Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple's press release for the HomePod mini 2 last month touted "rich sound" and "advanced computational audio," but it did not explicitly mention if the second-generation model has better sound compared to the original. A few early reviews of the speaker, however, said that audio quality has in fact improved.

Four-HomePod-Mini-2-Surround-Sound.jpg
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Z-4195
I wonder how it is compared to the HomePod 2? I really liked my HomePod 2 but had to sell it, and I'm looking to get an another one soon.

I wonder if it would be better to get two HomePod mini 2 speakers for a room, or a single HomePod 2?
 
  • Like
Reactions: centauratlas
It is "louder". It has more bass. That is not indication if anything is better. The first one sounded crappy but was good enough for my bathroom. I guess we are not getting into anything hifi. But also it is a relatively cheap product and delivers quite some sound. So we can not compare it on some high level anyway just compare to other cheap speakers. But I would still wish for the review being more useful than "louder" or "more bass". Does the bass go deeper? What is the lower limit? What is the frequency curve? Are the bass overly represented. Where are spikes and gaps in the curve?
 
It is "louder". It has more bass. That is not indication if anything is better. The first one sounded crappy but was good enough for my bathroom. I guess we are not getting into anything hifi. But also it is a relatively cheap product and delivers quite some sound. So we can not compare it on some high level anyway just compare to other cheap speakers. But I would still wish for the review being more useful than "louder" or "more bass". Does the bass go deeper? What is the lower limit? What is the frequency curve? Are the bass overly represented. Where are spikes and gaps in the curve?
Confirmation bias, I purchased a new product it surely should have improved sound when in reality nothing was improved. Have to substitute and justify the purchase. 😅
 
It is "louder". It has more bass. That is not indication if anything is better. The first one sounded crappy but was good enough for my bathroom. I guess we are not getting into anything hifi. But also it is a relatively cheap product and delivers quite some sound. So we can not compare it on some high level anyway just compare to other cheap speakers. But I would still wish for the review being more useful than "louder" or "more bass". Does the bass go deeper? What is the lower limit? What is the frequency curve? Are the bass overly represented. Where are spikes and gaps in the curve?

Did you read the reviews? What's wrong with:
"The new Mini 2 had significantly greater range and louder, clearer audio than the first HomePod Mini" and "sounds noticeably better"?
🤔

Personally I prefer good sound before a nice looking curve.
 
It sounds maybe a tad better - your kidding yourself if you’re trying to say it sounds leaps and bounds better to the everyday consumers ear. My wife allowed me to give a Hopepod Mini 2 a shot and we compared it to my 5 year old Alexa echo. My hope was that I could finally start replacing my echo devices. Im sorry to report the HomePod mini 2 is going back. My wife had frustration that the wake word didn’t work as well as ‘Alexa’ (had to repeat ourselves regularly giving up with frustration) and it just didn’t respond as well when setting timers - it got easily confused. And for the life of me I could get Siri’s voice loud enough. Apple had one shot in my home to convert me and my family’s devices and unfortunately it failed.
 
At $150 dollars, is it worth it however? I feel like some people are grasping at anything to justify the higher costs because they want the latest and “greatest.” What if everyone just decided to not pay the higher prices of these products and just let them die? Would that drastically change the way Apple or other companies do business? If you know finances and the economy, please do let me know. It would seem like we are just taking the price increases and not protesting enough with our spending choices.
 
I wonder how it is compared to the HomePod 2? I really liked my HomePod 2 but had to sell it, and I'm looking to get an another one soon.

I wonder if it would be better to get two HomePod mini 2 speakers for a room, or a single HomePod 2?
In my experience, the big homepod will still give a fuller sound, just because of physics. It got a bigger speaker. But you could get an airplay receiver and 2 speakers with better sound for not much more than a single homepod. Then you'd also have Bluetooth connectivity and audio-in, and it would also be more future-proof.
 
I upgraded 2 of my minis last week.

I dont think I needed proof that the S10 would obviously have advantages over the S5...

But, my biggest gripe with the OG minis is their appalling Siri performance and indeed the mini 2 is significantly better in that regard.

Im surprised Apple havent made any mention of this but I suppose in doing so would just serve as a reminder that it was rubbish and to those sticking with the OG minis that they are having a much worse time than the new owners are.
 
For desktop use, I recently purchased a pair of Kanto Ora, which have an excellent uncolored sound, for less than a pair of HomePod mini 2 would cost. Mind you, these are for near-field use only and of course don’t feature a digital assistant. But leagues better in terms of sound quality.
 
Gotta love the scientific sounds reviews by these Tech writers. I got rid of my HomePods and Mini's and will never buy another Apple speaker again. Too many issues, average sound quality at best, and Apple doesn't seem to support them properly. It would be nice if the new Mini's sounded better though!!
 
I wonder how it is compared to the HomePod 2? I really liked my HomePod 2 but had to sell it, and I'm looking to get an another one soon.

I wonder if it would be better to get two HomePod mini 2 speakers for a room, or a single HomePod 2?
Recently, I got two HomePod 2 speakers as a stereo pair with our 2nd Gen ATV 4k. ($700 from Wal-Mart, holiday returns until Jan 31, 2027.) They sound great, a HUGE improvement over the stereo pair Minis we had. (I've suffered through those long enough as TV speakers.) There's no comparison between any Mini and the full-size HomePods (1 or 2).

However, on a whim I bought a JBL Bar 500MK2 as a comparison. (I got it for $500 on Amazon.) Holy smokes, that thing blows the HomePods out of the water for Home Theater. I'll be returning the HomePods and using the $200 I saved to buy groceries for my family of 7. I get the appeal of Smart Speakers, and Apple's ecosystem, and maybe the "Hey Siri" functionality, but I'm probably just going to ditch the ATV set top box, too. Plus, even with the new HomePods I got there is a distinct crackle when AirPlaying content (Music app or 3rd part app) at roughly 60% volume. It was consistently happening, but when I switched the AirPlay to the JBL it is always crystal clear. It makes me wonder if Apple's software quality is getting in way of what is a pretty decent speaker (the HomePod). I wanted to try a different (respected audio) brand because I just can't keep up with Apple's price increases.

We have an OG HomePod in our kitchen (obvi outside of the return window 🙂) that we use for timers and Music, and I'm considering replacing it with a HomeView. (I want to see reviews first, tho.)
 
repeat ourselves regularly giving up with frustration) and it just didn’t respond as well when setting timers - it got easily confused. And for the life of me I could get Siri’s voice loud enough. Apple had one shot in my home to convert me and my family’s devices and unfortunately it failed.
Of our HomePod OG, Gen 2, and Mini, all respond well and set timers and control HomeKit functions perfectly. I continue to suggest that most issues with Siri and HomePods of any kind stem from operator error. Good diction is rewarded, and proper grammar helps, too! Don't expect that a sloppy command muttered hastily over your shoulder will be comprehended properly every time. Neither me nor my wife has any issue getting good performance with any of our 3 different HomePods.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.