Install VPN on the Synology and WebDAV is all you need. Simple and everything you need on the Mac side is built into OSX.
Hi,
Pretty much an amateur when setting up networks etc. so bear with me. I have set up my DS411j and it seems to be working fine in all other respects, however when I point the Time machine Back Up on my iMac to the folder I have set up for it on the NAS it fails, stating that the file system is unsupported and should be AFP. I have followed the instructions to enable 'Apple Talk' on the NAS with the correct folder selected and I have checked and rechecked to make sure I haven't missed anything. Can't see why it fails - any ideas?
Thanks.
Cheers. I just skimmed a setup guide and I think you have to shut down to replace a drive. Not a big deal, I think that's the main difference between something like this and Drobo.
Not all synology NAS support hot-Swapping. Check in the tech specs.
Thanks for this great review. I'm also thinking of getting a NAS soon. How is the web interface with other browsers? I would've using chrome and maybe safari.
Post above has a couple UI screenshots taken in Mac Chrome. It's a very standard-driven UI. Works basically the same in all browsers. I find it to be pretty intuitive once you play around for a bit.
Thanks for this really useful thread!
I've just had a DS411J delivered, loaded it up with 1TB drives and moved my iTunes library to it. It worked really well: I'm not super-techy, and so was pleasantly surprised to find how simple it was to set up.
I am having one issue:
I have the DS411J conected to an AEBS, which then streams (via macbook pro) to my aTV (v1). With larger movies (eg: BR rips compresed to about 3gb) playback starts to hang/stutter about 20 mins in.
I've googled-around and found some other people complaining of this too - that it may be a bug with 3.2 of the DMS or may have somthing to do with disks spinning down after 20 mins (would the do that during streaming? Surely not).
Does anyone hve any insights about how I could fix this?
Hmm, I stream all the time via Plex and I can't say I've had this issue happen. In your energy settings (on the 411j), do you have it set to spin down the hard drives? My setting is enabled, but I've never seen it do this when in use.
Thanks again for starting this thread!
After the crash of my 2 x 4TB JBOD media storage box hanging off an iMac, I've decided to get "serious" and put in a real NAS. The Synology seems to be the clear winner in terms of usability and feature set. My household consists of three Macbook Pros, one iMac, one Macbook, an ATV1 and an ATV2, 4 iPhone 4, and 2 iPads. For the network, its a pair of bridged AEBS units (version 2, not the newest ones).
I'm trying to decide between the DS411 and the DS411+II. From a performance standpoint, my main concern is being able to stream movies either using iTunes (running on the iMac) and Frontrow on the ATV, or hacking one (or both) of the ATVs for use with Firecore.
As far as file sharing, there will be very little demand on the box other than receiving Time Machine backups from each Mac on the network and hosting a very large (600GB and growing) Aperture library that is accessed by a single MBP.
Can anyone tell me if the DS411 is sufficient, or do I need to spend the extra $200 and go with the DS411+II?
I'll be loading the box with 3 x 2TB (5400) and 1 x 1TB (7200) drives from Seagate, because that's what I have already (one of the 2TB drives crashed).
Thansk!
I have a Synology DS1511+. I cannot recommend it highly enough.
Great thread!
I've been comparing Synology D411+II and QNAP 439II+PRO recently.
And I heard that Synology has slow transfer issue when using external USB drive coping NTFS files. Does any body meet this problem?
By the way, I've several Macs at home and want to know which one works best with OSX? My main requirement is iTunes server/streaming movies/photo sharing and etc...
Thanks a lot!
Great thread!
I've been comparing Synology D411+II and QNAP 439II+PRO recently.
And I heard that Synology has slow transfer issue when using external USB drive coping NTFS files. Does any body meet this problem?
By the way, I've several Macs at home and want to know which one works best with OSX? My main requirement is iTunes server/streaming movies/photo sharing and etc...
Thanks a lot!
Can't speak to the others as I haven't dealt with them, but be aware that no NAS can do iTunes video streaming. They all use the same implementation of the "hacked" Airport Extreme AirTunes protocol, and the ATV2 only supports videos via AirVideo.
That's what I'm talking about. External disk better to be ext4 otherwise there's some compatibility issue with it. Sorry I didn't make myself clear about movie streaming. What I meant is just store movies on NAS and use my Mac Mini/Macbook Pro to play movies on NAS via PLEX. Anyway, I think that should be no problem for the NAS to handle it.I have a Syno DS212j and I am very happy with it. However, my main complaint is about USB backup:
- There is a lot of compatibility issue depending on which USB enclosure you are using. For example, I had problems with a Mediasonic 4 bays enclosure and Thermaltake BlacX and BlacX duet enclosures. I am using now Mediasonic USB 3.0 enclosures (even though the syno is USB 2.0) and it seems to work fine.
- I think you're better off if you format your USB disk in ext4.
In addition, be careful about streaming movies: do you really want to stream movies (the syno is the player) ? or to share movies (an external player, a Mac or a WD TV Live for example, is playing the movie from the syno) ? In general, streaming capabilities are not very good in NAS due to CPU limitations, especially if you have 720p or 1080p movies.
Thanks for the heads up. Actually I use PLEX to manage and play my movies like you. And am about to buy the ATV2 for my parent's room.
----------
That's what I'm talking about. External disk better to be ext4 otherwise there's some compatibility issue with it. Sorry I didn't make myself clear about movie streaming. What I meant is just store movies on NAS and use my Mac Mini/Macbook Pro to play movies on NAS via PLEX. Anyway, I think that should be no problem for the NAS to handle it.
Thanks for sharing your experience.