Originally posted by Nepenthe
Digidesign's Pro Tools LE/24 Mix/HD or whatever version you are looking at, and Emagic's Logic Audio are NOT direct competitors.
Pro Tools focuses on Audio recording&editing
Logic Audio focuses on MIDI
Pro Tools is widely recognized (although some hate to admit it) as the most powerful audio recording/editing and general sonic manipulation software package on market. Up until like, a year ago, Pro Tools didn't even posess MIDI capability. It has just recently been added, and it really blows (imho).
Logic Audio is arguably the most powerful MIDI sequencing software on the market. The name "Logic AUDIO" is quite deceptive because, by nature, the application handles no audio data at all -it has always posessed audio capabilities, although *realatively* basic compared to pro tools (the audio in Logic Audio is fine for simple audio RECORDING (not multitrack)). Logic Audio's audio HANDLING is great. Its audio editing works if that is all you have, but personally I prefer dedicated apps like Spark.
Most electronic music producers & MIDI users get outstanding results from using just Logic Audio for MIDI and audio. Pro recording studios, and audio-centric sound pros (whatever that means) usu. use a combination of Pro Tools and Logic Audio (that is what is normal, they also substitute Cubase or another Big MIDI app? for Logic Audio on occasion...or use both)
Logic's direct competition is Cubase and Digital Performer
Protools' direct competition is... I don't remember right now, but there are a few out there.
In terms of MIDI ability/Audio ability
Pro Tools 2/10
Logic 10/4
Saying Pro Tools competes wif Logic is analagous to that commercial where a guy hooks his Chevy Tracker up to a stalled Semi. Or similar to comparing Sonic Foundry's Acid Pro and iMovie.
Not trying to be mouthy, 'just want to set the record straight.
-trev