MBA vs rMBP vs Lenovo X1 Carbon - for business school ?

Discussion in 'Buying Tips and Advice' started by smdewart, Jun 13, 2013.

  1. smdewart macrumors newbie

    Oct 11, 2005
    Hi - debating btw the following for business school (MBA):

    - MacBook Air 13"
    - Retina MacBook Pro 13"
    - Lenovo X1 Carbon

    Business school is very much Excel-based, and Excel is a lot better on Windows. That said, I'm a Mac fanatic, and would prefer to imagine that this computer will be for more than b-school.

    I certainly can run Windows via Parallels, but if I'm using Windows a lot on a Mac, would it be worthwhile just... to get a Lenovo?
  2. sick z33 macrumors 6502

    Sep 20, 2008
    Being this is for school, I think you would appreciate the battery life of the MBA, especially for Excel primary purposes. I would do the MBA which would be cheaper than the MBP depending on features.
  3. jlehman macrumors member

    Apr 16, 2013

    If your programs are mainly Windows programs and Excel is a big one, than i would stick with a Lenovo. You may run into more than one program that is Windows exclusive. Office runs better on Windows anyway. The MBA is an awesome product but you'll more than likely be putting Windows on it in a VM if you have any programs that make you use Windows. If you know what you're getting into i would say go with a 13" MBA with 8GB of RAM Minimum use it until you need Windows then do a VM. Of course this will add alot of cost onto the machine. So if you can't afford it (and as a college student don't buy stuff you can't afford just to have it) buy the Lenovo. I feel like you may have less headaches with the Lenovo just because the business world lives in Windows. If Excel is your main concern i think you might be ok. But what about Access or Visio or any other apps? Maybe ask your school's office or a professor or look at what's on a computer lab machine.

    I'm a Desktop Technician for my school as well as the only Mac Tech and i just cringe when having to fix "Mac issues" because more or less the people should just not have a Mac (mapped drives, network printing, various scripts that run to keep them happy on a windows network, Mountain Lion being a pain).
  4. smdewart thread starter macrumors newbie

    Oct 11, 2005
    Thanks for everyone's feedback thus far! How good/bad does Parallels run Windows apps like Excel? I've heard differing accounts of both performance and battery life -- with battery life taking a significant toll. True? If so - to what extent?

    It *pains* me to consider a Lenovo. Because I know that the moment I exit Excel, the rest of the experience sucks...

Share This Page