Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple designed Siri AI on the HomeView to complete household tasks with natural voice commands and minimal follow-up questions, executives told The Verge, emphasizing simplicity as a key feature of the new home hub.

homeview-calendar.jpg
 
So Apple gave an interview to explain the (very limited) use cases because no one could figure them out when this was introduced
I predict Homeview will have a life very similar to Apple Watch: Apple launches it with the idea that the product can do a thousand different things, and then the product will become popular based on just a few basic features, that it does really well. And even though it will be easy to say “300 dollars just for THAT?”, it will slowly but steadily become a mainstay in home control.

I could easily see myself buying several of them, even though I can’t use Siri AI.
 
So Apple gave an interview to explain the (very limited) use cases because no one could figure them out when this was introduced
I mean, setting the temperature via natural language is nice, but how often are people doing that?

Most of my interactions with HomeKit are controlling lights (dimming lights in the kids bedroom etc.) but that is something I usually do in that particular room. I.e. with the phone or watch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Regbial and k1121j
I predict Homeview will have a life very similar to Apple Watch: Apple launches it with the idea that the product can do a thousand different things, and then the product will become popular based on just a few basic features, that it does really well. And even though it will be easy to say “300 dollars just for THAT?”, it will slowly but steadily become a mainstay in home control.
I predict Homeview will have a life very similar to Apple Vision Pro. Apple launches it with the idea that they'll be flying off the shelves, but it'll turn out only a small percentage of Apple customers are actually interested.

Only question is whether Apple then attempts to pivot and claim Homeview was intended as a limited technology preview for developers.
 
At a quick glance of the title, I see AI and killer.
The image in my head is killer bot... 🤣

And then after watching M3GAN. 🤣🤣🤣
 
  • Haha
Reactions: iLLUMI
Apple has a history of making complicated things simple, and it seems like they have the right attitude towards this. Their biggest competition is going to be their own products though, which can all do the same thing that HomeView does. The advantage that it does have is that it supports multiple users, so if it's parked in a central location where people come and go they can interact with it without having to drag their own devices around. It also works as home hub, which may open up some people to smart homes if they don't already have the gear.

It's also good that Apple is finally taking the home seriously, Apple seems like the company that could integrate smart home tech together as well as anyone. It's a ripe time to jump in, with Matter and Thread lots of products can potentially be added to an Apple home now where there was limited support before. If they really are serious remains the question though, if they keep dabbling then things will work fine but not be the futuristic home we all hoped that smart homes would be.

We will just have to wait and see what happens when these are released...I expect them to sell pretty well at first because of the cool Apple gadget effect. When reviews start coming in, and people start talking about how they use it, or if they give up on them because <reasons>, we'll get an idea of where things are headed. I'm not planning to buy one, but I can see a reason for us to have one in the kitchen for everyone to use...if the reviews are promising enough we'll think about trying it out.
 
I mean, setting the temperature via natural language is nice, but how often are people doing that?

Most of my interactions with HomeKit are controlling lights (dimming lights in the kids bedroom etc.) but that is something I usually do in that particular room. I.e. with the phone or watch.
I don’t need it to do much. Setting the temperature is less important than viewing it. But a pretty thing on the wall that shows me time, temperature inside and out, weather, today’s calendar events, and perhaps a random picture of the kids if there’s still room, I would buy that just as a display. If it can show who’s at the door when the door bell rings, that’s just a bonus.

I currently have in my kitchen: A clock, a controller for the heated floor showing inside temperature, a device showing outside temperature, a digital picture frame showing old kids’ pictures, and a paper calendar letting my kids know when I go on the next business trip (which I have been mulling over replacing with an old iPad as it is a moving target).

These are all trivial things, the killer app for me would be combining them into one nice looking device. Easily worth the price of admission.

And look at prices of professional home control displays. Custom installers are going to put these in every room of a house. For that purpose, it is super cheap even if it is just a “now playing” screen. There’s a whole host of mounting brackets to use iPads for that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: triom and Sir Ruben
Apple has a history of making complicated things simple, and it seems like they have the right attitude towards this. Their biggest competition is going to be their own products though, which can all do the same thing that HomeView does. The advantage that it does have is that it supports multiple users, so if it's parked in a central location where people come and go they can interact with it without having to drag their own devices around. It also works as home hub, which may open up some people to smart homes if they don't already have the gear.

It's also good that Apple is finally taking the home seriously, Apple seems like the company that could integrate smart home tech together as well as anyone. It's a ripe time to jump in, with Matter and Thread lots of products can potentially be added to an Apple home now where there was limited support before. If they really are serious remains the question though, if they keep dabbling then things will work fine but not be the futuristic home we all hoped that smart homes would be.

We will just have to wait and see what happens when these are released...I expect them to sell pretty well at first because of the cool Apple gadget effect. When reviews start coming in, and people start talking about how they use it, or if they give up on them because <reasons>, we'll get an idea of where things are headed. I'm not planning to buy one, but I can see a reason for us to have one in the kitchen for everyone to use...if the reviews are promising enough we'll think about trying it out.
I think you are missing the picture if you think the use case is to have one in a home. The use case is to have one in a room.
 
Lol these marketing spins always make me laugh. "Siri is still far behind competition but we focus on simplicity!" and then she focuses on asking Siri to set the thermostat as an example like are you for real? You could do that even before "AI" and yes, even from my phone that may be laying somewhere in the other room without yet another device
 
Is it my failure to understand, or Apple's failure of explaining, why I need HomeView? A little of both perhaps? Is Apple not aware of their other products that are seemingly just as capable as HomeView?

Well, good for Apple that I'd rather drop 2K on a Duo than 300 for HomeView.
 
Last edited:
At $299 it is priced favorably to compete with things like Google Nest Hub ($249) - Apple always charges a premium. I think this is going to turn out to be a modest hit.

The question is how willing are people going to be to give up work and personal details to Ai generally. As mentioned above, most of these devices are for setting the thermostat, and turning on/off lights.
 
HomeView is a home "dashboard". The Home Assistant home automation community creates hundreds of new dashboards every day. Creating a Home Assistant dashboard is a rite of passage. Dashboards look cool, so nearly every new user creates one (tellingly, they never use a ready made one, because the fun is in creating the dashboard, not using it). Only for the new shiny dashboard never to be used. Because dashboards are completely and utterly useless. A dashboard is diametrically opposite of what good home automation is - invisible.

Dashboards are useless and HomeView is a dashboard, hence HomeView is useless.
 
Is it my failure to understand, or Apple's failure of explaining, why I need HomeView? A little of both perhaps? Is Apple not aware of their other products that are seemingly just as capable as HomeView?

Well, good for Apple that I'd rather drop 2K on a Duo than 300 for HoneView.
“Why should I buy an iPad when I have both a Mac/PC and an iPhone?”

They are all just different ways to achieve the same tasks.
 
HomeView is a home "dashboard". The Home Assistant home automation community creates hundreds of new dashboards every day. Creating a Home Assistant dashboard is a rite of passage. Dashboards look cool, so nearly every new user creates one (tellingly, they never use a ready made one, because the fun is in creating the dashboard, not using it). Only for the new shiny dashboard never to be used. Because dashboards are completely and utterly useless. A dashboard is diametrically opposite of what good home automation is - invisible.

Dashboards are useless and HomeView is a dashboard, hence HomeView is useless.
I disagree, for the same reason the various attempts at replacing iPhone with screen-less assistants all fail miserably: Some information is simply best viewed.

Music is playing. I wonder who this artist is. I could take out my phone and find the app, or Shazam it of music is not coming from my phone (which it shouldn’t in good home automation). Or, I could look at the Now playing screen in the room. I sure as heck would not ask Siri.

The failure of Apple’s marketing is presenting it as a “do everything” device, when in reality most people will buy it to do ONE thing. Just not the same thing for all.

I have been very close to buying a “now playing” screen for my kitchen, that cost more than a Homeview, and didn’t do ANYTHING else.
 
  • Love
Reactions: zapmymac
Here's the facts though. Apple is lying to you.

The entire HomeKit control engine via Siri is actually the original Siri, not Siri AI.

Go ask your iPhone 18 Pro Max or Duo to "Turn off the bedroom lights and turn on the bedroom fan" and watch what happens.

Instead of the the new Siri AI engine sending a command to turn off the lights and another command turn on the fan. It will instead complain that you can't do multiple things at once, which is because it's still the original Siri engine.
The new Siri AI could easily execute different commands at once using the same API calls that the Siri Shortcuts app can access. But it can't...

We have still a long way to go before this stuff is really next gen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gleepskip and Velli
Music is playing. I wonder who this artist is. I could take out my phone and find the app, or Shazam it of music is not coming from my phone (which it shouldn’t in good home automation). Or, I could look at the Now playing screen in the room. I sure as heck would not ask Siri.

This use case implicitly presupposes that the HomeView is somewhere within your view when you want to find the arist. More often than not, it won’t be. It will require you to interrupt whatever else it is you are doing, to position yourself in front of it. Much more disruptive than glancing at your watch or phone, or asking a competent Siri.

This is one of the core problems with dashboards - they require your attention in a particular place.
 
This use case implicitly presupposes that the HomeView is somewhere within your view when you want to find the arist. More often than not, it won’t be. It will require you to interrupt whatever else it is you are doing, to position yourself in front of it. Much more disruptive than glancing at your watch or phone, or asking a competent Siri.

This is one of the core problems with dashboards - they require your attention in a particular place.
Your argument implicitly presupposes that I only have one. Redundancy is a core part of home automation. A Now playing screen, Homeview or otherwise, needs to be positioned in view from wherever I might actually listen to music. Currently I have one in my living room, which doesn’t help me in the kitchen, and in my pocket which is fiddly when I’m cooking.

Edit: As an example, I have a controller/display on the wall for the floor heating in every room where I have floor heating.
 
People keep missing the point of this device. It's a fancy light switch. Essentially a competitor to the control panels from companies like Control4 and Crestron.

People have been 3D printing wall mounts for iPads to use in this way for years this just simplifies the setup especially with the PoE and AC hardwired options. You don't need a full iPad for that and if you're buying multiple of them for a whole home setup the lower price helps tremendously.

It essentially allows people to build DIY systems similar to one of those high end home automation systems without having to pay an integrator. Just buy some Caseta switches and one of these for each room in your house and you end up with a functionally similar system for much less money.

I can even see people who would otherwise have bought a Control4 or Crestron system using these instead. Just install all your switches in a centralized location and then put one of these at the entrance and exit of every room and you have yourself a really clean setup without any switches on the walls just like if you used one of those high end setups but for far less money.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Velli
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.