So, getting sick of waiting for Apple to update the Mac Mini. I did it for them. And it works fantastically and the results speak for themselves. First the specs:
Original Mac Mini
- 1.5 Ghz Intel Core Solo
- 512 MB RAM
- DVD-ROM/CD-RW Combo Drive
- 120 GB 5400RPM Hard Drive
- 802.11a/b/g
The New Mac Mini
- 2.33 Ghz Intel Core2Duo
- 2 GB RAM
- Dual Layer DVD-RW / CD-RW SuperDrive
- 250 GB 7200RPM Hard Drive
- 802.11a/b/g/n
MacBook (Comparison Purposes Only)
- 2.0 Ghz Intel Core Duo
- 1.25 GB RAM
- Dual Layer DVD-RW / CD-RW SuperDrive
- 120 GB 5400RPM Hard Drive
- 802.11a/b/g/n
New System Profiler Screenshots
Due to the large size of the screen shots and for everyone's scrolling sake, I've attached the screenshots as attachments to the bottom of this thread. (Just in case you don't want to look at all of my testing)
Testing
I did a few tests for the things that I do most often and would like to see sped up a bit on my poor core solo mini. These are the following tests:
- Ripping a DVD using Handbrake
- Burning an iDVD Disc Image using Disc Utility
- Tagging a Ripped Movie Using Lostify
- Tagging Box Cover Art in iTunes for the Ripped & Tagged Movie
- Burning a CD Using iTunes
- Ripping a CD Using iTunes
- Converting a Windows Media File to MPEG-4 using EasyWMV
- Transferring a file from a firewire hard drive and to a firewire hard drive
Obviously none of these tests are by any means scientific as I used a simple stopwatch and didn't eliminate all variables. For instance, when I did all of the testing with the Core Solo, I didn't wipe the drive first. I did all of the testing with all the crap that has accumulated in their since I think I formatted it originally a year ago. Your mileage may vary.
If you want to skip the run down, here's the results for all the tests:
http://homepage.mac.com/idrivex/stats.pdf
Rip a DVD Using Handbrake
Here are the settings that were utilities in Handbrake:
The DVD was the Disney Movie "The Sword in the Stone". It is approximately 1 Hour and 20 Minutes. Here are the results:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 3 Hrs., 7 Min., 47 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 2 Hrs., 57 Min. 14 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 2 Hrs., 57 Min. 28 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 1 Hr. 24 Min. 18 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Hr. 15 Min., 38 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 2.2x
Tagging a Ripped DVD's Media File using Lostify
I like Lostify, I know others like MetaX, but whatever. With the Core Solo it was painfully slow. My point was to get it to speed up to be more in line with the MacBook I own.
For those unfamiliar with the Lostify tagging program. It's pretty much a one-window application that allows you to tag your files like this:
So why spend so much time tagging my files? So that when I use my AppleTV, it doesn't look like a 12 year old is managing my iTunes Library:
Anyways, I digress, here are the results for the Sword in the Stone Tagging:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 2 Min., 27 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 1 Min., 30 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 41 Seconds
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Min., 23 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 3.6x
iTunes Picture Tagging
So the final stage in my DVD Ripping is to tag them with nice pictures, not just a frame from the movie. I like to use DVD Box Covers and make them actually look like DVD Box Covers. To do this, I use Delicious Monster's Delicious Library. While you can do this with their trial version, I recommend buying it because it is one of the best examples of programming on the Mac Platform hands down. And no I don't work for them.
If you want to be able to do this, you'll look up the DVD in Delicious Library, add it to your library, and then look under the Synopsis tab.
Do a screen shot of just the DVD Box Cover (CMD+SHIFT+4) and it'll save to your desktop. Navigate in iTunes to where you can add the cover art and select it from your desktop:
Press the OK button and go surf the web, cause it's gonna be a while. This seems to only be a problem that I use Handbrake to rip, other movies that I buy from the iTunes Movie Store don't seem to have this problem. After it's all done though, you have a beautiful DVD library that you can scroll through in cover flow view:
Here are the results for the time it took from the moment I clicked "OK" to the time that iTunes was functional again (ie the image was tagged to the file):
Mac Mini Core Solo: 2 Min., 48 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 1 Min., 30 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 1 Minute, 1 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Min., 44 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 2.8x
So in essence it has cut my DVD Ripping, Tagging, and Adding to iTunes time to the following:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 3 Hrs., 13 Min., 2 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 3 Hrs., 2 Min., 29 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 2 Hrs., 59 Min., 44 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 1 Hr., 26 Min., 0 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Hr., 18 Min., 45 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 2.2x
DVD Burn Test
Now that we know how well it can rip and encode, let's see how it does at burning a DVD-Video. I took a small 100 MB or so video of the Fam and threw it into iDVD. In iDVD, I told it to make a Disc Image. I used Disc Utility to burn the Disc Image.
The image ended up weighing in at 1.13GB.
Sorry about the lack of pictures in this one, Apple just hasn't made DVD Burning exciting enough yet to warrant screen shots. The whole thing ended up being a wash anyways with what seems to be the only thing that matters is the speed of the DVD-RW. All of my tests came in at 6 Minutes and 15 Seconds across both the MacBook and all configurations of the Mini.
CD Burn Test
The CD Burn Test though was a little different. I used an album playlist in iTunes, Aerosmith's "Just Push Play". All of the songs have the same following attributes, except for different song names obviously:
The entire playlist comes in at 13 Songs, 53.6 Minutes, and 75.7 MB worth of Data. Press the burn button in iTunes and the following dialog comes up:
Click OK, Start your Stopwatch and this is what you get:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 6 Min, 10 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 5 Min., 29 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 5 Min., 30 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 4 Min., 40 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 4 Min., 49 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.3x
CD Rip Test
Now that we have our burned CD. We're just going to reinsert it right back into our Mini/MacBook and we're going to change the Artist's name when the CDDB info pre-loads (One - To avoid the warning message about importing dupicate songs and Two - To easily remove the duplicate songs for re-testing later). Here's the info on the file type, normal Audio CD File type:
Create a bogus playlist and drag all of your songs from the CD to the playlist. Get out your stop watch again and watch it rip away. Oh here are the rip settings:
Then after all of your testing is done, you find out this:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 6 Min., 23 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 4 Min., 31 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 4 Min., 50 Sec. (What the F?)
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 4 Min., 6 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 4 Min., 17 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.6x
Transcode a WMV File to an MP4 File using EasyWMV
Another hidden gem in the Mac world is a program called EasyWMV for converting WMV files to MP4 Files to view on your AppleTV or iPhone on the fly. I just thought this would be a good example of processor power for testing purposes. I'll spare you a screen shot of EasyWMV's insanely simple user interface and instead show you what the WMV file looked like before:
and after the transcoding to an Mp4 file:
These are your results:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 9 Min., 6 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 8 Min., 11 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 7 Min., 7 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 6 Min., 59 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.3x
Transferring Data from a FireWire Hard Drive and to a FireWire Hard Drive
This is also one of those things that doesn't really involve screen shots to be an effective presentation. I will tell you this though, the test file that was being dragged back and forth was a 247.3 MB TV Show Episode purchased off of the iTunes Music Store. It is an MPEG-4 Video File. 640x480, AAC Protected, yada yada yada.
Results: (From FW / To FW)
Mac Mini Core Solo: 12.5 Seconds / 13.3 Seconds
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 10.1 Seconds / 10.2 Seconds
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 10.5 Seconds / 10.3 Seconds
MacBook Core Duo: 12.0 Seconds / 13.4 Seconds
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.2x / 1.3x
So that's pretty much everything. I waited a long @ss time for Apple to update the Mini with all of these features I wanted so that I could finally drop my long in the tooth Mac Mini Core Solo. But with processor prices dropping and no "Mini Event" in sight, I finally bit the bullet. I also figure that I'm going to give it a little coat of paint courtesy of Colorwarepc.com. I figure that they'll eventually make the new Mini look like the MacBooks and iMacs, so why not also get a jump start on that as well:
Original Mac Mini
- 1.5 Ghz Intel Core Solo
- 512 MB RAM
- DVD-ROM/CD-RW Combo Drive
- 120 GB 5400RPM Hard Drive
- 802.11a/b/g
The New Mac Mini
- 2.33 Ghz Intel Core2Duo
- 2 GB RAM
- Dual Layer DVD-RW / CD-RW SuperDrive
- 250 GB 7200RPM Hard Drive
- 802.11a/b/g/n
MacBook (Comparison Purposes Only)
- 2.0 Ghz Intel Core Duo
- 1.25 GB RAM
- Dual Layer DVD-RW / CD-RW SuperDrive
- 120 GB 5400RPM Hard Drive
- 802.11a/b/g/n
New System Profiler Screenshots
Due to the large size of the screen shots and for everyone's scrolling sake, I've attached the screenshots as attachments to the bottom of this thread. (Just in case you don't want to look at all of my testing)
Testing
I did a few tests for the things that I do most often and would like to see sped up a bit on my poor core solo mini. These are the following tests:
- Ripping a DVD using Handbrake
- Burning an iDVD Disc Image using Disc Utility
- Tagging a Ripped Movie Using Lostify
- Tagging Box Cover Art in iTunes for the Ripped & Tagged Movie
- Burning a CD Using iTunes
- Ripping a CD Using iTunes
- Converting a Windows Media File to MPEG-4 using EasyWMV
- Transferring a file from a firewire hard drive and to a firewire hard drive
Obviously none of these tests are by any means scientific as I used a simple stopwatch and didn't eliminate all variables. For instance, when I did all of the testing with the Core Solo, I didn't wipe the drive first. I did all of the testing with all the crap that has accumulated in their since I think I formatted it originally a year ago. Your mileage may vary.
If you want to skip the run down, here's the results for all the tests:
http://homepage.mac.com/idrivex/stats.pdf
Rip a DVD Using Handbrake
Here are the settings that were utilities in Handbrake:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 3 Hrs., 7 Min., 47 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 2 Hrs., 57 Min. 14 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 2 Hrs., 57 Min. 28 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 1 Hr. 24 Min. 18 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Hr. 15 Min., 38 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 2.2x
Tagging a Ripped DVD's Media File using Lostify
I like Lostify, I know others like MetaX, but whatever. With the Core Solo it was painfully slow. My point was to get it to speed up to be more in line with the MacBook I own.
For those unfamiliar with the Lostify tagging program. It's pretty much a one-window application that allows you to tag your files like this:
Anyways, I digress, here are the results for the Sword in the Stone Tagging:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 2 Min., 27 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 1 Min., 30 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 41 Seconds
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Min., 23 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 3.6x
iTunes Picture Tagging
So the final stage in my DVD Ripping is to tag them with nice pictures, not just a frame from the movie. I like to use DVD Box Covers and make them actually look like DVD Box Covers. To do this, I use Delicious Monster's Delicious Library. While you can do this with their trial version, I recommend buying it because it is one of the best examples of programming on the Mac Platform hands down. And no I don't work for them.
If you want to be able to do this, you'll look up the DVD in Delicious Library, add it to your library, and then look under the Synopsis tab.
Do a screen shot of just the DVD Box Cover (CMD+SHIFT+4) and it'll save to your desktop. Navigate in iTunes to where you can add the cover art and select it from your desktop:
Here are the results for the time it took from the moment I clicked "OK" to the time that iTunes was functional again (ie the image was tagged to the file):
Mac Mini Core Solo: 2 Min., 48 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 1 Min., 30 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 1 Minute, 1 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Min., 44 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 2.8x
So in essence it has cut my DVD Ripping, Tagging, and Adding to iTunes time to the following:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 3 Hrs., 13 Min., 2 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 3 Hrs., 2 Min., 29 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 2 Hrs., 59 Min., 44 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 1 Hr., 26 Min., 0 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 1 Hr., 18 Min., 45 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 2.2x
DVD Burn Test
Now that we know how well it can rip and encode, let's see how it does at burning a DVD-Video. I took a small 100 MB or so video of the Fam and threw it into iDVD. In iDVD, I told it to make a Disc Image. I used Disc Utility to burn the Disc Image.
The image ended up weighing in at 1.13GB.
Sorry about the lack of pictures in this one, Apple just hasn't made DVD Burning exciting enough yet to warrant screen shots. The whole thing ended up being a wash anyways with what seems to be the only thing that matters is the speed of the DVD-RW. All of my tests came in at 6 Minutes and 15 Seconds across both the MacBook and all configurations of the Mini.
CD Burn Test
The CD Burn Test though was a little different. I used an album playlist in iTunes, Aerosmith's "Just Push Play". All of the songs have the same following attributes, except for different song names obviously:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 6 Min, 10 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 5 Min., 29 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 5 Min., 30 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 4 Min., 40 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 4 Min., 49 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.3x
CD Rip Test
Now that we have our burned CD. We're just going to reinsert it right back into our Mini/MacBook and we're going to change the Artist's name when the CDDB info pre-loads (One - To avoid the warning message about importing dupicate songs and Two - To easily remove the duplicate songs for re-testing later). Here's the info on the file type, normal Audio CD File type:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 6 Min., 23 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: 4 Min., 31 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 4 Min., 50 Sec. (What the F?)
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 4 Min., 6 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 4 Min., 17 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.6x
Transcode a WMV File to an MP4 File using EasyWMV
Another hidden gem in the Mac world is a program called EasyWMV for converting WMV files to MP4 Files to view on your AppleTV or iPhone on the fly. I just thought this would be a good example of processor power for testing purposes. I'll spare you a screen shot of EasyWMV's insanely simple user interface and instead show you what the WMV file looked like before:
and after the transcoding to an Mp4 file:
These are your results:
Mac Mini Core Solo: 9 Min., 6 Sec.
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 8 Min., 11 Sec.
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 7 Min., 7 Sec.
MacBook Core Duo: 6 Min., 59 Sec.
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.3x
Transferring Data from a FireWire Hard Drive and to a FireWire Hard Drive
This is also one of those things that doesn't really involve screen shots to be an effective presentation. I will tell you this though, the test file that was being dragged back and forth was a 247.3 MB TV Show Episode purchased off of the iTunes Music Store. It is an MPEG-4 Video File. 640x480, AAC Protected, yada yada yada.
Results: (From FW / To FW)
Mac Mini Core Solo: 12.5 Seconds / 13.3 Seconds
Core Solo w/ DVD-R Drive Only: Did Not Test
Core Solo w/ DVD-R & Hard Drive Only: 10.1 Seconds / 10.2 Seconds
Mac Mini Core2Duo: 10.5 Seconds / 10.3 Seconds
MacBook Core Duo: 12.0 Seconds / 13.4 Seconds
Speed Increase from Core Solo to Core2Duo: 1.2x / 1.3x
So that's pretty much everything. I waited a long @ss time for Apple to update the Mini with all of these features I wanted so that I could finally drop my long in the tooth Mac Mini Core Solo. But with processor prices dropping and no "Mini Event" in sight, I finally bit the bullet. I also figure that I'm going to give it a little coat of paint courtesy of Colorwarepc.com. I figure that they'll eventually make the new Mini look like the MacBooks and iMacs, so why not also get a jump start on that as well:
The New Uni-Body Constructed Core 2 Duo Mac Mini
Twice as Fast as the Original
Twice as Fast as the Original