Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

JulianL

macrumors 68020
Original poster
I just got my first ever HomePod - a mini 2 - and I must say that so far I am not impressed.

I've heard all the jokes about wrong or unhelpful answers like "here's something I found on the web" or "Now playing the Weather Girls" when asked what the weather is but I'd almost prefer that to what I'm getting sometimes.

This might be pushing Siri's abilities too far and what I asked might not have been an appropriate question - for old Siri obviously because Siri AI is not yet available on the mini 2 - but honestly that is 100% not relevant and no excuse for the behaviour I see consistently after repeating the experiment multiple times. I have updated my HomePod to 27.2 and this is what I get..

Me: Siri...
Siri: <The top light starts swirling to indicate it is listening>
Me: "When is the next train from <My local train station> to <Another train station on a direct line from me>?"
Siri: <The top light carries on swirling to indicate it is still active>
Siri: <About 3 seconds later the light goes off>

... and that's it. No, "I can't help you with that" or "Now playing Crazy Train by Ozzy Osbourne" which would at least indicate that it had tried to process the command and failed or got it wrong but the only thing I get is total silence with only the swirling light indicating that it is doing anything.

I've tried rephrasing the question all sorts of ways but the result is the same, it just goes dark without ever saying a word back to me. Asking it about the weather immediately afterward such a failure does give me an appropriate response so it's not a total failure anywhere like a broken microphone array, it just seems to be totally ignoring some questions.

As the title of my thread says, is this normal behaviour for some questions?
 
How does it respond to a simple question that would be easy for old Siri?
If the mini 2 still has old Siri, just curious how you expected it to respond?
 
How does it respond to a simple question that would be easy for old Siri?
If the mini 2 still has old Siri, just curious how you expected it to respond?

Yes, it is old Siri. New Siri (Siri AI) isn’t available on the mini 2 yet (or any other HomePod).

Because it was old Siri I expected something like “I can’t answer that” or “I didn’t understand that” or some other failure message and that would actually have been OK given that I’m aware of old Sir’s limitations. What I consider unacceptable is for it to simply deactivate again without any response whatsoever. If you’re talking to it from the other side of a room and can’t see the light you wouldn’t even know it had heard the wake word/phrase so you’d probably think it hadn’t even woken up and repeat the question in a louder voice.

The behaviour I saw would be such bad system design that I’m assuming it’s very unusual behaviour, maybe some sort of glitch, rather than it being something that Siri does quite often hence my question about whether other people see this behaviour from time to time.

By the way, I had so little faith that old Siri would give a good answer that I wasn’t even going to ask the question (which is one of my test questions for smart assistants) but then I got a surprise. The previous question that I had just asked it was “how long will it take me to walk to <somewhere-nearby>?” Again expecting it to fail to give a decent answer but to my surprise it actually gave a really good and accurate answer. That made me think that maybe I had underestimated old Siri and that it actually had a good integration with probably Apple Maps route planning, which can also do route planning using public transport, which is why I thought that maybe it was worth trying it out with the train times question.

Incidentally, Google Assistant could answer that train time question with complete accuracy way back in 2018 when I got my first ever smart speaker - a Google Home Mini.

I suppose that maybe after Siri woke up it somehow thought that my question wasn’t me talking to it but misinterpreted the sound as being a TV or radio playing in the background and thought that it had false-triggered in which case I suppose a silent shutdown would be appropriate behaviour.
 
I’ve had both old Siri and Siri AI basically act like it didn’t hear me, for what it’s worth. They definitely need to fix that on Siri AI, but I’m not sure it’s typical for Apple to update tech they are phasing out.
 
I’ve had both old Siri and Siri AI basically act like it didn’t hear me, for what it’s worth. They definitely need to fix that on Siri AI, but I’m not sure it’s typical for Apple to update tech they are phasing out.

Thanks for the feedback.

I actually don't care too much about old Siri performance since I did buy my HPM to see what Siri AI is going to be like. It's my first ever HomePod so I'm obviously playing around with what I've got right now - which is still old Siri and - while I'm curious about what I consider a few cases of unexpected and unwelcome behaviour hence the questions here - knowing that this is just a transition phase while I wait for Siri AI to arrive on my device means I'm not going to get overly upset about things I don't like just yet and am happy to wait in the hope that they will get addressed with the Siri AI release.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatTribble
Thanks for the feedback.

I actually don't care too much about old Siri performance since I did buy my HPM to see what Siri AI is going to be like. It's my first ever HomePod so I'm obviously playing around with what I've got right now - which is still old Siri and - while I'm curious about what I consider a few cases of unexpected and unwelcome behaviour hence the questions here - knowing that this is just a transition phase while I wait for Siri AI to arrive on my device means I'm not going to get overly upset about things I don't like just yet and am happy to wait in the hope that they will get addressed with the Siri AI release.
I think Apple said the other day that they plan to keep iterating on Siri AI improvements. So you have the hardware for it. Hopefully the good updates will come soon. Congratulations on your first HomePod!
 
  • Like
Reactions: JulianL
Sometimes I wonder if I suffer from the "problem" of having too many devices listening for the Siri wakeup commands. I know that at times, I see a Homepod light up briefly and then stop and I think it's ignoring me. Then I see later that my watch or phone actually completed the request. Or I wonder if multiple devices heard it and each thought the other was going to complete the task, so it quit.

Whatever the case is, I too am hoping that Siri AI will eventually make some of this better. More likely, it will get worse before it gets better. At least with Apple's new focus on the smart home, I'm expecting more attention to be paid to the platform.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.