I started this thread because it seems interesting to get opinions on this subject (coupled with my other thread about AVCHD editing on Mac). Anyway, I know FCE and even iMovie can be used pretty well for creating HD clips, but I would like to export these together with a DVD-like menu structure so I can choose which clips are displayed for example on my PS3. So essentially, I want to create a DVD with HD content (playable on newer devices like Popcorn Hour, PS3, Xbox360 etc...). iDVD seems unable to create a HD DVD, but downsizes to SD. I do not necessarily want to burn BluRay (too expensive) but quite a bit of (other OS) software easily allows to create a HD menu and export this to BluRay DVD discs (BluRay content and structure, but only written on DVD's so less long/less content).