I have an iPhone 4S on AT&T, and this thing has NEVER switched to the Edge network. Even in areas of poor coverage where it doesn't get a 3G signal, it always sticks to the 3G network. I was just out in an area where it didn't have good coverage - in fact, the phone popped up a message saying "Cannot connect to cellular network" - but for some reason it said "3G" the entire time. It never went to "E". Why is that? My old iPhone 3G on AT&T had no problem switching to E. Now I have the iPhone 4S on AT&T, and I still live and work in the same area, but it never switches to E when it can't get a 3G signal.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 4S never switches to Edge network
- Thread starter slapple
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Unless you are jailbroken, this issue will be fixed in iOS 5.1. Whenever Apple decides to release it.
That is weird, I have seen my 4S switch to Edge in areas of low 3G connectivity, but obviously I don't have the toggle switch. (not jailbroken)
Same here, though it's Sprint's equivalent of the slower network. It did it when I was in the ER for a few hours the other night, since it's in the hospital basement. I had to use their wifi, which wasn't much better. LOL
that's actually very different from a switch to EDGE, where a totally different radio interface is used. A switch from EVDO from 1x is pretty trivial (and technically still considered "3G").
So was this issue fixed in 5.1? I'm on 5.1 now and still have never seen my phone switch to Edge.
Weird then. This morning my phone just can't get a connection for some reason. The SpeedTest app can't do a ping at all. But it still says 4G, and won't switch to Edge.
i'd do a hard restart on your phone. Also if you have AT&T you won't have the 3G switch that people were talking about earlier in this thread.
I get edge whenever I want on my 4S via the 3G toggle of SBSettings
Exactly. I've had the same issue on other phones. They love 3G. That's one of the reasons I Jailbroke.
I can't believe AT&T is blocking the 3G switch. All phones should have it. Oh well, I do.
The areas in the Dakotas that are 3G-only never had AT&T service until they went directly to 3G after the Alltel divestiture. So, there are no areas that "no longer" have service.
EDIT: And WHY ON EARTH are people upping his post that's clearly wrong?
They had some native coverage before, I think, that would still be EDGE/3G. The new areas are 3G-only.
OK last night at home I finally saw my phone switch to Edge.
But today at my office the 4G network doesn't seem to be working. The SpeedTest.net app doesn't work, plus an app that requires the internet keeps telling me there is no internet connection. I have done a hard reboot and also a soft reboot on the iPhone, and it still can't get an internet connection. But it still won't switch to Edge for some reason. I know they have Edge around my office, because my old iPhone 3G switched to Edge frequently at my office. But this iPhone 4S won't switch to Edge at my office for some reason.
But today at my office the 4G network doesn't seem to be working. The SpeedTest.net app doesn't work, plus an app that requires the internet keeps telling me there is no internet connection. I have done a hard reboot and also a soft reboot on the iPhone, and it still can't get an internet connection. But it still won't switch to Edge for some reason. I know they have Edge around my office, because my old iPhone 3G switched to Edge frequently at my office. But this iPhone 4S won't switch to Edge at my office for some reason.
If there's 3G, it's going to stay on it most likely. The only reason it should switch is on the edge of 3G (no pun intended), and that's where the issue is.
Settings/General/Reset/Reset Network Settings. I don't think people do this enough. Who knows when or where tower upgrades take place... And resetting network settings is safe for jailbroken phones too.
I also have a 4S on AT&T (in NYC). I have never seen it automatically go to EDGE, even when 3G is so weak that it won't load any data at all. It just keeps trying to get a 3G connection.
Since jailbreaking and using the toggle, when 3G is not able to connect I will manually switch it to EDGE, and there is always a solid signal.
I truly believe that AT&T has something in place to keep the phone from switching in all but the most extreme circumstances because they want to move away from EDGE altogether, and that belief was reinforced by the exclusion of a 3G toggle in 5.1 for AT&T users.
Since jailbreaking and using the toggle, when 3G is not able to connect I will manually switch it to EDGE, and there is always a solid signal.
I truly believe that AT&T has something in place to keep the phone from switching in all but the most extreme circumstances because they want to move away from EDGE altogether, and that belief was reinforced by the exclusion of a 3G toggle in 5.1 for AT&T users.
They've been like that for years. Most AT&T 3G phones never had the option, even back when they were running god-awful PCS 3G.