I mean this is getting outta hand. Mine luckily only had the smallest nick on the bottom bezel that I barely even notice but clearly they have a manufacturing cluster ****** on there hands. These phone cost wayyyyy to much to be getting them scratched or with Dents in it right out the box. An for them to have all these replacements laying around and there damaged as well?!?!? I mean there has to be a statement made about this ASAP! No product no matter how much should be defective right out the box and clearly this isn't an isolated issue. Seems to be a huge problem all over and I'm sure there are people who dot even notice or dot care that aren't reporting this.Yes, the genius was happy to replace my phone (it wouldn't activate and had two nicks on the bottom). All four of the 64/black replacements they had in stock were already nicked, or scuffed, or damaged in some other way. I took the one with the least damage but will be back after they improve their manufacturing processes.
I have an original iPhone Genius Bar Work Authorization dated 2007-08-02 and it includes the entry:... could someone pull up an iPhone 4 work order to see if this is the case. I'm just curious if they started the cosmetic condition rating recently.