Lets see:
1. When iCloud music was launched, it messed up people's libraries (some of them highly curated over several years) deleting music, ratings, playcounts etc, in some cases irreparable damage.
that happened to some people ...
The unfortunate issue has nothing to do with this news.
2. iOS Music app has some of the worst UI I have seen in a long time, even with the initial fixes, it remains second class.
that's subjective and completely debatable.
I don't like it , but I don't think it's "second class" by any means.
3. iOS Music app now puts all your music into a tiny tab, and the rest are streaming, which means if you don't like streaming, you are forced to see it everyday cluttering your UI and affecting your usage every single day. I really miss having the playlists, artists, songs, albums tabs at the bottom, now it's "Music" "Playlists" "Radio" "Connect" It's a joke, why doesn't Apple let me customize it so I can remove the useless "Connect" and remove the useless beats1 and radio I don't care about?
It's not a "tiny" tab. It's a tab. And NOT the rest is not streaming. Streaming is another tab. The default tab that opens when you launch the app is your music, and you still have your playlists.
As I said, critics are overly exaggerated ...
Are you surprised Apple doesnt let you customize everything about their UI ? Are you an Apple user since when ? yesterday ? Apple isn't about deep customization in UI, deal with it or move on.
Simple like that...
4. Rather than entering the market and competing fairly, Apple imposes 30% premium on Spotify and other similar services when users sign up through the app store. This puts Apple music at an advantage over competitors and potentially threatens in the long term Spotify's viability. Do we want fair competition, or monopolies? Why is a 30% premium imposed monthly on Spotify?
who care ? Are you a Spotify shareholder ? I don't care if Spotify close tomorrow, for what it counts. I do care if Apple Music improve, because I invested in Apple's ecosystem ....
As far as I know, Spotify is sold through the app store, so I can't see any monopoly here.
You don't think the criticism has some merit?
Sure. And most were overly exaggerated as usual on forums like this.