Rebroadcast Request

Discussion in 'Mac Blog Discussion' started by MacRumors, Apr 26, 2003.

  1. MacRumors macrumors bot


    Apr 12, 2001
    In an interesting request (joerndyck at is requesting the following from a Satellite equiped user:

    Contact Person: joerndyck at
  2. Xerov macrumors member

    Jan 1, 2003
  3. sebimeyer macrumors member

    Jul 16, 2002
    How about using the stream that they will offer?
    Every time they did something like this they also offered a stream. The original iPod release is a good example for this.
    Do you honestly think Steve would not share his awesomeness with the world? Why rent the moscone center (or a room there) and not show it to people?

    Feel free to contact me for information where to send the $100, though. :D
  4. arn macrumors god


    Staff Member

    Apr 9, 2001
    actually - I don't think the original iPod had a live stream. They posted a qt after the fact.

  5. DaveGee macrumors 6502a

    Jul 25, 2001
    Just my .02 cents and I know I'm gonna stir up a who mess of angry comments from folks not located in the US but.....

    Things to think about...

    1 - By all accounts the Monday sat-cast / event seems to be 'big'.
    2 - When Apple has done 'big' events (in the past) Europe (western europe anyway) sats were put to use.
    3 - Content owners (movies, books, music, smaller software developers, etc) often have different deals (based on the country) and often specific contracts with local partners/distributers in other countries.

    Add it all together and it sounds like the event that Apple has on Monday may not be open to people located in places other than the US and/or North America.

    If this turns out to be true (and I hope I'm wrong) I'm afraid Apple will get the brunt of the anger. Will it be fair? No, but when has life been fair.

    In short: If the content owners tell Apple they can only sell in say North America Apple can't help it and if that's the case then it wouldn't make any sense to sat-cast an event to Europe when they can't access it.

    Hey maybe I'm all wrong here... does anyone know if Liquid and the other music services have any restrictions? That might be a good starting point.

    I did find this via google news groups that shows just how messed up content distribution is:

    "Right, whilst we at OD2 did encode the entire "Up" album we only have the rights to sell it for digital download in Europe. Liquid Audio handled all the sales in North America, which is where you purchased it. We both use slightly differently constructed systems for delivering the license that allows you to play the music."

    Another one:

    "We are restricted from even downloading the Liquid Audio samples from the site. Check out this lovely message: "The following song could not be added to your cart due to territory and licensing restrictions " "

    Finally found this on Liquid Audio:

    Q: What does the message:"Territory Restriction" mean?
    A: The song you were trying to download has a restriction to only allow downloading in certain countries. Territory restriction is a way for the music label/publisher or artist to control which countries their content is distributed in. Liquid Audio has no control over their decisions, nor can we override this restriction. In a future release of our Liquid Store you will be able to tell which songs are restricted, and to what countries. A large portion of the content in the Liquid Store is unrestricted.

    So who knows... either way don't everyone get all upset (at Apple) if insert-music-title-here isn't available to everyone...

  6. sparks9 macrumors 6502a

    Jan 29, 2003
  7. froggy78 macrumors newbie

    Apr 26, 2003
    I agree with DaveGee and I think that it´ll be that way.
    I´m from Europe and tried to access several music download services like pressplay in the past and everytime it said "Not available outside the US".

    By the way, there are several services offered by Apple only available in the US/Canada. The option to order a book out of iPhoto. Only available in the US.

    Even .mac only has basic support for Europe.

    I love Apple but everytime there´s a keynote I feel like "Will it be available over here?"

    I hope they signed contracts for a wordwide availability of the service, but if I look at the past, I think on Monday night , for me as a european mac user, the perfect system for legal music downloads will still be far away.

    But who knows. Maybe they´ll make it a world-wide test-drive for such a service...
  8. d.f macrumors regular

    Jan 11, 2003
    Good Point!!

    I hadn't thought about this. but i think you're on to something. I can think of one good reason - PRICE. It looks like it's going to be 60/99cents per track (according to the rumours). that wouldn't work in the UK - not because of the currency, i mean the equivalent (roughly 40 - 66 pence). the record companies would baulk at this idea. the UK and most of Europe has been a very good cash cow for most business, especially the record industry as we pay WAY more than the states fot the same product. Record companies use the same promo materials and product here so in effect they're paid the costly overheads of an album / singe and the revenue from UK / Europe is HUGE profit for them.

    in short, unfortuantely, i think you're going to be proved right. If Apple offered the US 99cents (66pence) downloads and the UK £1.50 (just over $2) for EXACLTY THE SAME TRACK, that would be a PR nightmare for Apple so i guess they're better of not doing it at all, for now.

    i hope i am wrong:rolleyes:
  9. DaveGee macrumors 6502a

    Jul 25, 2001
    Re: Good Point!!

    Well by my read it's not really a money thing in as much as a contract thing. The studios seem to have made previous deals with 'local distributors' in specific regions (where no doubt they made money doing it at the time) but now are prevented from allowing online services (not just Apple) from selling into markets where those contracts are in effect.

    The movie industry has the same 'deals' just look at the market, some titles available in europe and or japan before the US (and vice versa).

    If you ask me it's a mess...

  10. eribula macrumors newbie

    Apr 27, 2003
    Re: Good Point!!

    I don't know how expensive it is to live in Britain. But the costs of a album with 14 tracks are about 15 Euros here in Germany. So 99 cents for one song (EUR and $) would be moderately priced.

    --> Support Jörn Dyck and Mac-TV!
  11. bryng macrumors member

    Jan 5, 2003
    I would be surprised to see anything offered outside the US - try and sign up for one-click outside US/Canada and you will see what I mean!

    All Apple has really convinced the music companies to do is to get their feet wet with online distribution. Apple has obviously come up with a great system, but a small customer-base is likely to be quite appealing to the music companies in the first instance as well.

    If it goes off like a firecracker, there are plenty of incentives for Apple to expand the service - in some territories such as Japan, for example, where Apple is quite big and uptake of new technology is good. So at least that encourages them to look at the issue.

    I for one would still be pretty stoked with iTunes 4 and AAC audio support for my iPod...though that will only tide me over for a very short while!

    (maybe a week...?) ;)
  12. neutrino23 macrumors 68000

    Feb 14, 2003
    SF Bay area
    We dropped by an Apple Store on the way home tonight. It was just at closing time. They had a sign up inviting people to come in to watch the announcement at 10:00AM on Monday. I asked an employee and they said they thought there would be a webcast but they weren't sure.

    Just after closing we saw them take down one of the large posters. I assume they are getting ready to put up new posters tomorrow.

    There was also a sign inviting people to come to the store for an event on May 2 at 6:00PM.
  13. dobbin macrumors 6502a


    Jan 28, 2002
    I hadn't even thought of this, but yes that would sound about right for Apple. I wouldn't be surprised at all if we can't use the service in the UK.

    It would be a shame though, as I for one would definitely pay to d/l music to iTunes. Otherwise I'll just carry on using limewire to try music and buying CDs from CD-WOW if I really like it.

    Who loses out in this case? Well, me a bit, I guess, but Apple and the music companies will too.

    Lets hope for a Worldwide service to be announced in 4 hours!


    PS. Its the same for iPhoto books and prints. I have money burning a hole in my pocket waiting for these services to be offered in the UK. In the meantime I will spend my money elsewhere but I would really love some of those books......
  14. jimjiminyjim macrumors 6502


    Feb 24, 2003
    A big thanks

    Well - despite the fact that this forum didn't stay on topic - thanks to for streaming the news for us!!

Share This Page

13 April 26, 2003