This was a direct order screen protector. It is just big enough to cover the screen, which needs to be lit up when you install it. It feels fine. The rounded edges are noticeable but not terrible. I spent about 5 minutes with the phone on testing the positioning before removing the plastic. One added note - there's almost no screen rise now with the Spigen Slim Armor case. *********EDITTED****Now with pics of it in the Otterbox Commuter. The Commuter case leaves the phone feeling much more protected. It has much more lip around the front to protect if dropped. The case fits, but it is no where near as tight as the Commuter on my old 4S. It is almost as if it is looser for more shock absorbing. The shell could probably be tighter, but in the past this caused some cracks. The button areas feel especially loose, but they may mold to the phone with some use, or not. I am much happier and far more comfortable with this case on that the Spigen Slim Armor.