What seems crazy is that this has already been documented and presented in Apple's own documents about the iPad--no one bothers to read them and then suddenly when someone finds something that was there all along it's some sort of "news" and people start thinking how "crazy" it is that no one knew about this...except that they did.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
14-Year-Old Discovers iPad Smart Cover Magnets Can Shut Off Implanted Defibrillators
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The original story is confusing. Is it the magnets in the iPad or the magnets in the iPad SmartCover? Or Both?
I've never liked those stupid smart covers. They flap around when you carry your iPad, they don't attach to the back when you're using the iPad and they don't provide the same protection or comfort as a proper case. They're a stupid gimmick and Apple should ditch them and create something more useful.
It's not only well-known (well it wasn't to me, but it would be to anyone with a defibrillator), it is by design: A person with a defibrillator can turn it off by holding a magnet to the right place of their body. Fully intentional.
----------
Any magnets (if strong enough). And it's a design feature of the defibrillator: It can be turned off if necessary without putting your finger on the "off" switch which would require first to cut someone's body open, by holding magnets in the right places.
My father didn't know he was diabetic until he almost died from the flu and spent a week in the hospital.That didnt know they had a pacemaker? LOL! It`s like saying diabetic people not knowing what they are eating.
I am more concerned that a 14 year old had nothing better to do and found this out as a result.
They don't make childhoods like they used to...
They don't make childhoods like they used to...
Um the iPad smart covers have a magnet in them? DUHH!!!!
So Samsung is hiring highschool freshmen now?
They kinda have to considering Apple hires kids to make lame comments about their competition.
Doesn't seem confusing at all: "A fourteen-year-old has discovered that the tiny magnets inside the iPad can inadvertently shut off..." and "Apple builds magnets into every iPad it sells for use with..."
Again, this is not about the Smart Covers but about the iPads.Um the iPad smart covers have a magnet in them? DUHH!!!!
They kinda have to considering Apple hires kids to make lame comments about their competition.
My iPad made me sterile!
Seriously. Holy crap. This is potentially a big story if it gets legs. How does Apple recall a gazillion iPads?
This is yellow journalism by MR - the MAGNETS cause the defibrillators to stop - not the iPad.
It's well known that ANYTHING magnetic shuts off a defib.
There is a major error in this article using the terms "pacemaker" and "defibrillators" synonymously. Pacemakers are devices that help control the rhythm of the heart and defibrillators act as those electric paddles to start the heart up again if the heart stops. It sounds from the article like the magnet stops the defibrillator, NOT the pacemaker. Kind of a big mistake if you are trying to save lives.
If those Samsung commercials are to be believed, it looks like Apple is trying to freshen up their image by killing off their current customer base.
Doesn't really seem it's pacemaker related as much as defibrillator related.
Especially since this doesn't have anything to do with the Smart Cover.
So are you suggesting that this information shouldn't be shared. Or better yet - are you insinuating that a 14 year old's science experiment is something to be mocked?
Exactly. Pacemaker is not the same thing as an implanted defibrillator.
Pacemakers are usually smaller than those implanted defibrillators, which can make a distinct difference in the probability of the SmartCover magnets affecting their operation.
I'm not surprised that the teen never won the fair. It's rather common knowledge that magnets can have an adverse affect on medical devices. It's even more apparent to those that actually have a medical device inside their chest. I am, however, surprised that her father, who is supposedly a Medical Doctor, found the "discovery" shocking to the point of presenting the "findings" to ~8000 other Doctors.
It was obviously sarcasm. Apparently jokes about Samsung don't go over very well around here.