AppleCare+ doesn't cover purely cosmetic damage, you probably won't get a replacement if it's only "scratched up".
This is completely false. AppleCare+ will replace the watch for whatever reason you want up to 2 times for $69 each time. After that it won't replace it for cosmetic damage. I just replaced my S0 due to a scratched screen so I could gift it to someone for xmas after i got my new black SS with link S2 on launch day. I even had them send me the new one before I sent in the old one.
From AC+ terms and conditions:
"(v) The Plan does not apply to cosmetic damage to the Covered Equipment, including but not limited to scratches and dents that do not otherwise affect the functionality of the Covered Equipment."
A scratched screen affects the functionality of the AW. Normal wear and tear on the body (or elsewhere) doesn't. We do not know what the OP meant by "badly scratched up."
well I have never had an issue getting anything from iPhones to applewatches replaces purely due to cosmetic damages and when AppleCare+ was almost up I wanted to get a replacement so I could sell a flawless phone (this doesn't happen anymore as I just give the phone back to tmobile and grab the latest one). If a service rep ever told me now and cited the paragraph above I would smash the crap out of it while they were on the phone and be like "oh no I just accidentally fell and smashed it" lol.
That's called fraud. Lenient Apple Store employees and too many people swapping out when they feel like a new replacement is exactly why Apple has jacked up the AC+ deductible over time. Remember that the iPhone deductible used to be $49. They bumped it up to $79 then $99.
It's only fraud if I am trying to get it replaced without payment in my opinion. I paid for insurance I should be able to use it how i see fit if a repair is warranted. Like a car, if you came home and it was all scratched up but you didn't know why the insurance company (those that are worth crud I imagine) will pay for "accidental" damage minus the deductible usually at least 1 time per year. Is that fraud to call you insurance company to get it fixed?
The OP said they wanted it replaced under the warranty. They didn't mention Apple care +.
Not that the warranty would cover physical wear.
The OP also said they had a Series 1. So I bet they also have AppleCare+ and just didn't name it correctly.The OP said they wanted it replaced under the warranty. They didn't mention Apple care +...