Pretty good analysis here but I need to address what I bolded:
Not to take away from Montana's 4/4 record in Superbowls, but he did also lose the NFC championship game twice. Brady might be 3/5 in the Superbowl, but he's also 5/6 in the AFC championship game. Peyton is 1/2 in the big game and 2/3 in the AFC championship I believe.
Just needed to throw that in to make the debate more cloudy, and you have to take it with a grain of salt too because the QB is just one of 53.
Like most people, I'm definitely hoping that the Pats and Broncos both win this weekend so we do get to see that matchup. Brady and Manning have faced each other in the AFC championship game twice (03, 06) and each guy won one of them. This could be the rubber match and possibly the last time we could see them face off in the playoffs.
While I will say, at least for the one game of the Super Bowl, to clarify, Montana is at 4 with no losses and overall, yes, he did twice lose the NFC championship and that equalizes the three of Manning, Brady, and Montana. I am sure he also lost a few late in season and it may have contributed to SF not even getting to playoffs or getting a bye.
I am sure there are many who believe, arguably with quick look at the yards and TDs, that Manning and Brady are actually
better than Montana and under that theory, the matchup of those two in an AFC championship game,
as they are both 1-1 with each other, is to potentially be the ultimate battle of football's best ever two quarterbacks. I won't be opposed to that characterization.
When Brady took their first battle in the 03-04 season, his team went on to win the Super Bowl. When Manning took the second battle in the 06-07 season, his team went on to win that Super Bowl. The only thing wrong with talking about a Brady-Manning AFC championship contest is that neither team is there yet.
A part of me would love to see this and for old times sake, it's always nice to see two well loved, familiar faces going for one more, perhaps last, battle. I am no fan of a Big Ben or Michael Vick, so for big name QBs it would be great to see Denver go against New England. If that's the case, all the hyped up press around that would like to crown the winner of that the eventual winner of the Super Bowl.
If it's NE that gets there against let's say my Niners, we know how to stop a great QB with our still good defense and I am sure we can also dismantle Manning and his Denver offense. With Green Bay if you have them to go against, there's no doubt that mid-career QB ratings leader Aaron Rodgers would be the better QB on that day. As for Atlanta or Seattle, I think those last two would be an even match with a NE or Denver even though some Vegas Odds sites would give it to the AFC team.
So instead of jumping ahead to the Super Bowl I will hope just a week in advance and want to see the "classic" Brady vs Peyton Manning matchup. If neither team goes to AFC game, it won't surprise me either since it is early favorite Houston going against ESPN's pre-season pick of Baltimore.
.......
Unlike baseball, I will enjoy who makes it to the big game. Locally where I am, many love Brady because he's a local league high school hero. If the Niners and/or Raiders have a bad season, the neighborhood automatically become Pats fans and root on Brady, local boy, and his team regardless of who it is (
assuming Brady can live beyond NE like Favre did beyond GB at same age...and sports talking heads always dream of Brady one day coming home and playing in Bay Area. Raiders have no QB and would take Brady even years from now, and if SF can't get it together with QB controversy, would shine with Brady). It's not a Niner or Raider who has the most visible charities here but Brady.
And as much as I want to root against any powerhouse NL baseball team that can take out SF as I like to root against teams as much as I like to root for my hometeam, it's hard to go against team who has a guy we all went to high school, church, and little league with (Aldrete with St. Louis Cardinals).
Anyway, life's too short to just love your team and hate all others, especially these days when even so-called pillars like Montana or Favre or Moss can end up in the strangest places late in career.