Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

Should I switch to a Samsung Galaxy S10 5G or keep my iPhone XS Max?

cinnabun814

Suspended
Original poster
Apr 2, 2018
111
83
I don't know why but I've been flirting with the idea of switching to a Samsung for a while now. I've played with it in stores and I didn't particularly like it I just find that iOS has gotten stale. I currently have a macbook pro, ipad pro, apple watch, airpods, multiple apple tvs, so i'm not sure whether or not it's a good idea to break out of the ecosystem. My iphone does more than everything I need it to do and i've never had a single problem with any iphone i've owned since the 4. I just for some reason want to try out an Android but my brain is telling me it's a terrible idea and that my XS Max is almost paid off. Any thoughts/suggestions?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alundra

Shanghaichica

macrumors G5
Apr 8, 2013
12,188
9,174
UK
The S10 plus is a great phone and a worthy purchase. However considering you already have several other Apple devices it might be better to stay with your iPhone. The S10 + won’t work as well with your Apple devices as an iPhone would and some like the Apple Watch don’t work at all. Obviously you could still use your iPad, Apple TVs and Mac with the S10 + but it depends on how much you rely/covet integration between your devices and your willingness to replace some with devices made by other manufacturers or how much you use Apple’s apps and services.

I’ve also thought about switching to the S10+ and other Samsung phones in the past but what ultimately keeps me with the iPhone is the ecosystem. I have an Apple Watch, 2 iPads, a MacBook, 2 Apple TVs, 2 HomePods and AirPods and for me it’s not worth the hassle of switching as excellent as the S10+ is. I also use a lot of Apple’s services such as iCloud Photo Library, iCloud Drive storage and keychain to name a few. I’ve also bought hundreds of TV shows and movies over the years and currently would have no way of playing them on a non Apple/windows device.
 
Comment

Apple_Robert

Contributor
Sep 21, 2012
18,392
20,060
In the middle of several books.
The S10 plus is a great phone and a worthy purchase. However considering you already have several other Apple devices it might be better to stay with your iPhone. The S10 + won’t work as well with your Apple devices as an iPhone would and some like the Apple Watch don’t work at all. Obviously you could still use your iPad, Apple TVs and Mac with the S10 + but it depends on how much you rely/covet integration between your devices and your willingness to replace some with devices made by other manufacturers or how much you use Apple’s apps and services.

I’ve also thought about switching to the S10+ and other Samsung phones in the past but what ultimately keeps me with the iPhone is the ecosystem. I have an Apple Watch, 2 iPads, a MacBook, 2 Apple TVs, 2 HomePods and AirPods and for me it’s not worth the hassle of switching as excellent as the S10+ is. I also use a lot of Apple’s services such as iCloud Photo Library, iCloud Drive storage and keychain to name a few. I’ve also bought hundreds of TV shows and movies over the years and currently would have no way of playing them on a non Apple/windows device.
You have a longterm marriage with Apple. :D

OP,
Jesus will still love you if you get a Sammy but, all bets are off with the forum members. :eek:
 
Comment

nrvna76

macrumors 65816
Aug 4, 2010
1,151
1,162
I don't know why but I've been flirting with the idea of switching to a Samsung for a while now. I've played with it in stores and I didn't particularly like it I just find that iOS has gotten stale. I currently have a macbook pro, ipad pro, apple watch, airpods, multiple apple tvs, so i'm not sure whether or not it's a good idea to break out of the ecosystem. My iphone does more than everything I need it to do and i've never had a single problem with any iphone i've owned since the 4. I just for some reason want to try out an Android but my brain is telling me it's a terrible idea and that my XS Max is almost paid off. Any thoughts/suggestions?

If boredom is the only reason (and I get that), I think you’ll end up regretting it and switching back. Maybe try some new apps or services to help the boredom.

Or start setting up google services to make the switch easier.
 
Comment

mtneer

macrumors 68030
Sep 15, 2012
2,944
2,205
Your phone is a tool - and by your own admission, it does everything you want it to do. So, the wise thing is not to sink capital into replacing/ buying another phone and instead invest it in another area of your life (savings, college, business, whatever your station in life maybe)
 
Comment

LIVEFRMNYC

macrumors 604
Oct 27, 2009
7,759
9,452
I don't know why but I've been flirting with the idea of switching to a Samsung for a while now. I've played with it in stores and I didn't particularly like it I just find that iOS has gotten stale. I currently have a macbook pro, ipad pro, apple watch, airpods, multiple apple tvs, so i'm not sure whether or not it's a good idea to break out of the ecosystem. My iphone does more than everything I need it to do and i've never had a single problem with any iphone i've owned since the 4. I just for some reason want to try out an Android but my brain is telling me it's a terrible idea and that my XS Max is almost paid off. Any thoughts/suggestions?


It's not a terrible idea, but it's going to take some investment. And not just financially like getting a new smart watch, earbuds, fast wireless charger, or other accessories. But an investment in redesigning your own ecosystem, and getting used to the way Android works. Plenty of switchers give up very quickly.

You've already made the first mistake (for lack of better word) in being fully engulfed in Apple's ecosystem.

I would personally suggest, slowly moving to Google services, like syncing contacts, calendar, voicemail (via Google Voice), and etc, while you're still using the iPhone. This will make for an easier transition.

The Pros will be the freedom, features, and compatibility.
The Cons will be the lack of integration with your other Apple devices, and Google nor Samsung is designed to hold you hand.
 
Comment

pika2000

Suspended
Jun 22, 2007
5,587
4,899
I don't know why but I've been flirting with the idea of switching to a Samsung for a while now. I've played with it in stores and I didn't particularly like it I just find that iOS has gotten stale. I currently have a macbook pro, ipad pro, apple watch, airpods, multiple apple tvs, so i'm not sure whether or not it's a good idea to break out of the ecosystem. My iphone does more than everything I need it to do and i've never had a single problem with any iphone i've owned since the 4. I just for some reason want to try out an Android but my brain is telling me it's a terrible idea and that my XS Max is almost paid off. Any thoughts/suggestions?
Sell all your Apple stuff NOW since they are doomed anyway (anytime soon, probably, I think). 5G Samsung is now and you don’t have to upgrade anymore for years to come (until you move a few feet away and no 5G coverage).

/s
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wide opeN
Comment

tranceking26

macrumors 6502a
Apr 16, 2013
860
634
Not that you need reminding, but iOS is getting updated in the near future, so maybe give it till then, then see if it's still boring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GrumpyMom
Comment

SteveJUAE

macrumors 68040
Aug 14, 2015
3,522
3,609
Land of Smiles
I don't know why but I've been flirting with the idea of switching to a Samsung for a while now. I've played with it in stores and I didn't particularly like it I just find that iOS has gotten stale. I currently have a macbook pro, ipad pro, apple watch, airpods, multiple apple tvs, so i'm not sure whether or not it's a good idea to break out of the ecosystem. My iphone does more than everything I need it to do and i've never had a single problem with any iphone i've owned since the 4. I just for some reason want to try out an Android but my brain is telling me it's a terrible idea and that my XS Max is almost paid off. Any thoughts/suggestions?
I'm not so sure going cold turkey is the best course of action to suit your curiosity etc for now

You don't have to opt for the flagship models initially IMO for $3-500 you can get a a very good Android device especially 2nd hand

I would try running an Android device as an experiment in frugality to chase out the excess in your current ECO and see how far you can go. I expect you will be amazed at your excess and savings possible just because of convenience

Even those with $100's if not $1000 of moves etc can still access them with a cheap/old Ipad

I would even try a simple carrier with no sms and 5GB data plan than the usual carriers unlimited bundles costing 5 or 6 times more

You can then decide how far you want to go extracting yourself or just sell the phone :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shanghaichica
Comment

torana355

macrumors 68040
Dec 8, 2009
3,517
2,533
Sydney, Australia
Seen it all before, people switch to Android because they are bored but expect things to work the same way as on iOS and inevitably switch back.

Unless you are really committed to change just stick with your iPhone. Android is different and it takes time to adjust and find new ways of doing things. However if you put in the time it has more potential then iOS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nikster0029
Comment

Cnasty

macrumors 68040
Jul 2, 2008
3,230
1,955
Stay with your iPhone and buy the S10+ in a couple months for a few hundred if you really want it as Samsung devices are the worst in the biz at keeping their value.

This gives you the best of both to dabble in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GrumpyMom
Comment

GrumpyMom

macrumors G3
Sep 11, 2014
9,192
13,192
I have spent the last 3 or 4 years laying the groundwork to leave Apple. I don’t know how, but I’m probably more entrenched now. :eek:

I think Apple Maps in conjunction with my Apple Watch was my undoing. Doing lane changes to get on and off roads is a tricky maneuver where I live. Our traffic is so bad everywhere because we have corrupt civic planning. I find that my Apple Watch tapping my wrist to get me ready for a lane change is a huge game changer in making me a more confident driver who will get to my destination with no missed turns.

The best I’ve been able to do is use my Android phone “flavor of the month” on a second line.

And I’m about to lend my dad the sim for that second line so my connected phone will be only my Xr.

By the way, my husband prefers his Android phones for a lot of reasons but had to go back to his Max because notifications were coming in delayed and bunched together. I’ve seen other people complain about that. Has that been fixed?

He also had a few key apps he did prefer on iOS as opposed to their Android versions.

I have a Samsung watch I really love. But Apple keeps building in more functionality into their watches and Samsung hasn’t quite matched that yet, at least not in watches small enough to suit me.
 
Comment

drinkingtea

macrumors 6502a
Jan 31, 2016
650
1,264
By the way, my husband prefers his Android phones for a lot of reasons but had to go back to his Max because notifications were coming in delayed and bunched together. I’ve seen other people complain about that. Has that been fixed?

I just asked about this in the OnePlus 7 Pro thread. I’ve had mixed answers to this question. One of the reasons I went back to my iPhone is because my notifications were coming in late on the Pixel 3 XL (and/or bunched together) and that’s really frustrating, especially when I need to interact with certain apps immediately. I’d really like to switch to the 7 Pro, but if this issue still persists (it sounds like it does), then I most likely won’t.
 
Comment
Had all the notes and S series, including S10 plus. Just ordered Xsmax. I am done with samsung. I will not disclose why, other than the instability of samsung's ecosystem. 13 years of samsung and other androids. As for 5g, NETWORK/DEVICE connectivity is sketchy at present.
 
Comment

yui4

macrumors 6502a
May 26, 2011
993
704
I just asked about this in the OnePlus 7 Pro thread. I’ve had mixed answers to this question. One of the reasons I went back to my iPhone is because my notifications were coming in late on the Pixel 3 XL (and/or bunched together) and that’s really frustrating, especially when I need to interact with certain apps immediately. I’d really like to switch to the 7 Pro, but if this issue still persists (it sounds like it does), then I most likely won’t.
I've had my s10+ for a while. I'm not sure which notifications people are talking about exactly as I haven't encountered an issue with anything generally
 
Comment

Tig Bitties

macrumors 68040
Sep 6, 2012
3,795
2,554
If your looking to upgrade from the XS Max, what about the OnePlus 7 Pro? That's supposed to be a amazing, and the Oxygen OS very smooth fast, and the 90hz display butter.
 
Comment

nburwell

macrumors 601
May 6, 2008
4,896
1,811
DE
I believe if the OP does in fact switch to Galaxy, they will most likely come back to iOS in due time. It certainly doesn't help that they are deeply ingrained in the Apple ecosystem either. The Galaxy will not play nice with their Apple products at home.

Like the OP, I have considered moving to Galaxy (and Pixel), but it's just not worth it for me. Considering our house is all Apple products. If they can, buy a used Galaxy on Swappa and play around with it for a week. If they don't like it, they can always sell the device.

iOS 13 is going to be released in a month and half (give or take). I'm sure that will make the iOS devices feel "new" to the OP with the new features and all. But ultimately it's up to them to decide on whether they go with a Galaxy device or stick with their iPhone.
 
Comment

mclld

macrumors 68020
Nov 6, 2012
2,286
1,345
Horrible idea

If you really want to try out Android, just buy a used older Samsung or a cheaper Android like a 3a or even a Pixel 2/3 used
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tig Bitties
Comment

cinnabun814

Suspended
Original poster
Apr 2, 2018
111
83
I made my decision. I’m just sticking with my XS Max and forgetting about it. It’s almost paid off and all of my stuff is Apple. Every single person in my contacts list has an iPhone as well. I just need to be happy with what I have and not chasing something else.
 
Comment

FFR

Suspended
Nov 4, 2007
4,507
2,373
London
  • Like
Reactions: Wide opeN
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.