Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Maps Significantly More Popular Than All Other iOS Mapping Apps, Including Google
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Apple maps has gotten a lot better.
If the address appears wrong. I just move the pin over and go from there. Usually whatever is wrong on Apple is wrong on Google too
Still 5+ years later google refuses to fix the location of my home address
----------
Actually the design of Mac Pro is incredible as silly as it may look. One fan pulls all the heat out. Wow!
If the address appears wrong. I just move the pin over and go from there. Usually whatever is wrong on Apple is wrong on Google too
Still 5+ years later google refuses to fix the location of my home address
----------
Actually the design of Mac Pro is incredible as silly as it may look. One fan pulls all the heat out. Wow!
I use both.
Google Maps does transit, street view, and has much better UK coverage (and accuracy).
Apple Maps does walking directions better (the prior version of Google Maps was an improvement, but they seem to have gone backwards with the latest update). Flyover is also good (in the few places where it works).
Google Maps does transit, street view, and has much better UK coverage (and accuracy).
Apple Maps does walking directions better (the prior version of Google Maps was an improvement, but they seem to have gone backwards with the latest update). Flyover is also good (in the few places where it works).
Google Maps much better
I used my iPhone as my GPS on 2 different motorcycle trips originating from Austin, Texas this last Summer. I used both Apple and Google maps and really wanted Apple to be the winner because it's just easier as the default map app.
The first Southwest trip was for about 5 weeks and went from Texas through, New Mexico, Utah, Arizona, Nevada, and back to Texas. The second trip was also about 5 weeks and went through the mid-west from Texas through Arkansas, Missouri, Kentucky, Tennessee, North Carolina, Virginia and Louisiana... back to Texas.
The Apple map results were consistently horrible, inaccurate, and got me lost several times. The Google maps were always perfect without exception.
Haven't tried since iOS7, but I find myself not even using Apple maps for quick local directions. I cut/paste addresses from the default Apple map results right into Google maps without even bothering with the Apple maps anymore.
Was curious if things had improved with iOS7, but the incredibly horrible experience of using Apple maps while traveling has me gun-shy to even bother with it at all.
I used my iPhone as my GPS on 2 different motorcycle trips originating from Austin, Texas this last Summer. I used both Apple and Google maps and really wanted Apple to be the winner because it's just easier as the default map app.
The first Southwest trip was for about 5 weeks and went from Texas through, New Mexico, Utah, Arizona, Nevada, and back to Texas. The second trip was also about 5 weeks and went through the mid-west from Texas through Arkansas, Missouri, Kentucky, Tennessee, North Carolina, Virginia and Louisiana... back to Texas.
The Apple map results were consistently horrible, inaccurate, and got me lost several times. The Google maps were always perfect without exception.
Haven't tried since iOS7, but I find myself not even using Apple maps for quick local directions. I cut/paste addresses from the default Apple map results right into Google maps without even bothering with the Apple maps anymore.
Was curious if things had improved with iOS7, but the incredibly horrible experience of using Apple maps while traveling has me gun-shy to even bother with it at all.
helps that it is the default and you can't change your default mapping app....
apple maps has steered me wrong (as in not even close to where the location is) so I try not to use it unless in a pinch
apple maps has steered me wrong (as in not even close to where the location is) so I try not to use it unless in a pinch
Yep. The best navigation app is the one that leads people onto an airport taxiway.
Seriously, yesterday when I was searching for restaurants around, Apple Maps only returned 2 results while Google returned around 10 results. That is why I always tell people to use Google Maps whenever possible because it is just much more complete.
Flyover is just about the only thing good with Apple Maps.
Last edited:
The side-by-side comparison of screenshots of Google vs. Apple maps in this article is a clear demonstration of why I don't like Apple Maps as much. There is very little contrast in Apple Maps, which it makes it difficult to see. The background is too light (nearly white background with white roads), the text is too light and it seems smaller.
Google's maps are (still) better than Apple's. They're more complete, more up-to-date, and the satellite/aerial views are far better. And Google's location search is of course still far, far better than Apple's.
But Google's Maps app on iOS just isn't that good. It feels slow and clunky compared to Apple's, even on an iPhone 5s; plus the UI is not as simple and elegant as Apple's.
But Google's Maps app on iOS just isn't that good. It feels slow and clunky compared to Apple's, even on an iPhone 5s; plus the UI is not as simple and elegant as Apple's.
Last edited:
I really want to like it but if they can't remove the location of our old Children's Hospital from years ago (a change I submitted when maps first came out) then I don't see much hope. Constantly can't find addresses and it seems like their map is from 10 years ago.
Maps sucks in Canada. I bet it's great in the USA.
Maps sucks in Canada. I bet it's great in the USA.
Exactly. I ran a poll about Maps in another thread (here), and more people outside the US said maps was poor than maps was great. I love Apple's products in general, but maps outside the US shows a serious lack of attention to detail. Moreover, Apple is not correcting errors that people have been submitting since Maps was first released. Apple has a lot of cash. There are lots of unemployed people who could check the accuracy of Maps and/or error reports. I don't get why Apple is poring effort into iCloud but not updating Maps....
It's not perfect in the US.... but neither was Google. Apple has worked better for me.
As a Google user we got bad info all the time and shrugged it off--it was still awesome for the 95% good info! But slap an Apple logo on an error and suddenly it's a war crime
I thought I'd miss Street View but I don't: blurry, awkward, and so... slow...
Exploring a neighborhood in fast-gliding Flyover (where available) is so much nicer for the same purposes. Except reading small signs... which Street View allows maybe half the time at best?
I'm imagining if Google Maps had had Flyover all along, and not Street View. Then imagine Apple came out with Street View as it exists: awkward to navigate, slow to load, full of glitches, double images, blurs, blinding sun flares and noisy shadows. Click... move 20 feet. Click... move 20 feet. Apple would be a laughing stock! But since Apple did NOT make Street View, bloggers pretend it's the greatest thing since sliced bread.
And it was useful, and still is where Flyover is missing. But not that great.
And now, for future improvements: Apple's getting a ton of mapping data that Google is no longer receiving.
As a Google user we got bad info all the time and shrugged it off--it was still awesome for the 95% good info! But slap an Apple logo on an error and suddenly it's a war crime
I thought I'd miss Street View but I don't: blurry, awkward, and so... slow...
Exploring a neighborhood in fast-gliding Flyover (where available) is so much nicer for the same purposes. Except reading small signs... which Street View allows maybe half the time at best?
I'm imagining if Google Maps had had Flyover all along, and not Street View. Then imagine Apple came out with Street View as it exists: awkward to navigate, slow to load, full of glitches, double images, blurs, blinding sun flares and noisy shadows. Click... move 20 feet. Click... move 20 feet. Apple would be a laughing stock! But since Apple did NOT make Street View, bloggers pretend it's the greatest thing since sliced bread.
And it was useful, and still is where Flyover is missing. But not that great.
And now, for future improvements: Apple's getting a ton of mapping data that Google is no longer receiving.
I'm always one to give Apple first crack at my usage, but even I have had to go with Google Maps for the following reasons:
- Google traffic data is way more accurate and presented in a much cleaner way than Apple's dotted line approach which I hate.
- Google Maps offers the double tap to zoom in AND out feature - very convenient for checking the map in traffic with one hand and keeping as much focus on the road as possible.
- On many occasions, Apple Maps has given me directions to go the wrong way down a one-way street which are very common here in Boston. Unacceptable.
You know you made the same mistake. Your "statistics" are just based on Internet anecdotes...
I have run three side by side tests comparing the apps while traveling. Apple maps was better for two and the same for the third. In one case, Google maps was 160 miles off.
I think for a lot of people transit is the #1 complaint about Apple Maps. Fortunately, Apple Maps will do transit in iOS 8, along with indoor location tracking and mapping.
I *WANT* to like Apple Maps, but I can't. If I'm looking for a street that may be a few blocks away, but can't think of where it is, Maps will find the street... well, a same-named street in another state. Something is SERIOUSLY wrong with the data and/or algorithm if it cannot find the street that may be a few blocks away or a neighboring town, but can find one 100s of miles away.