I think it's 100% fair to make the comparison. You have no choice but to compare the best each manufacturer at any given time. That's how it works. I'm surprised I'm reading so many Apple loyalists crying foul. These 2 phones are separated by about 6 months. Why do you feel the comparison is only fair when it's the iphone that's 6 months newer. Not only do I think it's fair comparing the GS3 to the 4s, but it will also be fair comparing the next iphone to what will be a 6 month old GS3. All things considered, the iPhone will always have a 2 generation advantage. So what's your opinion?