I have Apple Care Plus for my black 32gb factory unlocked iPhone and my lock-screen button has failed. I talked to a genius and they said that the Apple store will replace my phone on the spot. So anytime I want I can get pretty much get my phone revived to a new one by replacement. Now I would get a 5S but if the trade-in value isn't worth it, I'll just wait for the 6 or next iteration of the iPhone. Paid around $830 for it and I'm searching the best route to obtain the most value that will go towards the new phone. T-mobile trade in offers $303 ... peanuts Gazelle offers $320 ... peanuts Craigslist goes around ~$550 ... ok, average but will want a little more and don't want to get shanked eBay completed listings bounce between $550-$800 ... this is great but what if the buyer claims some ******** delivery issue? So what do you guys think? Please share your experience on the best way to achieve maximum value for your 5.