Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

7149041

Cancelled
Sep 3, 2019
506
798
This is ‘cool’ but i’d love to know some actual use cases people are using this for..
My home setup is a Mac Pro with two 24" 4k screens. Sidecar allowed me to emulate this setup when I travel (MBP 15" + iPad Pro 12"), but I feel like Universal Control is less battery draining. Secondary screen is usually Slack, email, calendar - so Universal Control works very well here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: basehead617

adrianlondon

macrumors 603
Nov 28, 2013
5,012
7,527
Switzerland
I have it working between my 2020 MBA and 2013 MBP (see here).

However, as soon as I move the computers more than around 2 metres away from each other, it disconnects. I was thinking to use this instead of screen sharing (VNC) to control my old laptop but it seems it's really designed for controlling two devices placed next to each other.

I suspect it's more for people who have iPads (I don't).
 

gcortesi

macrumors member
Aug 27, 2013
42
32
I know it is still in beta but a general observation with Apple in the last few years is that they barely introduce new features to the public like they are just hidden somewhere in the settings panel (that the average user isn't even looking at) and you have to discover them yourself. Why is there no pop up after installing a new OS version introducing to "what's new" properly with some nice on-boarding screens? I know people that did not even know you could add widgets to your iPhone Home Screen let alone stack them on top of each other. I also wonder how many people actually use the hide your email feature, hidden in the iCloud controls (again, who actually checks those?). I personally had to tell people about it. I also still do not understand how the new multi tasking actually works on the iPad or why they changed it in the first place and I do not care enough to invest my time in finding out
You make some good points. There are many new features tucked away that most never learn about. BTW - the new multitasking feature shows up as three dots at the top of the screen when you open an iPad app. Click them and you can add another app from there. Those dots are always there now when you open an app.
 

telo123

macrumors 6502
Mar 11, 2021
312
398
Anyone know why Command and Shift keys on either internal keyboard of M1 Air or external magic keyboard that I use for clamshell mode, randomly stop working on the iPad via Universal Control?

For example, I'm typing in the middle of a text or composing an email, no keyboard commands that require Command or Shift keys stop working. I can't even capitalize a letter via Shift + letter.

Disconnect and reconnect does not work. I need to restart my Mac to stop it, but it just starts again after some time. Killing universal control via Activity Monitor also doesn't work.

Kinda weird. I've reported it to apple, was wondering if anyone else is seeing this?
 

ignic

macrumors newbie
May 26, 2021
4
1
Spain
Anyone know why Command and Shift keys on either internal keyboard of M1 Air or external magic keyboard that I use for clamshell mode, randomly stop working on the iPad via Universal Control?

For example, I'm typing in the middle of a text or composing an email, no keyboard commands that require Command or Shift keys stop working. I can't even capitalize a letter via Shift + letter.

Disconnect and reconnect does not work. I need to restart my Mac to stop it, but it just starts again after some time. Killing universal control via Activity Monitor also doesn't work.

Kinda weird. I've reported it to apple, was wondering if anyone else is seeing this?

Exactly the same problem happens to me. In my case I use a Mac mini M1 with a Logitech mx keys, and an iPad Pro 11 M1.

It's pretty frustrating not being able to use the modifier keys.
 

DFZD

macrumors 65816
Apr 6, 2012
1,061
2,901
Actually none of the tips worked but what worked was a good ol' "Have you tried it turning off and on again?"

In my case it worked after I turned off the wifi on my iPad and turned it on again.
 

paulmayson

macrumors newbie
Nov 8, 2018
1
0
Fairfield, CT
I have an old, 1st gen 12.9 iPad Pro with an M1 MBA & an external display. I had to reset "Location & Privacy", then plug it in to the Mac and "re-trust" the Mac on the iPad. Then everything showed up and worked.
 

chrisf60647

macrumors regular
Jun 30, 2010
109
86
This scenario is not working for me at this point. Desktop mac pro running over hardwired ehternet. Macbook pro on wifi. UC is available to turn on but is currently not working.
 

eperitus

macrumors member
Jul 3, 2020
56
63
By the way, if people have trouble reconnecting via Universal Control from one Mac to another when the display goes to sleep on one, a workaround is to keep an external keyboard or mouse attached and press a button.

Another workaround is to use a mouse like the Logitech M720 which supports 3 devices/3 bluetooth profiles and switch to that Mac momentarily with that mouse to wake up the screen.

Or just connect via screen sharing.

Would be great though if Universal Control supported waking up the other Mac.
 
Last edited:

eperitus

macrumors member
Jul 3, 2020
56
63
This scenario is not working for me at this point. Desktop mac pro running over hardwired ehternet. Macbook pro on wifi. UC is available to turn on but is currently not working.
I also have a desktop Mac with ethernet, but turn on wifi at the same time. This gives your Mac 2 IPs. I'm not sure how the Mac determines which network interface to use for any given situation (I have 2 default routes for example), but Universal Control works fine.
 
Last edited:

TheRealDrJones

macrumors member
Feb 22, 2019
33
32
Is it sufficient to be logged in with your Apple-ID or do you have to enable iCloud as well?
The Apple manual only says Apple ID is required but the macrumors article says 'sign in with your iCloud account', whatever that means.

It is currently not working for me and I think everything else should be ok. On the Mac I am logged in with my Apple ID but I haven't activated iCloud and would like to keep it that way.
 

mert1

macrumors newbie
Mar 18, 2022
1
1
Universal Control also fails to work when another user is logged in in the background with Fast User Switching. See https://www.reddit.com/r/MacOSBeta/comments/sf3jgz - this is true for the release version as well. I've given feedback to Apple on this - https://www.apple.com/feedback/macos.html
I just signed up to say thank you! I couldn't figure out why it seemingly arbitrarily stopped working for me, logging out of my personal or work user account that's not currently in use fixed it for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eperitus

dsmedic10

macrumors member
Feb 16, 2015
81
47
Just logged in to say that UC doesnt work for me.. Until I read on this thread that multiple accounts will cause a problem. I have two account on my Mac desktop - myself and my wife. I am trying to connect to my iPad.
I logged my wife out of her account, logged myself out, then logged myself back in -- now UC works on my iPad.
Strange bug - - hopefully Apple gets it worked out.

Thanks to

eperitus

for sharing!
 
  • Like
Reactions: eperitus

jOlivier

macrumors newbie
Feb 15, 2022
13
16
Has anyone experienced an issue with placing their iPad underneath their secondary display? I can position it to the left of right of my setup and underneath the laptop, but not underneath my secondary display (it just automatically pops to the left of it).

Anyone have any tips?

 

Le0M

macrumors 6502a
Aug 13, 2020
849
1,200
Followed every troubleshooting step, but still no sign of cursor actually entering iPad's screen....
Uff.. I was looking forward to this so much!
I turned everything on, same network, even turned off private relay - just in case - but still nothing.
Any hint?
 

Le0M

macrumors 6502a
Aug 13, 2020
849
1,200
This is ‘cool’ but i’d love to know some actual use cases people are using this for..

Ehm... having two displays instead of one? Can make tons of things with it, from working, to studying, to do researches, I mean, the list of possibilities is endless.
 

KDLM

macrumors member
Dec 2, 2018
87
54
San Diego
Has anyone experienced an issue with placing their iPad underneath their secondary display? I can position it to the left of right of my setup and underneath the laptop, but not underneath my secondary display (it just automatically pops to the left of it).

Anyone have any tips?

View attachment 1986860
I'm having a very similar problem. I have my MBP and two LG 5K monitors to the right of it. I can place my iPad to the left or right of the displays, and under any of them, but I cannot put it above any of the displays. Based on my results, I would think you could place your iPad under either of your monitors, but not above any of them. Could you try to see if you can place your iPad above your monitors in the arrangement?
 

jOlivier

macrumors newbie
Feb 15, 2022
13
16
I'm having a very similar problem. I have my MBP and two LG 5K monitors to the right of it. I can place my iPad to the left or right of the displays, and under any of them, but I cannot put it above any of the displays. Based on my results, I would think you could place your iPad under either of your monitors, but not above any of them. Could you try to see if you can place your iPad above your monitors in the arrangement?
Ended up making it work by aligning the bottom of the laptop and external monitors. After that, the iPad fit underneath the external monitor. Seems like the system doesn't like it when monitors are slightly off axis.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KDLM

KDLM

macrumors member
Dec 2, 2018
87
54
San Diego
Ended up making it work by aligning the bottom of the laptop and external monitors. After that, the iPad fit underneath the external monitor. Seems like the system doesn't like it when monitors are slightly off axis.
jOlivier - You inspired me to try some more. I added in another of my iPad Pros. With the MBP display, two LG 5K monitors and two M1 iPad Pros, I was able to get one of the iPad Pros on top, almost exactly where I want it. However, it was not easy. It was like playing a video game, or sort of like a Rubik's Cube. I kept moving the iPad Pros around until I got them both on top, and the main one where I wanted it.

This is something that Apple needs to fix. I'm sure they didn't mean to make it so random and imprecise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jOlivier
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.