Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iPad mini Black anodized metal rubbing off.

DerfBWH

DerfBWH

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Aug 11, 2008
342
411
So I've got a launch day iPad mini wi-fi, really really happy with the device overall. Been a huge Apple fan and never really had a major issue with any of their products within their normal lifespan. However, I've noticed this strange issue with my iPad mini - the black anodized metal appears to be rubbing off.

It's on the top left corner of the device, close to the headphone jack. Never seen this happen on any of my other Apple devices, especially not so early. The iPad has been totally babied and has never been dropped on anything other than a bed, and other than this there's not a scratch on it.

Anybody have any advice? Honestly in the grand scheme of things this isn't a huge deal, but has anyone else noticed anything similar/is this a bigger problem, or am I a one off sort of case here?
 

Attachments

  • Photo Dec 06, 10 51 37 PM.jpg
    Photo Dec 06, 10 51 37 PM.jpg
    2.1 MB · Views: 1,415
maflynn

maflynn

macrumors Haswell
May 3, 2009
73,469
43,388
DerfBWH said:
Anybody have any advice? Honestly in the grand scheme of things this isn't a huge deal, but has anyone else noticed anything similar/is this a bigger problem, or am I a one off sort of case here?
Click to expand...

It looks more like you banged/dropped it. I'd recommend you put it in a case to protect the finish or use a product like Ghost Armor for the same effect.

Bummers on it getting chipped though :(
 
N

Namtaro

macrumors regular
Dec 4, 2011
135
0
Definitely a scratch. If it was rubbed off, the aluminum under would be completely smooth.

Bummer though... I'm still waiting for my case to arrive... so far so good in protecting it. :p
 
DerfBWH

DerfBWH

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Aug 11, 2008
342
411
Definitely not scratched. Feeling the device, it's perfectly smooth. If you close your eyes and rub your finger against the side of the device, you can't notice any change in texture. Not to mention I have not, as I've said before it, dropped it.
 
maflynn

maflynn

macrumors Haswell
May 3, 2009
73,469
43,388
Well if its not dropped or scratched then take it back because that's not normal.
 
Menel

Menel

Suspended
Aug 4, 2011
6,351
1,356
DerfBWH said:
So I've got a launch day iPad mini wi-fi, really really happy with the device overall. Been a huge Apple fan and never really had a major issue with any of their products within their normal lifespan. However, I've noticed this strange issue with my iPad mini - the black anodized metal appears to be rubbing off.

It's on the top left corner of the device, close to the headphone jack. Never seen this happen on any of my other Apple devices, especially not so early. The iPad has been totally babied and has never been dropped on anything other than a bed, and other than this there's not a scratch on it.

Anybody have any advice? Honestly in the grand scheme of things this isn't a huge deal, but has anyone else noticed anything similar/is this a bigger problem, or am I a one off sort of case here?
Click to expand...

Anodization rubs off, normal wear. The number of anodized old cameras and tools I have seen with wear on the finish... I cant grasp why people are surprised
 
N

Namtaro

macrumors regular
Dec 4, 2011
135
0
Take a macro shot of the area, from that picture it looks scratched.
If the annodizing was rubbed off from say a cloth or wooden table scruff, it should be perfectly smooth.

I've had a bunch of paintball guns years back that were anodized and the only way they'd get scratched is if they knocked onto something. Any parts that were rubbed off (Say the trigger or inside the barrel) were always shiny.

The anodizing on the iPad Mini is very thin so any hard bumps, even on wood could knock off the coating. If it got knocked off by wood, it might not even leave a scratch on the actual aluminum since it's softer, but only take off the coating.
 
urkel

urkel

macrumors 68030
Nov 3, 2008
2,795
917
DerfBWH said:
So I've got a launch day iPad mini wi-fi, really really happy with the device overall. Been a huge Apple fan and never really had a major issue with any of their products within their normal lifespan. However, I've noticed this strange issue with my iPad mini - the black anodized metal appears to be rubbing off.
Click to expand...
Around here then "choice of materials used" has now been deemed "user error" so unfortunately you're going to get a lot of backlash just for trying to discuss a legitimate subject.

BTW, I use a protective film on the back of all 3 of our iPad Mini's (and two iPhone 5's) so I thought I was going to be protected from normal wear and tear but every single one of them has chipping of some sort on that exposed beveled edge. I don't usually mind imperfections like that but the way that silver underneath shines is going to absolutely murder resale value. It's too bad we aren't allowed to discuss this stuff in a non-hostile way because its a real issue that shouldn't be swept under the rug so easily.
 
urkel

urkel

macrumors 68030
Nov 3, 2008
2,795
917
maflynn said:
Well if its not dropped or scratched then take it back because that's not normal.
Click to expand...

We have 2 iPhone 5's and 3 iPad Mini's all black. I'm not sure how durable that back casing is since we're using invisible shields on the back of the 4 pictured the exposed edges are all flaking.

Here's the honest truth about each one:
- None have been dropped
- Top (My iPhone 5) and bottom (Kids iPad Mini) are chipped paint. I say that because theyve been in a bumper and otter box from day 1.
- Middle iPad Mini's (Mine/Wife) are abrasion marks. Never dropped but I guess thats our fault anyway since we didnt buy full cases
- Not Pictures (Wifes iPhone 5). She uses a full case so her edges are decent but the problem is the back anodized aluminum showing discoloration/gouges from dust caught between case/phone.


Im not complaining at all because i knew in advance that black would have issues quicker than white but it is disappointing that theyre all within 2mo old and look like theyve been beat up over an entire year. Hopefully next gen addresses some of these issues.

Edit: Just for kicks, I added a pic of the 4 devices with all the "protection" on.
 

Attachments

  • 121209-IMG_3989 60D.jpg
    121209-IMG_3989 60D.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 775
  • IMG_3993.JPG
    IMG_3993.JPG
    748 KB · Views: 361
Last edited:
S

SomeDudeAsking

macrumors 65816
Nov 23, 2010
1,250
2
urkel said:
We have 2 iPhone 5's and 3 iPad Mini's all black. I'm not sure how durable that back casing is since we're using invisible shields on the back of the 4 pictured the exposed edges are all flaking.

Here's the honest truth about each one:
- None have been dropped
- Top (My iPhone 5) and bottom (Kids iPad Mini) are chipped paint. I say that because theyve been in a bumper and otter box from day 1.
- Middle iPad Mini's (Mine/Wife) are abrasion marks. Never dropped but I guess thats our fault anyway since we didnt buy full cases
- Not Pictures (Wifes iPhone 5). She uses a full case so her edges are decent but the problem is the back anodized aluminum showing discoloration/gouges from dust caught between case/phone.


Im not complaining at all because i knew in advance that black would have issues quicker than white but it is disappointing that theyre all within 2mo old and look like theyve been beat up over an entire year. Hopefully next gen addresses some of these issues.
Click to expand...

OMG, that's some pretty bad quality.
 
urkel

urkel

macrumors 68030
Nov 3, 2008
2,795
917
SomeDudeAsking said:
OMG, that's some pretty bad quality.
Click to expand...
Actually, Im not sure how to judge the quality.

I plug in blindly every night and there's constant metal on metal interaction betwen the device bottom and lightning cable yet if you look at the picture then there isnt one visible scratch. So what the heck is going on because it seems both indestructible and fragile at the same time.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3993.JPG
    IMG_3993.JPG
    748 KB · Views: 231
E

EMAN19

macrumors 6502
Sep 19, 2012
275
0
New York, NY
urkel said:
We have 2 iPhone 5's and 3 iPad Mini's all black. I'm not sure how durable that back casing is since we're using invisible shields on the back of the 4 pictured the exposed edges are all flaking.

Here's the honest truth about each one:
- None have been dropped
- Top (My iPhone 5) and bottom (Kids iPad Mini) are chipped paint. I say that because theyve been in a bumper and otter box from day 1.
- Middle iPad Mini's (Mine/Wife) are abrasion marks. Never dropped but I guess thats our fault anyway since we didnt buy full cases
- Not Pictures (Wifes iPhone 5). She uses a full case so her edges are decent but the problem is the back anodized aluminum showing discoloration/gouges from dust caught between case/phone.


Im not complaining at all because i knew in advance that black would have issues quicker than white but it is disappointing that theyre all within 2mo old and look like theyve been beat up over an entire year. Hopefully next gen addresses some of these issues.

Edit: Just for kicks, I added a pic of the 4 devices with all the "protection" on.
Click to expand...

Thanks for posting and shedding some light on that! Those devices look like they've gone through a couple of wars!

I had my black iPad mini for a week before I decided to take it back due to the paint peeling off. Luckily this does not happen with the white iPad mini and white iPhone 5.
 
L

LeeM

macrumors 6502a
Jan 1, 2012
603
0
i really want a black mini, but worried about this paint issue.
with that in mind none of the black ones in the apple store i was in had this problem, and surely theyre not replacing them daily?!
 
E

EMAN19

macrumors 6502
Sep 19, 2012
275
0
New York, NY
LeeM said:
i really want a black mini, but worried about this paint issue.
with that in mind none of the black ones in the apple store i was in had this problem, and surely theyre not replacing them daily?!
Click to expand...

It's very well possible. In any case, buy the black one and try it out. I had it for a full 7 days before I noticed silver linings on the chamfered edges. And I babied it too. I never placed it a hard surface, never bumped it, nothing.

I've had the white for 3 weeks now and it holds up extremely well. Dust and prints are hardly visible. I love the white version.
 
vastoholic

vastoholic

macrumors 68000
Jan 28, 2009
1,957
1
Tulsa, OK
urkel said:
We have 2 iPhone 5's and 3 iPad Mini's all black. I'm not sure how durable that back casing is since we're using invisible shields on the back of the 4 pictured the exposed edges are all flaking.

Here's the honest truth about each one:
- None have been dropped
- Top (My iPhone 5) and bottom (Kids iPad Mini) are chipped paint. I say that because theyve been in a bumper and otter box from day 1.
- Middle iPad Mini's (Mine/Wife) are abrasion marks. Never dropped but I guess thats our fault anyway since we didnt buy full cases
- Not Pictures (Wifes iPhone 5). She uses a full case so her edges are decent but the problem is the back anodized aluminum showing discoloration/gouges from dust caught between case/phone.


Im not complaining at all because i knew in advance that black would have issues quicker than white but it is disappointing that theyre all within 2mo old and look like theyve been beat up over an entire year. Hopefully next gen addresses some of these issues.

Edit: Just for kicks, I added a pic of the 4 devices with all the "protection" on.
Click to expand...

Dude, those look like actual scratches like it was rubbed on concrete or something. I'd say you might not want to use those cases.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom