powermac666 said:
I have to say I'm one of them, too. I love my Tungsten T3, and I'm very happy with the Verizon service on my LG phone, but I'd dump them both in a hot second if Apple came out with a PDA/phone done the way only Apple can do it.
The funny thing is I dumped my Palm Tungsten C after I got an iPod Mini, because I just store my PIM information on that. I had recently bought an iBook, and the awesome sleep feature sort of eliminated my need for the Palm (in combination with the iPod Mini.)
I think any discussion of an Apple smartphone would begin with what actual features or uses that Apple would anticipate users wanting/needing. Would it mainly be accessing info (PIM, text/email, text updates/information from the web) or manipulating info (all the myriad things you can do on a Palm.) I think Apple would stick to a reduced feature set that is done very well. The problem with PDA's in general is that the makers have added tons of features over the years, but that they are shoehorned into a format (small screen, slow user input methods) that is not ideal for many computing tasks.
The way I might imagine an Apple smart phone is something with a supremely simple interface- default mode is to talk, but otherwise you have a list of choices up front- iTunes, iPhoto (or equivalent), Messages (text or email), .Mac, News, Weather, Stocks, Sports, etc...Make your selection, and boom- you're instantly there without any significant delays or having to drill down through too many obscure menus. I think Sherlock would be the type of interface used for accessing info (simple, targeted, elegant), rather than a web browser (more versatile but not as clean or organized, problematic on a small screen.)
It's a common adage that 90% of PDA users only use the pre-installed apps, so Apple would focus heavily on that, rather than worry about developing a complete mobile computer OS. It would have some expandibility, but not as much as Palm or Windows Mobile.
I think a smartphone like this would also be more attractive to Apple than a PDA. A lot of people would use a smartphone like this, while not nearly as many people want a PDA.