or Europe or some other market-country that you accidentally crack your Apple Watch and require an express replacement to your hotel or nearest store.... seems to be they give you the country issued in device.

Sickening that this comapny can drag Apple through the courts. How exactly did Masimo lose out again because I bought an Apple Watch? ... I don't know what they make but I'm pretty sure it doesn't compete nor had a chance on my shortlist for my Apple integrated health sensor needs. is Tim Sweeney a shareholder or something?
Sometimes it’s better not to say anything before you have the facts. Masimo is a leading provider of pulse oximetry devices.


 
Something needs to be done with these patent trolls who misuse the original purpose, but our representatives only do something when there are campaign donations involved.
Masimo is not a patent troll. They made medical equipment and have been in business for nearly 40 years. I'm a physician and we use their products in the hospital as well as out patient clinics.
 
Sometimes it’s better not to say anything before you have the facts. Masimo is a leading provider of pulse oximetry devices.


Maybe they are - I wouldn't know. But if a company like Apple thinks they are in the right and are willing to take it to court, you can't immediately dismiss anyone who suspects that they might actually be in the right.

I'm not really sure how it works in the US in terms of back and forth, seems a lot more drawn out and 'one minute he's right, one minute she's wrong' sort of stuff in a lot of these cases. So when it's all eventually said and done, I suppose Macrumors will post another article and we all post again as a comment.

Apple has had a lot of this stuff though, some Scottish company claimed to have invented multi-touch amongst other cases.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: marte91
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.