iChat Question


jameshalldotcom

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Oct 25, 2002
4
0
Baltimore, MD
Wow, quick reply.

Here's another one.

Other than iChat, is there a good, reliable AIM client that:
- allows you to edit your profile
- has most of AIM's buddy alerts
- allows you to automatically log conversations
- doesn't completely suck
- isn't Adium
?

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance,
James
 

alex_ant

macrumors 68020
Feb 5, 2002
2,473
0
All up in your bidness
I may be wrong, but I think profile editing (as well as away message viewing) is a feature of the OSCAR protocol which none of the 3rd party Mac AIM clients (Adium, Fire, Proteus) use. There used to be a banner-removal patch for the official AOL AIM client, which makes that client tolerable, but I think the author was forced to pull it, and it was for an older version anyway. (Not that I didn't save a copy onto my hard disk before it was pulled :D)
 

mischief

macrumors 68030
Aug 1, 2001
2,920
0
Santa Cruz Ca
Oh sure, qualify the thing to death.

Originally posted by jameshalldotcom


Other than iChat, is there a good, reliable AIM client that:
- allows you to edit your profile
- has most of AIM's buddy alerts
- allows you to automatically log conversations
- doesn't completely suck
- isn't Adium

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance,
James
AIM's actual Client would be the only one I can think of that meets all those criteria. I'm actually really enjoying iChat and before Jag I was using Adium. It would help for you to define what precisely you qualify as "suckage" so we can better help you. I suggest you actually play with Adium, AIM or iChat for more than a couple minutes before deciding they suck.
 

jameshalldotcom

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Oct 25, 2002
4
0
Baltimore, MD
Thanks for the reply.

None of the 3 clients mentioned really suck, they just don't really meet my needs, and if there's something better out there, I'd be interested in it.

Not being able to edit my profile eliminates iChat, not being able to see away messages eliminated Adium, and the official AIM Client is a little slow, bulky, and advertisment-ridden for my tastes. But obviously, if there are no better alternatives, I'll just go back to the official AIM client. Are there any better alternatives? Are there any in the works?

Does Trillian have a MAC version?
 

mischief

macrumors 68030
Aug 1, 2001
2,920
0
Santa Cruz Ca
Welllllllll............

As to editing your profile.... Adium works. I rarely IM with anyone who's not on my Buddy List and don't really pay attention to profiles so iChat has served well. Most 3rd party clients are based on the same opensource code that Adium is written from and therefore are equally as limited.

I keep Adium in my Dock and switch to it when I can't see someone through iChat that I think may be looking to get ahold of me..... there are some issues with iChat not "seeing" 3rd party clients.

Most of my IM communication is perfect for iChat: a bit of file sharing and a lot of basic networking. Both iChat and Adium can be set to Log Chat sessions and have multiple options for AIM sounds and alert actions.
 

jaredcash

macrumors newbie
Oct 25, 2002
5
0
Originally posted by jameshalldotcom
Thanks for the reply.

None of the 3 clients mentioned really suck, they just don't really meet my needs, and if there's something better out there, I'd be interested in it.

Not being able to edit my profile eliminates iChat, not being able to see away messages eliminated Adium, and the official AIM Client is a little slow, bulky, and advertisment-ridden for my tastes. But obviously, if there are no better alternatives, I'll just go back to the official AIM client. Are there any better alternatives? Are there any in the works?

Does Trillian have a MAC version?
There is Proteus which is AIM, MSN, Jabber, ICQ, and Yahoo all rolled into one. Fire is a similar product, though much buggier, in my opinion. But I haven't used either in a while, so it's hard to tell. I wouldn't necessarily give up entirely on iChat just yet, however. There will be an update to it in the next system software revision through Software Update which should be available within a month. It's said to to fix a lot of bugs in iChat (thoughI've only ever seen one bug) and probably add features, as well. We'll see, though.

Jared