G3/600 or G4/550

If you had a choice between the two processor platforms - which would you go with?

  • G3/600

    Votes: 2 11.8%
  • G4/550

    Votes: 15 88.2%

  • Total voters
    17

gregorypierce

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jan 28, 2002
162
0
Not to really get into the numbers game, but if you had a choise of buying an iBook with the G3 or the powerBook with the G4 - (assuming both at +/- $150 of each other), which would you go with?
 

DakotaGuy

macrumors 601
Jan 14, 2002
4,022
3,286
South Dakota, USA
Okay let it rip on me I picked the G3 600...the reason I did is because I had the same choice when I got my iBook...to get the TiBook550 or the iBook600. At the time the TiBook was only a DVD ROM...this was a week before they added the Combo drive and there was a lot more then $150 difference in the two. I went with the iBook 50 more MHz, a Combo drive, and a lot lower price. What did I loose going that way...a larger screen (which is not a lot bigger now with the 14" iBook out) and the G4 processor, which I know is better then the G3, but I use my iBook for AppleWorks, IE, Email, iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie. For me the G3 works well and for all I saved...it was not a bad choice
 

palala

macrumors member
Jan 16, 2002
53
0
Long Island
hmmm

Well since you got a Mac, you really didn't lose...however I would have gone with the G4. If it was truly a $150 difference, then this is a no-brainer. You get a bigger, wider screen for starters. Second, Even though you gain 50Mhz with the G3, the power you have with the velocity engine in the G4 would more than make up for that. Almost every program you mention is optimized for the G4 and the velocity engine. I don't even think you can do transitions in iPhoto without a G4...not to mention that OSX runs much better on a G4. I would suggest that if you can cancel the order and get the TiBook to do that. Otherwise enjoy any Mac that you have as they are all better than the alternative.
 

BubbaTAC

macrumors member
Jan 12, 2002
43
0
good question

He raises a good question, and I would like ot hear more replies...imagine that the price difference is what we all know it to be. THe TI book is not that much larger, nthe drive is basically the same (whether it slot loads or not makes very little difference) and the ibook seems to be MUCH more robust, I have seen several Ti's suffer a lot from scrathing and flexing and simply getting gorss...even taken care of, but put in a sleeve to travel. The 14" ibook seems like a MUCH better deal, only difference being vido card and comparably clockec, but different core chips...so the questions is...
Is the G4 better on real world things like opening IE and word?


I know it is better for running photoshp, which I also do a lot, but three minutes is very little difference from 5...

I am debating the same purchase
 

arn

macrumors god
Staff member
Apr 9, 2001
14,794
2,228
Abercrombi:

I don't think you made the wrong decision... with the same choice - I would chose the iBook...

Why? The tiBook is significantly larger overall.... it certainly feels less compact. If I want a portable - I want it to be compact... the sort of thing I can toss into my bag or just grab easily...

If I was going to have a laptop as my _only_ computer - then I might reconsider... but I do have a desktopmachine as well.

arn
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.