Best UPS for MAC Pro Tower

You asked for it....

Click to expand...

I don't think that's what the article is trying to say.

Figure 1 is simply detailing the internal waveform coming off a square wave inverter. It's totally above the centre axis of the graph, so there's no inversion going on there- that would have to be handled by a separate circuit down the line. And there's no way that is what they're blaring out of the back of the PSU because I'm not aware of -any- equipment, APFC or not- that would survive being hit by that kind of signal. Also, I'm not sure where you're getting 400V from because the graph is totally unlabelled.

I don't mean to question you here, but do you have any other evidence of this? I've discussed this matter at length with both Apple and APC over the span of approximately a month, and I was told exactly what that paper describes in Figure 2- that a stepped sine wave can introduce a "dead zone", and if that zone happens to be long enough an APFC power supply will simply shut off. Not once was I told or warned that a stepped sine wave could actually damage such equipment.

-SC

ScottishCaptain said:

I don't think that's what the article is trying to say.

Figure 1 is simply detailing the internal waveform coming off a square wave inverter. It's totally above the centre axis of the graph, so there's no inversion going on there- that would have to be handled by a separate circuit down the line. And there's no way that is what they're blaring out of the back of the PSU because I'm not aware of -any- equipment, APFC or not- that would survive being hit by that kind of signal. Also, I'm not sure where you're getting 400V from because the graph is totally unlabeled.

I don't mean to question you here, but do you have any other evidence of this? I've discussed this matter at length with both Apple and APC over the span of approximately a month, and I was told exactly what that paper describes in Figure 2- that a stepped sine wave can introduce a "dead zone", and if that zone happens to be long enough an APFC power supply will simply shut off. Not once was I told or warned that a stepped sine wave could actually damage such equipment.

-SC

Click to expand...

The article itself is just a basic description of the types of inverters.

My point, has to do with how the circuits are actually made, so it focuses on the voltages (peak step value output of the UPS >> than the peak input voltage of an APFC PSU). This isn't opinion, it's physics.

Over-volt a capacitor, and it's going to die. Potentially explosively, if the voltage is high enough (there are youtube videos of this).

Now why I focused on Figure 1 rather than Figure 2 (which is what causes the OFF condition on some APFC PSU's due to zero - potential, aka dead time), is that most of the Stepped Inverter types output is that of Figure 1 (3 steps).

PWM based inverters increase the number of steps, so the peak output voltage does not exceed the input voltage of an APFC PSU design. And this is how CyberPower got around this issue (solves the issue, yet still cheaper to produce than traditional Pure Sine wave inverters).

Belkin ones are good.

nanofrog said:

The article itself is just a basic description of the types of inverters.

My point, has to do with how the circuits are actually made, so it focuses on the voltages (peak step value output of the UPS >> than the peak input voltage of an APFC PSU). This isn't opinion, it's physics.

Over-volt a capacitor, and it's going to die. Potentially explosively, if the voltage is high enough (there are youtube videos of this).

Now why I focused on Figure 1 rather than Figure 2 (which is what causes the OFF condition on some APFC PSU's due to zero - potential, aka dead time), is that most of the Stepped Inverter types output is that of Figure 1 (3 steps).

PWM based inverters increase the number of steps, so the peak output voltage does not exceed the input voltage of an APFC PSU design. And this is how CyberPower got around this issue (solves the issue, yet still cheaper to produce than traditional Pure Sine wave inverters).

Click to expand...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3dEJIzwa_3E

That's the closest thing I could come to finding something like this. Skip past midway when he engages the UPS, and much to my horror- that thing is throwing off a square wave- but there doesn't appear to be any significant over-voltage (if any) at all. The best I can make out is that the leading ledge of the square wave is slightly higher then that of the A/C sine wave, but not by much.

I know capacitors can leak and explode, in a former life I specialized in PLC and HMI systems. And I'm not questioning the fact that a square wave could potentially be a really, really bad thing for -any- power supply that expects a sine wave, I'm just on the fence about the fact that it will actually cause irreparable damage.

Again, I sure as **** would NEVER run a Mac Pro off a Back-UPS for the reasons shown in the video above. I would recommend a pure sine wave UPS for anything, irregardless of the cost simply on the principal of operation.

I've just never heard of a square wave inverter *damaging* a PSU.

-SC

I've been using a Pure Sine Cyber Power unit for about two years now. Tastes great and it's less filling.

ScottishCaptain said:

That's the closest thing I could come to finding something like this. Skip past midway when he engages the UPS, and much to my horror- that thing is throwing off a square wave- but there doesn't appear to be any significant over-voltage (if any) at all.

Click to expand...

No, the over-voltage occurs within the APFC based PSU itself, not the UPS's stepped output.

To test if this is the case, it requires obtaining the desired APFC based PSU, opening it up, and hooking either a TRMS DMM or better yet, an oscilloscope to the primary caps, and watch for the peak voltage.

Most aren't able to do this as it requires special equipment and skills.

Nor is it a guarantee that this will be the case, as there are variations in APFC designs, such as whether or not they have a sensing circuit as part of the APFC in order to control the charging cycle of the primary caps. IF this is missing, the cap is charged "blindly" based on a fixed charge cycle (milliseconds, say on the order of 16ms). But an adaptive implementation can adjust the charge cycle to make sure the primary caps are not overcharged.

The reason to be concerned IMHO, is that computers are built out of parts from the lowest bidder. So cutting corners (i.e. eliminating additional circuitry) from the design allows them to cut costs, either in order to meet budget, or increase their margins (PSU ODM, not necessarily the system vendor, but it's not uncommon for this to happen at both the ODM & system vendor level, so a double whammy).

So the safest thing to do IMHO, is run a more suitable type of inverter, which is a PWM based unit (still stepped, but has enough steps that the peak voltages in the caps don't exceed their ratings), or better.

ScottishCaptain said:

And I'm not questioning the fact that a square wave could potentially be a really, really bad thing for -any- power supply that expects a sine wave, I'm just on the fence about the fact that it will actually cause irreparable damage.

Click to expand...

Take what you know, then add in the fact the peak values can exceed the cap's ratings, and you should have a reasonable understanding of what's going on in both early and less expensive units (in regard to manufacturing cost, not retail, which can be hard to gauge without opening up the unit and performing a tear-down).

ScottishCaptain said:

I've just never heard of a square wave inverter *damaging* a PSU.

Click to expand...

Now you have.

I've been using a MP (1,1 and now 5,1) for nearly 6 years without a UPS, and I never ran into problem. I don't need another box cluttering my office! Unless you're running mission critical apps or huge simulations that can be paused gracefully if given a chance (saving hours, if not days of rework), a UPS is a waste of money, I think. Or am I missing something?

EDIT:

Of course, there are gamers among us, who just couldn't bear losing whatever it is that they got.

akadmon said:

I've been using a MP (1,1 and now 5,1) for nearly 6 years without a UPS, and I never ran into problem. I don't need another box cluttering my office! Unless you're running mission critical apps or huge simulations that can be paused gracefully if given a chance (saving hours, if not days of rework), a UPS is a waste of money, I think. Or am I missing something?

Click to expand...

Assuming lost work isn't an issue, and the quality of the power off of the wall is always within spec (no brown-outs, excess noise, frequent outages <black out>, or spikes), then this is feasible.

But the part you don't notice, yet tends to be very important, is that most power utilities do not supply ideal power (brown-outs, black-outs, spikes, and noise).

This is where a good UPS will cover you, as it can deal with these issues by design, particularly those that wouldn't cause the inverter to kick in on a line interactive type (usually what most are), thus reducing, if not completely eliminate, equipment damage due to poor power conditions.

johnnymg said:

I've been using a Pure Sine Cyber Power unit for about two years now. Tastes great and it's less filling.

Click to expand...

+1 but only if you add salt and pepper....

On a serious note, this has saved me twice. My area goes through periods where the power cuts out momentarily and the Cyber Power steps in. When running normally it is whisper quiet....

what about this:

APC SMART-UPS 1500 1500VA 980W SUA1500RM2U 2U UPS BACKUP
ebay item 110996477433

Manufacturer: APC
Model: Smart UPS 1500 Rackmount 2U 120V
Condition: Refurbished with New Batteries
Part Number: SUA15000RM2U
Maximum output: 980 Watts / 1440 VA
Typical backup time at half load: 26.5 minutes (490 Watts)
Typical backup time at full load: 7.4 minutes (980 Watts)
Output Waveform: Sinewave
Warranty: 1 Year Full Replacement Warranty, 30 Day Money Back Guarantee!

APC Smart-UPS 1500 SUA1500RM2U Rackmount 2U User's Manual

Output:
Output power capacity
980 Watts / 1440 V
Max Configurable Power
980 Watts / 1440 V
Nominal output voltage
120V
Output Voltage Distortion
less than 5% at full load
Output Frequency (sync to mains)
47-53Hz for 50Hz nominal , 57-63Hz for 60Hz nominal
Crest Factor
up to 5 : 1
Waveform type
Sinewave
Output Connections
(6) NEMA 5-15R

Input:
Nominal input voltage
120V
Input frequency
50/60 Hz +/- 3 Hz (auto sensing)
Input Connection Type
NEMA 5-15P

Cord Length
6 feet ( 1.83 meters )
Input voltage range for main operations
82 - 144 V
Input voltage adjustable range for mains operation
75 - 154 V
Batteries and Runtime:
Battery type
Maintenance-free sealed Lead-Acid battery with suspended electrolyte : leakproof
Replacement battery cartridge
RBC24
RBC Quantity
1
Typical backup time
at half load
26.5 minutes (490 Watts)
Typical backup time
at full load
7.4 minutes (980 Watts)
Communications and Management:
Interface port
DB-9 RS-232 , SmartSlot , USB
Available Smart Slot Interface Quantity
1
Control panel
LED status display with load and battery bar-graphs and On Line : On Battery : Replace Battery : and Overload Indicators
Audible alarm
Alarm when on battery : distinctive low battery alarm : configurable delays
Emergency Power Off (EPO)
Optional
Surge:
Surge energy rating
459 Joules
Filtering
Full time multi-pole noise filtering : 0.3% IEEE surge let-through : zero clamping response time : meets UL 1449
Physical:
Maximum height
3.50 inches (89 mm)
Maximum width
17.00 inches (432 mm)
Maximum depth
18.00 inches (457 mm)
Rack Height 2U
Net weight
63.00 lbs. (28.64 kg)
Shipping Weight
70.20 lbs. (31.91 kg)

adam9c1 said:

what about this:

APC SMART-UPS 1500 1500VA 980W SUA1500RM2U 2U UPS BACKUP
ebay item 110996477433

Manufacturer: APC
Model: Smart UPS 1500 Rackmount 2U 120V

Click to expand...

If you have a rack to mount it in, sure. It's not a standalone model. I have the standalone SUA1500 and it's excellent.

Are replacement batteries same price for the floor standing and rack mount?

adam9c1 said:

Are replacement batteries same price for the floor standing and rack mount?

Click to expand...

I'm sure the batteries are completely different, being that they'd have to fit into a flat 2U chassis, and therefore I'd expect the price to be different as well. The normal cube-shaped one I bought for my SUA1500 (again, non-rackmount) was a little over $100 from APC, if I recall correctly.

thank you sir

$100 is pretty cheap (comparing to what I see on ebay)
Are there different capacities batteries that fit the same enclosure possibly?
I understand one is 2U unit and one is a brick thus different size batteries.

I was purly trying to understand if one kind is similarly priced to the other.
I actually would rather have the floor standing, the rack mounts would sit on the floor anyways

Can the floor standing unit also accept a management card?
I only want this so I can remote into it and run a self test, schedule self test once a week and get an email back.

adam9c1 said:

thank you sir

$100 is pretty cheap (comparing to what I see on ebay)
Are there different capacities batteries that fit the same enclosure possibly?
I understand one is 2U unit and one is a brick thus different size batteries.

I was purly trying to understand if one kind is similarly priced to the other.
I actually would rather have the floor standing, the rack mounts would sit on the floor anyways

Can the floor standing unit also accept a management card?
I only want this so I can remote into it and run a self test, schedule self test once a week and get an email back.

Click to expand...

The 2U rackmount model takes four RBC24 batteries, which are $350 from APC. The standalone SUA1500 takes one RBC7 battery, which they sell for $180. You could find them cheaper somewhere like eBay, I'm sure. I think I might have received a discount from APC or something, but maybe I did pay $180... I just don't recall anymore.

Here's a place selling a set of all four batteries for that rackmount for $76. I'm generally accepting of 3rd party batteries, but I tend to be a little more cautious when it comes to the battery that will sustain my business machine. Use your best judgment.

I don't know about remote management. I know my SUA1500 is recognized by my Mac Pro, and can be configured in the System Preference panel.

----------

By the way, that 2U model you posted about says it has fresh batteries, so you don't need them for a long time anyway. Not sure if you noticed that.

adam9c1 said:

what about this:

APC SMART-UPS 1500 1500VA 980W SUA1500RM2U 2U UPS BACKUP
ebay item 110996477433

Manufacturer: APC
Model: Smart UPS 1500 Rackmount 2U 120V
Condition: Refurbished with New Batteries

Click to expand...

adam9c1 said:

Are replacement batteries same price for the floor standing and rack mount?

Click to expand...

The only difference in rack mount - the two 12v SLA Batteries are simply turned on their side.

I've used a rack mount for 6 years on it's edge standing next to Cinema Display.
On it's edge takes only 3" foot print on the shelf, vs hidden from view.
If it chirps-I know it just took care of business..the same time the lights dimmed for a micro second.

Having so many extra outlets easy to get at of the UPS, allows me to use them for rechargeable battery chargers - cell phone chargers - ETC.

I just installed new batteries couple weeks ago, now it decides to have issues
going into alarm mode, and won't go silent w/o shutting down.
Manufacturer claims something must have caused a main board issue.

I'm looking at another rack mount, and now with extra 24v battery pack,
It could easily double back up time and provide lighting at night at the same time.

2 - Power-Sonic 12V/8Ah Sealed Lead Acid Battery with F2 Terminal Fire Retardant
SKU: PSH-1280FR (8081)$28.99 - $57.98 http://AtBatt.com/

is it possible to add external battery pack to the floor model like I know some rack mounts have?
I don't think this is huge, I think I'd just get another unit for the other computer.

main unit:
my mac pro, one monitor, modem, router, and VOIP adapter when I get that.

2nd unit
my windows tower and one monitor

duffer42 said:

I have a Mac Pro Tower (mid 2010) 5,1, running Lion 10.7.2. It has one 240 gb SSD, and three 1tb HD's internally. 16 gig of Ram and a 24" monitor. I am interested in what I would need to protect this computer and monitor for a 10-20 minute period of time in the event of power failure. If you can suggest manufacturers also, that would be appreciated.
Thank you

Click to expand...

I have the same Mac Pro with similar RAM and Hard Drive setup. I researched a number of UPS Options and went with CyberPower 1500PFCLCD. I chose it based on my price point and that it provided smoothing out of the signal as well as the more basic functions of a BackupUPS. It's worked really well for me and has protected my equipment from brown-outs. You can hear it click on once in a while, but I haven't had any major black-outs yet. Hope this helps. Paras.

tikku22 said:

I have the same Mac Pro with similar RAM and Hard Drive setup. I researched a number of UPS Options and went with CyberPower 1500PFCLCD. I chose it based on my price point and that it provided smoothing out of the signal as well as the more basic functions of a BackupUPS. It's worked really well for me and has protected my equipment from brown-outs. You can hear it click on once in a while, but I haven't had any major black-outs yet. Hope this helps. Paras.

Click to expand...

Just one thing, though. The CyberPower 1500PFCLCD automatic voltage regulation only does boost and not buck; so on over voltage it will go to battery. I would prefer to have both buck and boost but where I am brownouts happen much more frequently than over voltage so boost is more important.

nanofrog said:

This one will work, and there are cables to make it work.

Examples:

• IEC-320-C14 to IEC-320-C13
• http://www.amazon.co.uk/APC-Power-c...LYE8/ref=sr_1_7?ie=UTF8&qid=1330929681&sr=8-7

I'd expect the UPS to come with some of the latter cables, but as a refurbished unit, it may not. You also have the ability to go for different lengths if needed (just do not exceed the current capability of the cord, UPS, or wall outlet it's connected to).


This one is NOT suitable (wrong type of inverter). CyberPower doesn't make the PWM controlled unit with UK plugs (should have ...PFC... in the model number).

Just standard EU plugs, so you'd need adapters to feed your devices, and the correct IEC to UK mains cord for the UPS itself.

You'd have to check on price, but if it were really tested, I expect the APC would be more durable/reliable than the CyberPower (I own both brands). APC's replacement batteries are also inexpensive and easy to get vs. other brands in my experience, but I've not yet had to replace them in a CyberPower (both under 1yr old, while I've been running APC for years).

Your choice, but keep in mind that it's more than used v. new, and initial price tag (figure on replacing batteries every 3 years, and using the unit for 10). And in the case of the CyberPower, it may not last that long (no idea; it may prove to be as good or better than the APC).

Hope this helps.

Click to expand...

[doublepost=1476409515][/doublepost]Agreed! I use a pure sine wave CyberPower 1350PFCLCD for my Mac Pro 4,1 . I do not recommend anyone use the AVR series as it is not pure sine wave and will over time do damage to your PSU.

sorry had to do this hehehe

CapnDavey said:

sorry had to do this hehehe

Click to expand...

Well, aren't you the wit!

I've been using an APC Back-UPS RS 1500 with the optional battery pack since my PowerMac G4 days. So this USP has been in service for well over a decade. I remember buying it from a local CompUSA store and lugging it all the way home. Don't do this!!! Order it online and have it shipped to you!!

Since then, I've gone through a MacPro1,1, MacPro3,1, MacPro5,1, and a hackintosh. I've had the batteries replaced several times (3rd party). It has survived through several extended blackouts including Hurricane Sandy when we were without power for over a week. None of the equipment connected to it has ever suffered any damage.

I have the utmost faith in APC UPSes.

In 2015, my APC SU1000XL Smart UPS, stopped working. I emailed APC for support and provided the serial number. Here is a portion of the response, "...according to the serial number, your model SU1000XL is 14 years old."

Over the life of the UPS, I replaced the batteries twice. I can attest to the quality of the product and superior tech/customer service. I didn't understand how well the APC functioned until I moved to a city with a constantly varying Vol/Current. Up until then, I only noticed power fluctuations when the lights dimmed. And each time this occurred, the UPS would chirp - letting me know there was a surge/spike/drop. When I moved to a new city, I noticed the APC chirped a lot more. However, the lights didn't dim. I plugged my laptop to see historical as well as live V/I readings. When I viewed the power from the outlet, it was all over the place.

The oldest item still plugged into the UPS is the 30" Apple Cinema Display, purchased on 2006. Still functions perfectly and no dead pixels.

I replaced the old box with an APC Smart-UPS 1500VA with LCD. Will be looking for a new one in about 10 years.

I second the praise of the APC Smart UPS series. I have had a SUA1500 for about 10 years now and it runs flawlessly as does the old MacPro connected to it. I have only replaced the batteries once and really appreciate the AVR buck and boost performance (unlike the CyberPower PFC series which only does boost and not buck which they slyly hide in their marketing literature and spec sheet).