Just ordered a used Pixel 3A in mint condition, just for reviewing a sponsor’s app in my YT channel. The app only available on Android for the moment.
The seller said the battery health is 94% and can hold SoT between 4-5 hours (3000 mAh). That is similar to my 12 mini (2200 mAh). We’ll see on my daily real usage.
The Pixel 3A will be my second Android phone since the 2011/2012 Galaxy Nexus. Both running stock Android which I always prefer back when I haven’t use an iPhone. This will also serve my purpose to compare modern iOS vs Android that I have not experience for years now. Should be interesting for me.
I settled the budget for this purpose for under USD 200, so the options were either a used Pixel 3A or a new Redmi Note 10 that has just been up for sale officially in my country. Read pretty much users complaining about the bloat, ads and inconsistency on the MiUI made me chose the Pixel. I personally prefer Samsung’s OneUI looks over any other skinned Android but it seems some users still complaining about daily performance degradation after few months of usage.
Also the Pixel 3A camera (photo) performance is said to be on par with the recent Pixel 4A, so should also be interesting for me to compare it to my 12 mini camera.
Entering day 3 using my Pixel 3a,
It has been fun and refreshing using it as my secondary phone with 12 mini as the primary.
I copied my iPhone data and contents directly to the Pixel using direct USB C to lightning cable connection. So they both have similar apps, settings and user data (photos, videos, text, etc.). The process was straight forward and intuitive. Very good welcoming feature for iPhone users coming to the Pixel.
This setup also serve me a power bank feature for the 12 mini from the Pixel. Reverse charging is nice.
Here's what I feel / found about stock Android 11 compared to iOS 14:
- They both feels very similar and I can see each being influenced by each other on certain features. But I think Android implemented more iOS core features more than vice versa.
- Android becoming more transparent by letting me know more about third party apps that trying to access my phone.
- Android 11 notification center is even getting way more advanced than iOS with smarter grouping between chats, app notifications and system notifications.
- I much prefer iOS's control center layout. But both functions great.
- Surprisingly, I think Android widgets is going no where, still doesn't improved compared to on Jelly Bean, Marshmello and Oreo that I've been familiar with. iOS implementation is more usable for me and being supported more by third party apps.
- Contextual menu extension on app icon also not being utilize to the max on Android, both by native apps and third party apps.
- Social media apps are indeed more polished on the iOS, haptic feedback are implemented better.
- Speaking of haptics, despite inferior haptic engine on Pixel 3a (not too bad actually), the whole system implementation is not on par with iOS. Subtle and tap like haptic are more refined on iOS.
- I prefer classic app drawer on Android then app library on iOS (including the whole app folder mess on home screen).
- Google Assistant is great. Siri is no contest.
- With the same 4gb of ram both on Pixel 3a and 12 mini, Android task manager kills more background apps than iOS. This is the opposite of what was happening in the past. But I'm glad Android do this to make the whole experience smoother.
- Gesture navigation on Android is great. There's 3 options available including the classic 3 buttons, the pil and back button (which I don't like) and the nav bar swipe button with screen edge back swipe that is very similar with iOS. But the difference is that on Android we can swipe it back from the right screen edge as well. Very convenient to use both with right or left thumb. Even though iOS back swipe feels more natural.
- Text selection with holding space bar in iOS is no where to be found on Android 11. Other Android UI like Samsung's OneUI have it I've been told.
- I also miss tapping top edge screen to go back up in iOS.
- There seems no reachability features on Android 11. Samsung and the others have some kind of shrinking the whole screen to make it easier to reach.
- Both native image editing software is great, I no longer need the kind of Snapseed app to edit my pictures. HDR processing on iOS is more agressive while stock Android do it more subtle. I like taking pictures more on the Pixel due to better experience and outputs, especially how it uses regular wide lens but auto cropping it to mimic telephoto lens on portrait mode. But low light mode processing is better on the iPhone.
- Battery monitoring system on Android 11 is lacking. Needs third party app to tell more like on iOS. But charging estimation info is a nice touch on Android.
- And battery life on standby mode is still disappointing. I lost around 20% overnight. Even though the 3000mAh battery allows me to have 6 hours of SoT.
- Automatization also needs third party app on Android, but it can do way more detailed macro scripting than what iOS allowing user to do on Shortcuts.
- Surprisingly, I found AOD to be more into my likings than previously I thought I would. Interested how Apple will implement this on the next iPhones.
- Auto OTP input on iOS when using two factors of authentication is also missing on Android 11.
- Animation and transitions are getting better on Android, although there's this thing about overall aesthetic, fluidity, and consistency both in terms of UI and UX that I found to be more refined on iOS. Tiny little details that we can feel and appreciate.
- The basic feature on Pixel launcher is adequate that I don't need to replace it with Nova launcher like in the past. iOS 14 also providing enough tools and shortcuts, that I don't feel it's lacking from Android 11.
- Live caption for speech and text selection tools for any screen features are something that iOS should be inspired from.
The list is getting lengthier than I thought, but I think there's more to find, the longer I use my Pixel 3a. Looking forward to see how stock Android would hold up staying smooth in the next few months.
Overall, I won't mind using the Pixel with stock Android as my daily driver, but I still prefers iOS experience by not too far in comparison.