Ben Carson: War Against ISIS Should Have No ‘Rules’

steve knight

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Jan 28, 2009
2,596
6,958
so kill children and woman old old people? no biggie rape those same people no biggie. this will really endure us to the world. really this is a presidential wannabe?

http://www.mediaite.com/tv/ben-carson-war-against-isis-should-have-no-rules/
According to pediatric neurosurgeon and potential 2016 presidential candidate Dr. Ben Carson, one of the main impediments to U.S. military success against ISIS in the Middle East is the fear of prosecution when those conducting the operations return home. In Carson’s view, we need to eliminate all “rules” in the fight against ISIS if we ever want to win.

“Our military needs to know that they’re not going be prosecuted when they come back, because somebody has said, ‘You did something that was politically incorrect
 

xmichaelp

macrumors 68000
Jul 10, 2012
1,806
625
If the belief that some conservatives have that Obama only got elected because he was black is true then they should nominate Carson. Surely he would get all the black and liberal votes and it would be an automatic win. :eek:

Really though this guy is a nut. Nothing to see here.
 

jnpy!$4g3cwk

macrumors 65816
Feb 11, 2010
1,100
1,293
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/ben-carson-war-against-isis-should-have-no-rules/
According to pediatric neurosurgeon and potential 2016 presidential candidate Dr. Ben Carson, one of the main impediments to U.S. military success against ISIS in the Middle East is the fear of prosecution when those conducting the operations return home. In Carson’s view, we need to eliminate all “rules” in the fight against ISIS if we ever want to win.

“Our military needs to know that they’re not going be prosecuted when they come back, because somebody has said, ‘You did something that was politically incorrect
I hope someone asks him what he means, exactly. Does he really want U.S. troops to violate {the rules of war; the Geneva Conventions; etc}? And, if he actually does want troops to violate the rules of war, exactly how that would help U.S. interests?
 

sodapop1

Suspended
Sep 7, 2014
187
1,282
“There is no such thing as a politically correct war. We need to grow up, we need to mature. If you’re gonna have rules for war, you should just have a rule that says no war. Other than that, we have to win. Our life depends on it.”
By this knucklehead's logic, we might as well just nuke the hell out of Syria and Iraq and be done with it.
 

thekev

macrumors 604
Aug 5, 2010
6,670
1,746
By this knucklehead's logic, we might as well just nuke the hell out of Syria and Iraq and be done with it.
He's just pandering to people who don't care about civilian deaths in other countries as long as they do not have to see them. The rest of it is just rhetoric. That the guy is probably a smart person just makes his responses even more insidious.
 

sodapop1

Suspended
Sep 7, 2014
187
1,282
He's just pandering to people who don't care about civilian deaths in other countries as long as they do not have to see them. The rest of it is just rhetoric. That the guy is probably a smart person just makes his responses even more insidious.
The problem with that is he's playing right into the hands of ISIS with all of his rhetoric. They want nothing more for the US to have some knee-jerk reaction and end up killing tons of muslims in the process, ultimately creating more tensions between the US and the Middle-east.
 

steve knight

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Jan 28, 2009
2,596
6,958
The problem with that is he's playing right into the hands of ISIS with all of his rhetoric. They want nothing more for the US to have some knee-jerk reaction and end up killing tons of muslims in the process, ultimately creating more tensions between the US and the Middle-east.
exactly and we are looking bad enough already just with the drone attacks. well another prime presidential candidate with foot in mouth desease.
 

jkcerda

macrumors 6502a
Jun 10, 2013
682
39,017
Criminal Mexi Midget
He's just pandering to people who don't care about civilian deaths in other countries as long as they do not have to see them. The rest of it is just rhetoric. That the guy is probably a smart person just makes his responses even more insidious.
The problem with that is he's playing right into the hands of ISIS with all of his rhetoric. They want nothing more for the US to have some knee-jerk reaction and end up killing tons of muslims in the process, ultimately creating more tensions between the US and the Middle-east.
exactly and we are looking bad enough already just with the drone attacks. well another prime presidential candidate with foot in mouth desease.
yes, because SLOWLY killing 1000's of civilians and occupying their territories for years on end is so much better, I bet ISIS/ISIL just LOVES us and our ways:rolleyes:

the only "War" that was semi decently executed was Bush SR's :eek: wam bam thank you mam, in & out in about a month. go in, kick butt & LEAVE.
 

thekev

macrumors 604
Aug 5, 2010
6,670
1,746
The problem with that is he's playing right into the hands of ISIS with all of his rhetoric. They want nothing more for the US to have some knee-jerk reaction and end up killing tons of muslims in the process, ultimately creating more tensions between the US and the Middle-east.
Yeah I have no idea how this will end, but I suspect it will just end with more enemies. How long before the Kurds hate the US too? After all the US and UK were at least partly friendly to Saddam in the 1980s.

yes, because SLOWLY killing 1000's of civilians and occupying their territories for years on end is so much better, I bet ISIS/ISIL just LOVES us and our ways:rolleyes:

the only "War" that was semi decently executed was Bush SR's :eek: wam bam thank you mam, in & out in about a month. go in, kick butt & LEAVE.
Are you at all familiar with the history of that war? It was just supporting one bad regime over another, in that case Kuwait over Iraq.
 

sodapop1

Suspended
Sep 7, 2014
187
1,282
yes, because SLOWLY killing 1000's of civilians and occupying their territories for years on end is so much better, I bet ISIS/ISIL just LOVES us and our ways:rolleyes:

the only "War" that was semi decently executed was Bush SR's :eek: wam bam thank you mam, in & out in about a month. go in, kick butt & LEAVE.
Both you and Ben Carson are nothing but checkers players in a world were everyone is playing chess.

Comparing the Desert Storm operation, which was isolated to the town of Kuwait against an actual military, to a war spanning many different towns across two different countries against civilian terrorists is completely absurd.
 

kds1

Suspended
Feb 17, 2013
818
314
New York, New York
exactly and we are looking bad enough already just with the drone attacks. well another prime presidential candidate with foot in mouth desease.
I fail to see the problem with drone attacks. You could send in a real plane, or you could send in a drone. If the drone is more advantageous, do it. People need to get a grip.

----------

Both you and Ben Carson are nothing but checkers players in a world were everyone is playing chess.

Comparing the Desert Storm operation, which was isolated to the town of Kuwait against an actual military, to a war spanning many different towns across two different countries against civilian terrorists is completely absurd.
I have news for you, Kuwait is a country, not a "town". Geez. And people wonder why Americans come off as ignorant about the rest of the world, and can't locate cities and countries on a map.
 

jkcerda

macrumors 6502a
Jun 10, 2013
682
39,017
Criminal Mexi Midget
Both you and Ben Carson are nothing but checkers players in a world were everyone is playing chess.

Comparing the Desert Storm operation, which was isolated to the town of Kuwait against an actual military, to a war spanning many different towns across two different countries against civilian terrorists is completely absurd.
how many years of "chess" again? :rolleyes:
 

556fmjoe

macrumors 68000
Apr 19, 2014
1,613
918
There should always be rules in war. ISIS is what you get when there are none.
 

sodapop1

Suspended
Sep 7, 2014
187
1,282
I have news for you, Kuwait is a country, not a "town". Geez. And people wonder why Americans come off as ignorant about the rest of the world, and can't locate cities and countries on a map.
I didn't realize that, thank you for the correction.
 

Natzoo

macrumors 65816
Sep 16, 2014
1,199
84
Not sure where i am
Sorry, but ISIS is what you get when Obama made it a point to pull all American troops out.
I agree to this but how long is the US supposed to support other countries. I agree with you, wouldnt it be nice to see Russia deploying troops in Iraq. That would definitely make US remove the sanctions that were thrust upon them
 

kds1

Suspended
Feb 17, 2013
818
314
New York, New York
Sorry, but ISIS is what you get when Obama made it a point to pull all American troops out.
ISIS is what we got by going into Iraq in the first place.

----------

I agree to this but how long is the US supposed to support other countries. I agree with you, wouldnt it be nice to see Russia deploying troops in Iraq. That would definitely make US remove the sanctions that were thrust upon them
Russia had two covert operatives operating within ISIS.
They were caught and beheaded, of course.
 

thekev

macrumors 604
Aug 5, 2010
6,670
1,746
Sorry, but ISIS is what you get when Obama made it a point to pull all American troops out.
Around that time there were several incidents of US troops killing innocent Iraqis, leading to negative sentiment toward the US. This didn't leave much in the way of good options, and aside from that, there was the initial lie that we wouldn't be there for years or decades. Basically enough people in the US didn't want US troops to remain there, and the Iraqis were in agreement. I can't say I blame them. I don't think Saddam would still be in power today or at least not for much longer, but we seem to make it a little worse each time we meddle there.
 

kds1

Suspended
Feb 17, 2013
818
314
New York, New York
Around that time there were several incidents of US troops killing innocent Iraqis, leading to negative sentiment toward the US. This didn't leave much in the way of good options, and aside from that, there was the initial lie that we wouldn't be there for years or decades. Basically enough people in the US didn't want US troops to remain there, and the Iraqis were in agreement. I can't say I blame them. I don't think Saddam would still be in power today or at least not for much longer, but we seem to make it a little worse each time we meddle there.
Well you know, fake WMD's and a very cynical plan to try and create some sort of U.S. foothold in the Middle East for oil under the guise of "liberation" did wonders didn't it? And I feel bad for Colin Powell, he was duped and made a fool of in front of the United Nations. A vey embarrasing time for the United States. And then there were "Freedom Fries"....Thanks G Dubs! Or maybe I should really be thanking the men behind the curtain: Cheney, Rove, Wolfowitz and Rumsfeld. They were the puppet masters to GWB's blockhead.
 

hulugu

macrumors 68000
Aug 13, 2003
1,819
10,237
quae tangit perit Trump
Things were copacetic until Obama pulled out the troops. Said another way, ISUS would not be part of our vocabulary had Obama left troops in place.
Possibly. On the other hand, the real breeding ground for ISIS was Syria, so unless we were ready to invade and hunt down Assad, we were going to face ISIS/ISIL and we might have found ourselves in direct asymmetric conflict with them rather than the Iraqis. And, the Iraqis may have been more willing to support ISIS because they wanted the US out.

If we really want to make that kind of argument, keep in mind that the vacuum created by the end of the Hussein and Gaddafi regimes has as much to do with ISIS as the withdrawal of US troops from Iraq.