Originally posted by Nepenthe
Digidesign's Pro Tools LE/24 Mix/HD or whatever version you are looking at, and Emagic's Logic Audio are NOT direct competitors.
<snip>
Logic Audio is arguably the most powerful MIDI sequencing software on the market. The name "Logic AUDIO" is quite deceptive because, by nature, the application handles no audio data at all -it has always posessed audio capabilities, although *realatively* basic compared to pro tools (the audio in Logic Audio is fine for simple audio RECORDING (not multitrack)). Logic Audio's audio HANDLING is great. Its audio editing works if that is all you have, but personally I prefer dedicated apps like Spark.
In terms of MIDI ability/Audio ability
Pro Tools 2/10
Logic 10/4
Not trying to be mouthy, 'just want to set the record straight.
-trev
Likewise, but I have to disagree with you ... Logic Platinum has very sophisticated audio recording, editing, arranging, realtime processing, mixing and automation functions. Provided your hardware - computer and interface are up to the job, you can run large multitrack projects no problem from start to finish.
Of course, Logic is composition oriented and has extensive midi facilities, and an absolutely kick ass set of virtual instruments, including synths, samplers, vocoders and some top notch vintage modelled emulations - hammond, rhodes and clavinet.
There's no doubt that ProTools is a great piece of software, but if you want all round pro level flexibility your best bet is often to use Digidesign's hardware and let Logic be the front end (instead of ProTools).
Its worth noting that with version 5.0 thru 6.0 Logic has acquired some features that bring a "familiar" automation system, the marquee selection tool, project management, video playback from firewire drives, mp3 import/export *and* some great cpu management tools, which close the gap in areas where some ProTools users tended to shy away from using Logic.
http://www.emagic.de/products/ls/ls/index.php?lang=EN
..... if you want to know more
(and I would rescore Logic as 10/10
Cheers
Chris