Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

caligurl

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Do I need to buy the new ATV to use 4 HomePods? Or will it be an OS update that my current 4K ATVs will get?
 
Do I need to buy the new ATV to use 4 HomePods? Or will it be an OS update that my current 4K ATVs will get?
Yep. You're gonna need the new ATV and new (v2) HomePods - mini or full size. So, potentially $900 for the ATV and 4 HP mini2s for surround sound.

Plus, after all of that, you get NO subwoofer and NO center channel. What a deal!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: caligurl
it is totally baffling why anyone would even consider this new feature unless they happen to have 4 mini's just laying around. A VERY good real 5 channel true surround with a sub-woofer, wireless surround rear speakers and excellent sound quality can be bought for LESS than the cost of 4 minis which do NOT have a sub nor a center . Save your shekels and buy a real surround system and use the minis for whatever they are good at.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PennHunter
is there is any indication that this can be paired up with a home stereo/3.1 system and a couple of mini speakers and get a semblance of surround sound ??
 
is there is any indication that this can be paired up with a home stereo/3.1 system and a couple of mini speakers and get a semblance of surround sound ??

No indication of such a configuration. And with Apple's "walled garden" approach, I'd doubt that it would ever be considered, let alone implemented.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robertmorris2
On the contrary, two Homepods in stereo sound sound really good for what they are. And, although it's not true stereo surround sound, you can add two more speakers to the output for even more sound. Again, NOT true surround, but it's a LOT of good sound overall! (Edited to remove Stereo for Surround, which is what I meant (see second sentence, unaltered). My bad for the confusion!)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: shakopeemn
it is totally baffling why anyone would even consider this new feature unless they happen to have 4 mini's just laying around. A VERY good real 5 channel true surround with a sub-woofer, wireless surround rear speakers and excellent sound quality can be bought for LESS than the cost of 4 minis which do NOT have a sub nor a center . Save your shekels and buy a real surround system and use the minis for whatever they are good at.
I hadn’t realized it required 2 minis with the HomePods. Actually hadn’t realized it required HP2! I have and extra pair of HomePods in the closet that I stopped using in the living room and was going to bring them in the den. But NONE of my items work so I’ll stick with my atv 4k version and my stereo paired original HomePods!
 
Yep. You're gonna need the new ATV and new (v2) HomePods - mini or full size. So, potentially $900 for the ATV and 4 HP mini2s for surround sound.

Plus, after all of that, you get NO subwoofer and NO center channel. What a deal!
Ya…… just sticking with what we already have set up!
 
  • Like
Reactions: shakopeemn
It genuinely baffles me when people claim that two HomePods aren’t true stereo, or that four HomePods can’t produce true surround sound.

Stereo simply means reproducing distinct left and right audio channels to create a soundstage. Two HomePods paired in stereo do exactly that. It’s not simulated stereo. It’s stereo. Likewise, surround sound isn’t defined by having a particular number of speakers, a separate centre channel, or a subwoofer. It’s about reproducing a sound field that surrounds the listener, with appropriate spatial positioning and separation.

Four HomePods positioned around a room, reproducing front and rear spatial information, absolutely are a surround sound system.

You can certainly argue that a well-designed traditional multichannel system might deliver better separation, accuracy or immersion. But claiming something isn’t stereo or surround sound simply because it doesn’t follow a traditional speaker configuration is confusing the technology used to reproduce sound with the sound itself.

John.
 
  • Like
Reactions: caligurl
It genuinely baffles me when people claim that two HomePods aren’t true stereo, or that four HomePods can’t produce true surround sound.

Stereo simply means reproducing distinct left and right audio channels to create a soundstage. Two HomePods paired in stereo do exactly that. It’s not simulated stereo. It’s stereo. Likewise, surround sound isn’t defined by having a particular number of speakers, a separate centre channel, or a subwoofer. It’s about reproducing a sound field that surrounds the listener, with appropriate spatial positioning and separation.

Four HomePods positioned around a room, reproducing front and rear spatial information, absolutely are a surround sound system.

You can certainly argue that a well-designed traditional multichannel system might deliver better separation, accuracy or immersion. But claiming something isn’t stereo or surround sound simply because it doesn’t follow a traditional speaker configuration is confusing the technology used to reproduce sound with the sound itself.

John.
True stereo sound, yes. True surround as in, multiple speakers with separate channels using the (now) old AppleTV 4k and Homepods, no. "Reproduced" or "simulated" sound is not real separate channels. When I select my front stereo pair, and my rear stereo pair to play at the same time, both stereo pairs play exactly the same sound. It does "spatially create" "simulated" surround, but it's not true surround with separate channels, nor does it claim to be.

Does it sound good, and am I happy with it, oh, heck yes. Not complaining at all.

@john.burn Sorry for the confusion, I used the wrong word in my post above. Fixed!
 
Last edited:
True stereo sound, yes. True surround as in, multiple speakers with separate channels using the (now) old AppleTV 4k and Homepods, no. "Reproduced" or "simulated" sound is not real separate channels. When I select my front stereo pair, and my rear stereo pair to play at the same time, both stereo pairs play exactly the same sound. It does "spatially create" "simulated" surround, but it's not true surround with separate channels, nor does it claim to be.

Does it sound good, and am I happy with it, oh, heck yes. Not complaining at all.

@john.burn Sorry for the confusion, I used the wrong word in my post above. Fixed!
Ah, I see what you’re doing now! You’re using two stereo pairs, one at the front and one at the rear, with both pairs reproducing exactly the same stereo signal.

In that configuration, you’re absolutely right — it isn’t surround sound. You’re simply playing stereo through four speakers, with the rear pair duplicating the front pair.

Four speakers playing the same stereo signal isn’t the same as a system that processes and distributes spatial audio information across four speakers to create a surround sound field.

So I think we’re talking about two rather different things. Your setup is dual stereo, whereas I’m referring to an actual surround sound configuration which the new HomePods can certainly do with the new AppleTV.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chadamorrill
it is totally baffling why anyone would even consider this new feature unless they happen to have 4 mini's just laying around. A VERY good real 5 channel true surround with a sub-woofer, wireless surround rear speakers and excellent sound quality can be bought for LESS than the cost of 4 minis which do NOT have a sub nor a center . Save your shekels and buy a real surround system and use the minis for whatever they are good at.
I am a big ATV and I couldn't agree more with this. 2k on 4 HomePods is insane lol
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.