Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Nick not unique

macrumors newbie
Original poster
I've just expanded my Homekit device list to include some Aqara cameras - super, and I love Homekit Secure Video. I would like to add other devices to Homekit too, but where is the support for solar energy and weather station devices?... there's more to it than lux, temperature & humidity readings: what about my rainfall, wind speed and electricity production/consumption?? I like the sound of the soon-to-be-released HomeOS and HomePod/Homepad, but shouldn't Apple be getting basic home parameters on board as a priority first? I'm frustrated: there are work-arounds by using Homebridge or Home Assistant but then, for example, rainfall quantity cannot be expressed in inches or mm but values can be fiddled to display as percent brightness or humidity. Well done to those who have found these solutions, but this is crazy, isn't it? When are Apple going to allow other units to be used such as mm, kph, kW etc?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shifts and srl7741
I've got more to say (sorry): for me, a home control system such as Homekit should be able to do more than just control things: display is also important, which is why I'm looking forward to HomeOS and the possibility of a wall-mounted screen. But how can I display my daily rainfall or power consumption? I also want to display temperatures that can be read from a distance... so I don't like the sound of one of the new HomeOS features that only gives you more data as you approach: that means all the data values will be tiny, for sure, and not visible from a distance.
I'm surprised that the Avery Home app hasn't had more takers - it's great, as any Homekit device or value can be displayed at any size... I attach the screen I use from an old always-on iPad which gives me both visual information from a distance as well as control buttons.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0277.png
    IMG_0277.png
    541.7 KB · Views: 109
There are so many things I think Apple could do here, even if I am only mildly (very very mildly) using Homekit. Can almost not say I actually am, even if a few lights and speakers are connected.

You spoke of daily rainfall, which made me think of outdoor temperature sensors. I'd love to see outdoor sensor connect via Homekit and display the actual reading in the Apple Weather app, while on my home wi-fi. If leaving home, whatever info the weather app has for my location could be displayed instead.

It is a no-brainer use case to me, similar to yours, which I am 100% sure will not be delivered.

At home I have seven indoor temperature sensors (1 Apple Homepod Mini, 2 Philips Hue motion sensors, 4 Tapo temperature and humidity sensors), and would love to have Apple Home display an average (as well as the individual readings) of all, and same with humidity.

The Tapo ones are a pipedream though, as they can't be connected to Apple Home afaik (thought it would be possible, but in practicallity no). But in principal, I'd see it could/should work like that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QuarterSwede
I totally agree. You could probably get your average displayed by using Home Assistant to do the maths and then sending it back to HomeKit... but no way directly with Homekit. My main beef is that there are two types of environments that Homekit completely ignores:
1. weather data (apart from temperatures, humidity and lux brightness)
2. solar and grid energy and power (kW & kWh)
Both these groups contain entities essential for the control of my home (close the blinds when it's too windy, charge the car rather than send the power back to the grid). It's nice to see all these rumours of HomeOS and a 'homepad', but it seems to me that the Apple infrastructure isn't there to support such a venture meaningfully... 🙁
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shifts
I totally agree. You could probably get your average displayed by using Home Assistant to do the maths and then sending it back to HomeKit... but no way directly with Homekit. My main beef is that there are two types of environments that Homekit completely ignores:
1. weather data (apart from temperatures, humidity and lux brightness)
2. solar and grid energy and power (kW & kWh)
Both these groups contain entities essential for the control of my home (close the blinds when it's too windy, charge the car rather than send the power back to the grid). It's nice to see all these rumours of HomeOS and a 'homepad', but it seems to me that the Apple infrastructure isn't there to support such a venture meaningfully... 🙁

While I can appreciate the sentiment and there is definitely room for improvement Apple goes out of their way to avoid too much raw data in the Home app.

If you just want an automation for something like wind speed just make one in the automation app. Create Home Automation (its at the bottom) in the Shortcut app or convert to shortcuts in the Home app. "When X arrives Home, Get weather at current location, If wind speed is greater than X mi/hr, Set Blinds, Otherwise, End If".

It doesn't need to be a HomeKit device either (personal automation). I have one that rooms my Roomba vacuum 3 days a week when I leave for work.

AppIntents framework has been around for years for developers to use with Shortcut automations, Widgets, Siri, etc. Apple can implement all the framework kits, and APIs they want, doesnt mean a developer will use them, especially considering Home/Shortcut moves you outside the developers eco$y$tem. Energy usage is a good example, Apple has utility usage stats in the app if the utility provider implements it (mine won't).
 
If you dont wanna go full Home Assistant, Homebridge is a good way to easily integrate more sensors and weather stations not supported by Homekit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Genelec8341
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.