The issue I have with the move / activity goals is they take no account of rest days: if you exercise regularly, the move goal needs to be set high to account for that, but then if you have a rest day you miss it.
I run for at least 1/2 hour most days but will take a rest day once every 10 days or so which means my streak never lasts more than that
I recently got a Garmin to better track my runs and the activity goal on that is on a weekly rather than daily basis, which makes much more sense to me
The issue I have with the move / activity goals is they take no account of rest days: if you exercise regularly, the move goal needs to be set high to account for that, but then if you have a rest day you miss it.
My roommates border collies get all excited when they see me groaning at my watch later in the evenings, as they know they're probably going to get an unexpected walk (so I can close the Move or Exercise rings). I feel bad I can't take my older beagle, but he moves too slow for me to get any credit. On nights where it's crappy weather outside, I'll walk up and down the stairs inside until the rings close...Run Other Workout for the time and/or calories you want to get credit for.
There are some apps that can write activity directly to the Activity app, which will count for exercise minutes with regard to the Exercise Ring on rest days, in turn still giving you credit. The Human app does this.
It is different than Apple's method as some don't take into account heart rate while walking. Apple's way gives you credit as long as long as you hit a certain HR.
The issue I have with the move / activity goals is they take no account of rest days: if you exercise regularly, the move goal needs to be set high to account for that, but then if you have a rest day you miss it.
I run for at least 1/2 hour most days but will take a rest day once every 10 days or so which means my streak never lasts more than that
I recently got a Garmin to better track my runs and the activity goal on that is on a weekly rather than daily basis, which makes much more sense to me
In theory unless your Move ring goal is ridiculously high, if you achieve one, you should achieve the other...but it never hurts to challenge yourself.
I just do not worry about it. I go from my Garmins to the AW and some days nothing.
Got better things to worry about.
Not necessarily. I often manage to fill my Move circle without having any exercise credit at all.
Did you update to Watch OS 3.1.1? I too used to have little to no data in my exercise ring, but now, it seems I am credited a lot more for normal activities than before.
During your next shift, see if you notice your arm position. If it's mostly horizontal, like if you were carrying something all the time (or typing at a computer, even at a standing desk), the watch won't think you were standing.I worked at upscale restaurant for 8 hours and Move Activity is nice to look at. Also Stand activity is bit odd when I stand all day t work but it says I missed few hours that's joke!
I recently got a Garmin to better track my runs and the activity goal on that is on a weekly rather than daily basis, which makes much more sense to me
I got the Forerunner 235 - after doing a lot of research it seemed to offer the best price / feature balance for what I wanted.Which Garmin did you get?
I got the Forerunner 235 - after doing a lot of research it seemed to offer the best price / feature balance for what I wanted.
I was a bit concerned that it would look too clunky as it is nowhere near as elegant as the AW, but having had it for nearly a fortnight I really like it and have been wearing it constantly apart from when I'm in the shower (it's water resistant to 5ATM but I use the opportunity to charge it)
I've run every day bar one since I got it and it is absolutely brilliant as a running Watch - it's much easier to control with the large buttons (particularly with gloves on in the cold weather), the screen is large and easy to read and you can customise the in activity screens to show you exactly the information you are interested in
On the negative side, there's no question it isn't as elegant as the AW and I'm keeping my AW for more formal occasions, but apart from that, I can't see me wearing my AW again: the Garmin is that good a fit for what I want from a Watch
Here's a picture of it on my wrist (I have very small wrists)
View attachment 679337
The AW is such a better day-to-day watch than the Garmins (I have the 735XT) that I would just use the Garmin for running and stick with the AW for the rest of the day if you can't make any of the running apps work for you. At some point, the AW apps may improve to the point where you're fine without using the Garmin for day-to-day running.so I'm starting to wonder whether I should carry my 225 only for days I run and wear a watch on both arms or just deal with the more limited running functions of the Apple Watch.
During your next shift, see if you notice your arm position. If it's mostly horizontal, like if you were carrying something all the time (or typing at a computer, even at a standing desk), the watch won't think you were standing.
If you're sitting down, you can fool it into giving Stand credit by dangling your arm downwards. It works in the car, too -- I've done it myself.
For a device to register Stand most accurately, it would have to be on your thigh.
Like I said, it depends on what your arm is doing, not your feet. The watch -- or any wrist-worn gadget -- only really knows whether it's sideways or vertical; it doesn't have any sensors telling it whether you're in a chair or not. It's really more of a "wrist orientation sensor", if you will. A 100% accurate Stand-detecting device would either be strapped to your thigh or attached to your butt.I thought when walking or running then AW would think I am standing around. I guess I'm wrong anyway.
Like I said, it depends on what your arm is doing, not your feet. The watch -- or any wrist-worn gadget -- only really knows whether it's sideways or vertical; it doesn't have any sensors telling it whether you're in a chair or not. It's really more of a "wrist orientation sensor", if you will. A 100% accurate Stand-detecting device would either be strapped to your thigh or attached to your butt.
If you're walking and carrying a cup of coffee in your watch hand (as an example), your wrist would be horizontal just like when you're sitting down.
I mentioned in another thread that when I use a stand-up desk for my computer, my watch doesn't know that I'm standing because my arm position is the same as if I were sitting down at a regular desk. And, even if I'm sitting for hours at a time, I can fool the watch into thinking I'm standing by dropping my hand downwards.
I just do not worry about it. I go from my Garmins to the AW and some days nothing.
Got better things to worry about.