Except that, given the first benchmark results, the iPhone 5 almost trippled the hardware speeds in comparison to the 4S and features a new design.
The 3G didn't feature much more compared to the classic except 3G. So it's actually not comparable and this release is much bigger. But still, haters gonna hate...
I for myself can't wait for Friday to arrive
I was about to post the same except then I realized the 3G also added a real GPS chip. And well, I would not have even turned my head to look at it if it weren't for the GPS on it (seriously, I was very closed minded about it and the fact it had GPS tempted me enough to get over that).
Also, Edge speeds are so slow that I do think 3G was a pretty big upgrade honestly. I mean I wouldn't find a phone so useful that was always getting edge speeds (judging from the few times I get them).
But... I am not sure I'd say the 3G was the biggest upgrade (not counting the 5
). It didn't increase speed and it made the phone get out of date very quickly. I mean Apple was proven right that they should have gimped iOS 4 for it and honestly, people ended up complaining that Apple should have just made it incompatible cause what they did allow it to do it still ran badly. And that was only the third OS. Every phone since then has been able to at least run three (or more in the case of the 3GS) OS's fine.
There is definitely merit to a good speed (and not just network) increase. The 5 may not have any standout new features (like GPS), oh wait it does, people are just ignoring it (and honestly, I meant to make the argument it did not have standout features and then realized that yes it does have some standout features, they just are just things people are taking for granted). Ignoring the larger screen the screen also has a better color gamut and is true to colors as well as changing the screen technology so that the touch screen is right on the display which I hear makes for a more crisp image and better touch sensitivity. It's got a faster processor (significantly faster and it shows, unlike the 4 which got a faster processor but because of increase in resolution didn't really show so well), more RAM (needs it imho), better wi-fi, LTE (which I myself was yawning at until people finally explained how much faster it is than 3G)... so yes, it does have some decent upgrades.
Yeah... the 5 is a lot bigger upgrade than people are giving it credit for (a helluva lot bigger than the 3G). It's just its upgrades are in things people take for granted (how nice the screen looks, how fast it runs). There's no new outstanding toy feature (like Siri or GPS <- which is useful but it is something people would consider a new feature without having to argue with them, or even NFC or wireless charging). And that's why people are complaining and people are still buying. Cause it's the tech geeks like us who like nifty new features who are complaining (I'm not but I can't count myself out as a gadget lover) but the people who are buying just want a better overall phone (as one article put it, ti doesn't have to have new features, it has to be a better iphone and it does exactly that).
Edit: I forgot to add battery life upgrade.... yeah, that is a really good one too (increasing speed and battery life, that's pretty damned cool).