Apple Seeking Stronger Foothold in India Through Financial Incentives for iPhone Manufacturing Plant

[MacRumors]

Apple is seeking financial incentives within India to make it easier to build a new manufacturing plant within the country (via The Economic Times).

The company has asked for incentives specifically from the Department of Revenue and the Department of Electronics and Information Technology in India as a way to offset the high cost of building an entirely new iPhone manufacturing unit in the country.

Throughout the year, Apple struggled with India's local sourcing laws, which requires 30 percent of goods sold by a foreign company to be manufactured or produced within India, a law which also hampered Apple's retail expansion because it creates most of its products in China. Over the summer, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi made it easier for Apple to expand its retail stores in the country by approving a three-year extension on the local sourcing laws because of its single-brand company status selling "cutting-edge technology."

These various extensions will only last for a few years, however, so Apple's seeking of financial incentives for its new manufacturing plant proves its long-term goal to have a consistent presence within India.

"They are doing their due diligence from quite some time. The Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP) will write to both the departments regarding this communication for their views," the official added.

At present, to boost electronic manufacturing in the country, the government provides benefits under Modified Special Incentive Package Scheme (MSIPS). The scheme provides financial incentives to offset disability and attract investments in the electronics hardware segment. It also gives subsidy for investments in Special Economic Zones, among other benefits.

In the spring, Apple CEO Tim Cook visited India to discuss manufacturing and retail opportunities with PM Modi. In terms of retail sales, Apple's Authorized Mobility Resellers program has allowed Apple to skirt the country's restrictive retail presence rules, but still lacks the ability to bring in big sales numbers from India.

In the midst of Apple's struggle to expand in India, a report from Strategy Analytics in August described a drastic percentage dip in iPhone users from 2015 to 2016, with 35 percent fewer iPhone devices sold this year. One reason for its deflating sales in the country, according to Tim Cook, could be the fact that iPhones are too expensive in the country, priced around 31 percent higher than they are in the U.S.

Article Link: Apple Seeking Stronger Foothold in India Through Financial Incentives for iPhone Manufacturing Plant

 

[H2SO4]

Financial incentives………I hope this doesn’t become the Ireland of the East.

 

[OllyW]

Financial incentives………I hope this doesn’t become the Ireland of the East.

They've even got the same colour flag.

 

[H2SO4]

They've even got the same colour flag.

LOL, never even noticed that.

 

[NT1440]

And the next stage of multinational globalism begins. India will soon be what China was 10 years ago, as the Chinese workers start to demand higher wages as the country continues to ascend financially.

What does it say when like clockwork, and all predictions, the assembly firms of the world continue to chase down labor markets that will accept a pittance for wages. Can we admit that without labor controls domestically (regardless of nation) your country's labor force is vulnerable (and therefore more willing to give in concessions while corporate profits are historically high) to outsourcing?

 

[0815]

The US should have a rule like that - for foreign AND domestic companies

 

[HiVolt]

Hah, Apple, the company that's sitting on $200+ BILLION, is asking a poor country for financial incentives, where the vast majority of people live in poverty, so they can build a factory and exploit those people to make iPhones that they won't be able to afford anyway.

That's just gold...

Timmy, give your head a shake... Build a factory if you want, you have the money to do it.

 

[NT1440]

Hah, Apple, the company that's sitting on $200+ BILLION, is asking a poor country for financial incentives, where the vast majority of people live in poverty, so they can build a factory and exploit those people to make iPhones that they won't be able to afford anyway.

That's just gold...

Timmy, give your head a shake... Build a factory if you want, you have the money to do it.

Foxconn, Pegatron, etc. These companies make every electronic product you've ever handled (almost literally). Tech companies contract to the most flexible/least expensive assembly company and those companies chase the lowest wage around the world. Apple is not alone here, but my god they could and should take a stand, but I don't expect them to.

 

[69Mustang]

Hah, Apple, the company that's sitting on $200+ BILLION, is asking a poor country for financial incentives, where the vast majority of people live in poverty, so they can build a factory and exploit those people to make iPhones that they won't be able to afford anyway.

That's just gold...

Timmy, give your head a shake... Build a factory if you want, you have the money to do it.

Apple is not asking for incentives, they are looking to avail themselves of the incentives India offers companies for building manufacturing plants in the country. It's right there in the article. These are the same incentives India offers other companies for building plants in the country.

It's not like Apple is going in and saying "gimme ABC and XYZ incentives and we will build a manufacturing plant in your country". To be honest, it's not like they could if they wanted to do so. In India, Apple isn't in a position to dictate terms. India doesn't need Apple. Apple technically doesn't need India either. But make no mistake, Apple desperately wants India.

 

[Pakaku]

I wonder how that Mac Pro factory in the US is doing.

 

[2010mini]

"Financial incentives"........

Another way of saying bribes???

 

[69Mustang]

I wonder how that Mac Pro factory in the US is doing.

Pictured: Mac Pro factory workers at busy hour.

 

[CB1234]

Apple is not asking for incentives, they are looking to avail themselves of the incentives India offers companies for building manufacturing plants in the country. It's right there in the article. These are the same incentives India offers other companies for building plants in the country.

It's not like Apple is going in and saying "gimme ABC and XYZ incentives and we will build a manufacturing plant in your country". To be honest, it's not like they could if they wanted to do so. In India, Apple isn't in a position to dictate terms. India doesn't need Apple. Apple technically doesn't need India either. But make no mistake, Apple desperately wants India.

Once again my friend, you are a voice of sense and logic amongst a lot of vitriol floating around here....

A lot of people think India is going to Apple with a begging bowl. That's totally not the case. It is more of Apple making the right noises to gain access to the Indian market..

A lot of people complaining about Apple and how it wants to exploit poor labour, are in fact insulting intelligence of hundreds of millions of Indians. Indians are quite business savvy and can hold their own when it comes to negotiating with multinationals. Some of the people posting on here & trying to protect the 'poor indians' should sometimes visit India and understand what the country is all about...

 

[thisisnotmyname]

Economics are not a zero sum game. When manufacturing jobs went to China the USA did not become China economically, other sectors continued to expand and our country continues to have a very high standard of living on a global scale. China has already seen a great deal of flight as well, to Malaysia, then Viet Nam; there's great interest (particularly by the Chinese somewhat ironically) in sub-Saharan Africa now. This movement from China to other labor markets has been going on for over a decade and (despite some turmoil lately with many other causes) you didn't see China collapse - to the contrary they continued to grow greatly (possibly into a bit of a bubble which is now correcting). Chasing labor markets doesn't have to detract from the prior manufacturing centers, instead it can be a kickstart to building critical momentum in these developing nations that then allows them to maintain a higher standard of living across the board when the next market becomes the hot zone.

 

[NT1440]

A lot of people complaining about Apple and how it wants to exploit poor labour, are in fact actually insulting intelligence of hundreds of millions of Indians. Indians are quite business savvy and can hold their own when it comes to negotiating with multinationals. Some of the people posting on here & trying to protect the 'poor indians' should sometimes visit India and understand what the country is all about...

....We've seen this play in China, Indonesia, Mexico, India in the textiles industry, etc. I'm stating that it's no secret that multinationals always actively exploit the ability to pay ludicrously low wages in countries that have developing markets, only to dump and run to the next country as soon as the workers start demanding higher wages/better working conditions. A country with nearly a billion working age people has hundreds of millions still in abject poverty that will sign up to live in "company cities" to support their families. Spare us this nonsense about "business savvy", history shows that these companies will continue the race to the bottom as they have been doing on steroids since globalization has kicked into overdrive.

You're completely ignoring the nearly 100 year history of how multinationals operate around the world. African countries are next up on the list after India as evidenced by the massive infrastructure investments China is making there for their future Foxconn/Pegatron factories being established there.

 

[Wayfarer]

Nice photoshop job. LOL!

 

[Cineplex]

Good for you, Tim. You know what? Just take Apple to India and rent out the space ship campus. Selling iPhones in India and China is clearly more important than developing new Macs. Just go.

 

[adamjackson]

I have a huge respect for the people of India for forcing Apple to invest in this way before allowing them to just come in and start selling.

I'm sure there are a lot of Apple fans there that would like to buy Apple devices but making a large company play-ball and invest in their country really is what India is about. Indians support each other and support businesses ran by their family & friends and fellow citizens.

 

[HiVolt]

I wonder how that Mac Pro factory in the US is doing.

Doing the same exact thing for the past 3 years... Making the same outdated Mac Pro, probably 10 per day... I don't see them selling more than 10 of those per day.

 

[CB1234]

....We've seen this play in China, Indonesia, Mexico, India in the textiles industry, etc. I'm stating that it's no secret that multinationals always actively exploit the ability to pay ludicrously low wages in countries that have developing markets, only to dump and run to the next country as soon as the workers start demanding higher wages/better working conditions. A country with nearly a billion working age people has hundreds of millions still in abject poverty that will sign up to live in "company cities" to support their families. Spare us this nonsense about "business savvy", history shows that these companies will continue the race to the bottom as they have been doing on steroids since globalization has kicked into overdrive.

You're completely ignoring the nearly 100 year history of how multinationals operate around the world. African countries are next up on the list after India as evidenced by the massive infrastructure investments China is making there for their future Foxconn/Pegatron factories being established there.

'Ludicrously low wages' is defined by standards set by western world. The 'ludicrous low wage' as you claim is probably going to be a lot more money these people will make, then they are currently earning.

Have you ever been to China? The progress that country is making in infrastructure is phenomenal!! It puts many western countries to shame. I have been travelling there for over 15 years and the growth in economy, infrastructure and the increase in people's earnings has been absolutely phenomenal and mind boggling.

If by Apple and other multinationals investing in India (or exploiting as you call it) can alleviate India to level where china is at, then my word it will be fantastic for the country.

 

[NT1440]

'Ludicrously low wages' is defined by standards set by western world. The 'ludicrous low wage' as you claim is probably going to be a lot more money these people will make, then they are currently earning.

Have you ever been to China? The progress that country is making in infrastructure is phenomenal!! It puts many western countries to shame. I have been travelling there for over 15 years and the growth in economy, infrastructure and the increase in people's earnings has been absolutely phenomenal and mind boggling.

If by Apple and other multinationals investing in India (or exploiting as you call it) can alleviate India to level where china is at, then my word it will be fantastic for the country.

Short termism. At the very onset yes they are attractive wages, but as the country lifts from poverty and workers demand better wages (as they stagnate) and working conditions these companies pick up and leave....if they aren't involved in human rights abuses against those demanding better.

Same cycle, rinse, repeat.

 

[macfacts]

...

If by Apple and other multinationals investing in India (or exploiting as you call it) can alleviate India to level where china is at, then my word it will be fantastic for the country.

How is it investing when Apple is asking for incentives to build in India. Being able to sell iphones to Indians isn't enough?

 

[Nefilim]

I wonder how that Mac Pro factory in the US is doing.

They are only assembling the Mac Pro, but I share your concerns, other companies failed miserably at the "assembled in US" concept, Motorola/Google comes to mind.