HomeKit Is a SmartHome just "cool" or do they solve problems?


macrumors 6502
Jun 14, 2015
Just don't expect this stuff to change your life 100% for the positive.
Even when it doesn’t work 100% of the time my life has changed 100% for the positive. I’d love home automation even if it failed 50% of the time. Home automation has been life changing for me.


Staff member
Jan 23, 2005
I'll give a you a personal example where my home automation gear saved my bacon.

About a month ago I bought the Hubitat Elevation home automation hub ($69.99 on sale), mainly for some lighting and switch control. I also bought several of these Samsung moisture sensors ($17 each) to put under all my sinks. So about two weeks in I get an iPhone alert the guest bathroom leak sensor is showing "wet". I check, and sure enough, all wet in the cabinet under the sink from a slow drip at one of the water lines. This is a guest bathroom where we go weeks at a time without looking in that cupboard, so I'm thinking I would have had a a lot of water damage by the time I finally noticed the leak.

So yes, some of the home automation stuff is doing it just because you can and it is fun, but there are also things that can have real utility like my leak detector example.

71jAANEGGAL._SL1500_.jpg 71ttpykJl0L._SL1500_.jpg


macrumors regular
Aug 17, 2017
Like anything else, Smart Home tech is "cool" when it works and majorly annoying/possibly dangerous when it doesn't.

E.g., asking Siri to raise the thermo temp 3 degrees and instead she pushes it to 98.
I read some really poor reviews of Homekit enabled AC thermostats, hence I used old fashioned programable one. It works well enough for me, 70F when I leave the house at 730am and 80F when I come back home at 5pm.

Otherwise I have HomePod, Philips hue lights/motion sensors and Serena Shades. These have worked 100% of the time in the past 1 month based on my cell phone location, time of a day, sun rise and sunset.


macrumors 68020
Apr 24, 2013
New Orleans
It makes life easier for me personally. I wake up around 4am, and having my smart lights set to turn on at that time, and my AC to turn off makes it more likely that I will get up and not hit snooze when my alarm goes off in the morning. For me personally its not necessarily about solving problems, but definitely more of improving my quality of life.
  • Like
Reactions: serpico007