I mean on one hand scuffgate was started because Apple anodized their aluminum in a manner that over time could seemingly have the color wear off. Whether you have a Black or White iPhone 5 this seems likely to happen. With the Black iPhone bearing the brunt of the criticism due to the more noticeable contrast. On the other hand are the obvious quality control issues that have new iPhone 5 owners opening the boxes to already scratched or dented iPhones. Both are issues but totally different and have seemed to kind of merge together as a singular complaint. At least with the way the media seems to be rolling with it. A little frustrating is all because they are both issues that in my opinion need be dealt with. Just my two cents.