Differences between SD Card and Memory Stick?

Re: Differences between SD Card and Memory Stick?

Originally posted by Veldek
Hi all!

I'm wondering if there are any differences between an SD Card and a Memory Stick used in Digital Cameras. I'm planning to buy one and want to know if I have to base my decision on this, too.

Thanks in advance.

Click to expand...

SDs are postage stamp sized cards whereas memory sticks are ... well, sticks. Memory sticks are used primarily by SONY. I am not aware of their use by any other digital camera manufacturer.

I'm pretty sure the SD card was developed by Panasonic as a rival to Sony's memory stick. I believe the tech of the SD card has since been licienced to other companies (eg, canon.)

I'd go canon, panasonic or JVC for mini DV cameras. you get a much better camera $ for $ compared to Sony.

Originally posted by Veldek
So, apart from the different shapes, there's no obvious difference?

And yes, I'm torn between a Sony and a Canon.

Click to expand...

Sony may sell decent digital cameras but Canon knows cameras. Given those two choices, Canon is the way to go.

memory stick is more durable, not as flimsy as sd, but you should concern yourself more with the camera, either will do just fine, its the camera thats important

SD has higher read/write speeds than Memory Stick and has higher capacities than the original Memory Stick. Memory Stick Pro, OTOH, goes up to 1 GB. Neither will affect picture quality at all--that all goes to the camera. so I'd be more concerned about the camera maker and its features than the memory format it uses unless you already ahve a but or SD cards or something. Sony makes great digital cameras, and so does Canon. Pretty much any digital camera you get from one of the big manufacturers will be pretty good--Sony, Canon, Pentax, Nikon, Olympus and HP all makes fine digital cameras. Some are better than others, but there is more disparity between individual models than between manufacturers in general. Just stay away from the new Gateway cameras and anything that seems too good to be true (ie 4 MP for $150 might take big 4 MP pics, but you'll have poor color fidelity and artifact-ridden pics). What kind of features and picture quality are you looking for?

BTW, i believe we're talking about digital still cameras here, not MiniDV, manitou.