I'm the second line in an AT&T family share and bought an iPhone 4S at launch last year. As expected, AT&T says I won't be eligible for upgrade until next May. However when checking eligibility in the Apple store earlier today, it came back that I was eligible for reduced discount upgrade on Nov 6. Now, this evening, I happened to check again with the Apple Store app on my phone, and its showing eligibility on Oct 6. I'm not sure whether to believe either one. Of course, I will be checking again on those dates, and I do recognize that FULL discount eligibility remains next May, but what I'm not getting a clear message on is when I'm eligible for a reduced discount. Anyone else receiving info like this from Apple?