P-Worm said:IBM is a great company and I'm glad Apple has a good relationship with them.
It's good to see the Power5! I think that SMT will make it into the derivatives Apple uses in their machines. In regards to your other question, there are two reasons: Firstly, IBM's 90nm/SSOI manufacturing process is not very mature yet and needs to have some kinks worked out of it. Secondly, doing the same thing with the Power5 that was done with the Power4 saves development costs, at least initially - plus it leaves room for the Power5 to improve once 90nm manufacturing becomes stable.Veldek said:I just hope they don't become to Motorola-like. The latest news didn't sound too good. Let's hope these new processor will evolve (soon) to a desktop version for Apple. Imagine 3.5GHz processors with SMT...
Edit: Does anyone wonder why these chips are manufactured by 0.13-micron and SOI-technology and not 0.09 and SSOI?
Veldek said:Imagine 3.5GHz processors with SMT...
No - the Power4/PowerPC G5 (970) did not have SMT support at release. IBM may have planned earlier to include it, but decided to hold off until the Power5 to use SMT.idkew said:i would imagine that this would be left out, in order to make the chip smaller, less complex and less expensive... i believe they did a similar thing with the power4/g5
That would be a huge step forward for the Mac world if it happened. Do you think Apple will dub IBM's Power6 the G6 and introduce it in 2006, for added effect?adamfilip said:Im sure when IBm makes the G5 replacement processor it will have SMT.
and i bet it will come next summer.
My Prediction for Summer of 2005 at WWDC
Dual 4.5 Ghz G5 Pro with SMT (equal to 4 virtual processors)
wrldwzrd89 said:That would be a huge step forward for the Mac world if it happened. Do you think Apple will dub IBM's Power6 the G6 and introduce it in 2006, for added effect?
pjkelnhofer said:Also, could some one refresh me on the difference between the chip that is currently the "G5" and the Power5 chip in the IBM server. I thought that one is a derivative of the other, but I am not really sure.
wrldwzrd89 said:No - the Power4/PowerPC G5 (970) did not have SMT support at release. IBM may have planned earlier to include it, but decided to hold off until the Power5 to use SMT.
I think Apple might just call the Power5 an enhanced G5 and save the G6 moniker for the Power6. It would be nice to see a G6 next year, but it doesn't fit with Apple tradition. Look at what Apple did with the 603/603e/604/604e (all considered "G2") and Motorola's 74XX series (all of them are called "G4" by Apple) for examples.Veldek said:Well, it's the Power5, so we might even see it next year... 😉
Yes - you were thinking about the dual cores. These were present in some Power4 models, but did not make it to the PowerPC 970.idkew said:sorry, maybe i was thinking of the dual cores then.?.
wrldwzrd89 said:I think Apple might just call the Power5 an enhanced G5 and save the G6 moniker for the Power6. It would be nice to see a G6 next year, but it doesn't fit with Apple tradition. Look at what Apple did with the 603/603e/604/604e (all considered "G2") and Motorola's 74XX series (all of them are called "G4" by Apple) for examples.
You are right, but don't forget about the problems IBM's been having getting reasonable yields from their 90nm manufacturing process. These problems surely were a factor in making the decision to go 130nm initially with the Power5, no?JFreak said:always remember that there are severe differencies with server class hardware and workstation class hardware, the reliability being the most important. it is actually ok to allow workstation to make calculation mistakes and have some amount of downtime, but in server hardware both of the two are severe mistakes.
server class hardware always has mature technology, not the latest and greates. so that's why no 90nm and no ssoi.
ibm technology looks very good. i'm really looking forward what apple can bring out within next six months. something's up, that's certain 😉