I used to have a Manfrotto, but I found it to be too heavy so I never carried it. I replaced it with a Gitzo 6x carbon fiber legs and Markins ballhead and now much happier.
To protect the legs from what? I always thought leg padding was for metal tripods that get very cold to the touch in low temperatures. Why would you need that on a CF tripod?
I'll add my own rig for your consideration, though it does exceed your budget. I use the RRS TVC-33 with BHS-55/BHS-40, depending on lens and wimberley sidekick for birding. Good stuff. Very light (4.25 lbs without head), will hold 50lbs and has really been a great companion - absolutely rock steady. Not cheap, but not something I'll need to replace soon either and it does allow for acquiring larger lenses later as my budget allows.
If you haven't read Thom Hogan's article on tripods, might be worth a look.
Can't go wrong with a Mountaineer. I also prefer 3 over 4 section, less hassle and in some cases (0531/0541) the bottom section of the 4-piece is thinner, more likely to flex.
Had a GT1541 as an all-around, very practical for those who can only have one set of sticks. I never use the columns, I take them out to maximize rigidity and save weight.
I've since replaced it with two others: a GT0531 strictly for long hikes in the mountains, and a RRS TVC-33, for video and heavy artillery stills. As much as I've liked my Gitzos, IMO the ReallyRightStuff tripods are amazing (and priced to match!)
Nice to hear from someone outside of the Gitzo/Manfrotto club. I saw the name Induro on the B&H product page. I'll look it up.Induro CT-213 legs with Manfrotto 498R2 ball head.
Sturdy, light-weight, and didn't break the bank. Highly recommended.
I'm following this thread with interest, because I'm looking to replace an old Manfrotto 3221 green with a lighter set of sticks. It's still working fine, but it's heavy.
And I can't resist . . . you want heavy? Here's an image (circa 1973) of my tripod holdings when I was doing research in the southwestern Pacific rainforest (and had hair). The left one (with the theodolite mounted) is wooden. Durable, stable, very heavy, and remarkably hard on the shoulder when moving from mark to mark and slogging back to the village. I still have it.
...
Have a look at Feisol, while you're at it. I spent months trying to figure out what I wanted vs. what I wanted to spend. In the end, I still ended up spending more than double my original budget (which was unrealistically low for what I wanted.) btw, that Thom Hogan article that r.harris1 linked to is a good read and also a big part of the reason I expanded my budget.
After using my Feisol for more than a month now, though, I am extremely happy.
Specifically, I went with:
Feisol CT-3472 Elite Tripod
Feisol LB-7572 Leveling Base
Really Right Stuff BH-55LR Ball Head