Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

gothamm

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Nov 18, 2007
844
3
can somebody/has anybody tried play 1080p .mkv files on their mac...say on vlc...


I am talking about 6gb+ files...


if so, how does it handle it? any stuttering?
 
My 2,4 Ghz Core 2 Duo with 4 GB RAM handles this easy... so it won't be a problem with the new arrandales for sure. Fan goes a bit wild though...
 
Well, I can play 13GB mkv's on my 3.5 year old MBP. Perfectly, in VLC and in Plex, and anything that will play MKV's that I've come across.

Does that answer your question?
 
The hardware is there even with the Core 2 Duo CPU. Poor playback is most likely related to

1) The software used for playback
2) The file itself

So to answer your question, the new Core iX CPUs should be able to play 1080p .mkv's with no problem given the two points above check out.
 
this is strange. I have a 2.2 C2d white macbook with the intel x3100, which stutters very noticeably when playing planet earth .mkv 1080p rips. Could it be the inferior integrated graphics? i was under the impression that programs like VLC were all CPU...
 
yes those onboard graphics are quite old. I had trouble playing 1080p with the 4500MHD, so i'd expect performance to be even less with the x3100.
 
can somebody/has anybody tried play 1080p .mkv files on their mac...say on vlc...


I am talking about 6gb+ files...


if so, how does it handle it? any stuttering?

I'm running a 9GB mkv file and no stuttering whatsoever. Runs smooth as butter.
 
yes those onboard graphics are quite old. I had trouble playing 1080p with the 4500MHD, so i'd expect performance to be even less with the x3100.

I thought VLC did not utilize the GFX card.

I know plex utilizes CPU only, and the 1080p certainly runs smoother, albeit still stuttering.
 
Well, my 2.2 ghz santa rosa 3 year old mbp plays them fine, using vlc or plex, with 10 to 14 gig files with optical dts audio out. So arrandale will not struggle.
 
Note that hard drive speed has a factor. If you're using a 4800rpm or maybe a 5400rpm, it will stutter depending on the other components of your computer.
 
VLC sucks. Use PLEX. It can play 1080p MKV perfectly on even my MBA.

+1
although i think(please don't attack me if i'm wrong) the plex project uses a lot of the open source code from vlc. The best thing about plex is it works great for a home theater because it works with the Harmony remote controls
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.